Pfitzy
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Ya think? Maybe 4 losses across 55 games isn't a great indicator, but I'd say a fair bit of silverware is there for the taking...
Subbies 2023!
- Thread starter Pfitzy
- Start date
Ya think? Maybe 4 losses across 55 games isn't a great indicator, but I'd say a fair bit of silverware is there for the taking...
Uzimal1989
Bob McCowan (2)
Be really good to see you play in the finals pfitzy because I hear you are one of the more loyal club people anyone or club could ask for. I have numerous sources who only speak with highly regard and respect for you mate so well done.Division 4
McClean Cup First Grade
Irish, having only lost one game (to us!
Never count Redfield out - round 14 at Redfield College v Irish should be very interesting, particularly as Irish will want to push their 2nd Grade into a top 2 spot to get the club a week off.
Renegades hopefully make it into 5th with Wakehurst looking likely for 6th, but will be a tall order for either club to survive the first week against some quality sides.
At this stage I've got the finals series looking like this:
Week 1 - 12 August
QF A: Rockdale (3) v Wakehurst (6)
QF B: Redfield (4) v Renegades (5)
Week 2 - 19 August
SF A: Irish (1) v Renegades
SF B: Merrylands (2) v Rockdale (W QF A)
Week 3 - Sat 26 Aug Grand Finals
GF: Renegades
Seriously tho think Irish have got this year in the bag. There will be some good finals tho and hopefully we get everyone on the park for a change
The big factor is going to be discipline. Once we get 3 qualified refs from a more qualified pool, and 2 guys on the sideline with full badges, it may affect some clubs more than others.
Grose Cup Second Grade
A note here: it would feel a bit shit if our team got into the finals on the back of forfeits. We haven't won on the field all year, the closest being a 4-try loss to Chatswood in R2. Like a second chocolate bar: I'll eat it, but I'll feel bad about it
Week 1 - 12 August
QF A: Redfield (3) v Renegades (6)
QF B: Irish (4) v Raptors (5)
Week 2 - 19 August
SF A: Merrylands (1) v Irish (W QF B)
SF B: Rockdale (2) v Renegades
Week 3 - Sat 26 Aug Grand Finals
GF: Merrylands (W SF A) v Renegades
TBH I'm less sure about this one - Merrylands have been the team to beat all year, then Irish went and did it. So Redfield and Rockdale will have taken notice of that.
TheBigArvo
Larry Dwyer (12)
I think more early guilty pleas should be on offer. Happy with a longer length for the suspension.
But so often clubs are forced to drag guys into DP only to plead guilty and split hairs on what happened.
Especially with the TV footage these days most charges are pretty cut and dry. So take the pressure off club volunteers and allow them to get it sorted sooner.
I will say certain issues (ref abuse etc) should be heard in person. But a high tackle or a punch? Early guilty plea 4-5 weeks. Case closed.
Pfitzy
Nathan Sharpe (72)
When the player lives out past Penrith, it's a long way for a 15 minute hearing. Even if you beat the charge and associated fine, the petrol and tolls... well...
Our current catchment is about 900sq km I figured out on a rough guide of player addresses.
Bismarck12345
Peter Burge (5)
Interested in the major stories of each div going into finals. Wonder if anyone who is across a division would have a stab at giving their team of the season so far (can’t be just from one team).
As finals near us I’m eager to see the narratives build before we reach the conclusion of the season.
As finals near us I’m eager to see the narratives build before we reach the conclusion of the season.
Eastcoast
Bill Watson (15)
Div 1 Round 12 Preview
Petersham - Colleagues - Another good game. There are no bad games in Div 1 this year. Every team is competitive. Petersham at home will again push Colleagues. Colleagues have the hardest run home with a bye to complicate factors. They will have circled this one as one they cant drop. Colleagues to win it late by 3
Hunters Hill - Blue Mountains. Top of the table clashes dont get much better than this. Prefer not to be at Lapstone in the cold but I expect this to an extremely physical game. Mountains have strike across the park. I reckon a last play penalty will win this game. HH by 2
Mosman - Drummoyne - Drummoyne are building very nicely and despite Mosmans effort to get away from the bottom of the CC, they wont be able to take Kentwell this week. Drummoyne to continue their push for the finals. Reds by 7
Waverley - Forest. Forest have done well this year, but just lack that depth and polish at the end of games. I can see this being close again for another 70 minutes, Waverley are a big team with strong forwards and strike out wide. Expect them to pull away late. Waves by 14. Only issue is are a few of the Waverley boys shooting up to Splendour this week.
Petersham - Colleagues - Another good game. There are no bad games in Div 1 this year. Every team is competitive. Petersham at home will again push Colleagues. Colleagues have the hardest run home with a bye to complicate factors. They will have circled this one as one they cant drop. Colleagues to win it late by 3
Hunters Hill - Blue Mountains. Top of the table clashes dont get much better than this. Prefer not to be at Lapstone in the cold but I expect this to an extremely physical game. Mountains have strike across the park. I reckon a last play penalty will win this game. HH by 2
Mosman - Drummoyne - Drummoyne are building very nicely and despite Mosmans effort to get away from the bottom of the CC, they wont be able to take Kentwell this week. Drummoyne to continue their push for the finals. Reds by 7
Waverley - Forest. Forest have done well this year, but just lack that depth and polish at the end of games. I can see this being close again for another 70 minutes, Waverley are a big team with strong forwards and strike out wide. Expect them to pull away late. Waves by 14. Only issue is are a few of the Waverley boys shooting up to Splendour this week.
Pfitzy
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Div 1 - all games appear to be on except Waverley's Colts - who aren't listed as a forfeit. The game simply doesn't have a kick off time so is a dead letter.
Div 2
BLUNT CUP
Briars forfeit UNSW
Newport forfeit Epping
Div 3
FARRANT CUP
Knox forfeit to HarbourEasts
Iggies forfeit to Beecroft
NICHOLSON CUP
Iggies forfeit to Beecroft
So Iggies only have one game at Ryde Park this week against the 'croft. Wow...
Div 2
BLUNT CUP
Briars forfeit UNSW
Newport forfeit Epping
Div 3
FARRANT CUP
Knox forfeit to HarbourEasts
Iggies forfeit to Beecroft
NICHOLSON CUP
Iggies forfeit to Beecroft
So Iggies only have one game at Ryde Park this week against the 'croft. Wow...
Uzimal1989
Bob McCowan (2)
Quick question for you please now that there’s forfeits in 2nd division in 3rd grade this week does that mean that 2nd grade forfeit as well or does it mean colts forfeit because a few years ago when covid was a thing one a couple of clubs forfeited and the grade above them automatically forfeited as well or is it the grade under
Pfitzy
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Ops Manual deals with this: https://rugby.net.au/ResDetail.asp?id=16980&OrgID=132&menu=637
9. FORFEITS
9.1 If a Club is forced to forfeit a match, it shall be the lowest grade(s) representing that Club, excluding Colts, which shall be forfeited.
9.2 If a club forfeits a grade higher than a grade already played on that day, then at the Board’s discretion, that club may be deemed to have forfeited all grades, excluding colts, previously played on that day. However, any point differential greater than 28-0 in favour of the non-forfeiting club will be preserved.
So Colts isn't considered "higher" or "lower" than other Grades.
Hence, last year Knox Old Boys forfeited everything except Colts for a few rounds, because if you forfeit other grades, it doesn't affect Colts.
Similarly if you forfeit Colts, it doesn't affect Grade.
WoodyWoodsman
Sydney Middleton (9)
The Woodsman loves a challenge and as a keen viewer of Division 2, I will nominate a 1st, 2nd and 3rd XV for Division 2, based on regular first grade players only. Hard to go past the two most dominant teams in Lindfield and UNSW.
| 1 | Jock Wilcox (Lindfield) | Ethan MacMinn (UNSW) | Johan Moll (Hills) |
| 2 | Mitch Antico (Lindfield) | John Sommerville (UNSW) | Anthony Nguyen (Briars) |
| 3 | Dave Davis (UNSW) | Jordy Nikolpoulos (Lindfield) | Tim McAlpine (Epping) |
| 4 | Conan Freeman (Lindfield) | Alasdair Forrest (Epping) | Luke Russo (Hills) |
| 5 | Zac Lomas (Lindfield) | James Benton (Valley) | Matt Alexander (Newport) |
| 6 | Harry Byrnes (Epping) | Will Ng-Fawcett (UNSW) | Danny Richards (Lindfield) |
| 7 | Elliot Cichero (UNSW) | Mick Brinnand (Hills) | Luke Milham (Lindfield) |
| 8 | Andrew Walsh (UNSW) | Tom Booth (Lindfield) | Raymondo Magalogo (Valley) |
| 9 | Sammy Reimer (Lindfield) | Harry Magriplis (UNSW) | Sebastian Allen (Newport) |
| 10 | Sean Grace (Lindfield) Favourite for the Barraclough Medal | Jack Keppel (UNSW) | Matt Brinnand (Hills) |
| 11 | Jono 'The Butcher' Cowley (Lindfield) | Geffrey Marshall (Epping) | Dom Southon (Hills) |
| 12 | Todd Palmer (Epping) | Pat Flaherty (Lindfield) | Nick 'Big Nige' Plunkett (UNSW) |
| 13 | Naibuka Nakavo (UNSW) | Viliami Fine (Briars) | Jake Skrab (Lindfield) |
| 14 | Edmund Tomsana (Epping) | Riley 'The Flying Mullet' Thompson (Lindfield) | Sam Parmentier (Hills) |
| 15 | Matt Garrow (Lindfield) | Nox Levea (UNSW) | Tadgh Van Schowen (Newport) |
Last edited:
Denistone_Dennis
Chris McKivat (8)
Says a lot about the standard of Div 2 this year....
Pfitzy
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Last edited:
HogansHeros
Jim Clark (26)
With Knox in finals contention this is suprising. 3 team comp now...
LRUsoldier
Allen Oxlade (6)
It’s a monster day at Lindfield Oval for anyone wanting a great day of rugby. We are aiming to wrap up a near perfect regular season with 5 wins against the division underdogs Hills Rugby. 1sts , 2nds, Colts and 4ths (against D2) are aiming to complete undefeated seasons.
1st XV - Lindfield win by 25 but I expect the red men to stay in it for a long time.
2nd XV - Lindfield by 1 against a Hills coming off 5 BP wins in a row. Match of the day.
3rd XV - Hills win by 3, though the aim for one team may be to play in the right spirit.
4th XV - Lindfield by 22
Colts - Lindfield by 22 with a comfortable victory
1st XV - Lindfield win by 25 but I expect the red men to stay in it for a long time.
2nd XV - Lindfield by 1 against a Hills coming off 5 BP wins in a row. Match of the day.
3rd XV - Hills win by 3, though the aim for one team may be to play in the right spirit.
4th XV - Lindfield by 22
Colts - Lindfield by 22 with a comfortable victory
Clark Cup Karen
Bob McCowan (2)
No arguments about Tim McAlpine being in this team, I watched the Newport Epping game and if I’m right he broke 4 Newport props over the 80 minutes.
Denistone_Dennis
Chris McKivat (8)
We should name it down to 9th XV so Kurtis Jones can get a run
LRUsoldier
Allen Oxlade (6)
4 wins from 5 against the arch rival Hills today.
In Barraclough, Old Soldier screamed out to a 27-0 lead, only for Hills to come back to 27-20. It was a strange play to finish the game when they took the 3 points even when the ref had called last play.
In Stockdale, and the highly tauted Hills did not look like a side who could challenge. Never in doubt for the blue and white, with Old Soldier 47-12.
In Colts, Old Soldier win 27-0. Young Hills are not a bad side and kept coming all day. A few late tries made it seem more one sided than it was.
In blunt, Hills win a on the last play of the game 24-17. The match was a see-saw and congratulations to Hills.
In 4th Grade, the Old Soldier 40-0 against a Hills team down on cattle.
And so that ends the season. Undefeated minor premiersis in 1s, 2s, 4s and colts. 3s make the finals and will have more to say when we face Hills again later in the year.
In Barraclough, Old Soldier screamed out to a 27-0 lead, only for Hills to come back to 27-20. It was a strange play to finish the game when they took the 3 points even when the ref had called last play.
In Stockdale, and the highly tauted Hills did not look like a side who could challenge. Never in doubt for the blue and white, with Old Soldier 47-12.
In Colts, Old Soldier win 27-0. Young Hills are not a bad side and kept coming all day. A few late tries made it seem more one sided than it was.
In blunt, Hills win a on the last play of the game 24-17. The match was a see-saw and congratulations to Hills.
In 4th Grade, the Old Soldier 40-0 against a Hills team down on cattle.
And so that ends the season. Undefeated minor premiersis in 1s, 2s, 4s and colts. 3s make the finals and will have more to say when we face Hills again later in the year.
Pfitzy
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Didn't you lose a game in 4s? Halligan cup vs colleagues.
Still, bloody impressive session. Well done to all involved
Prodigy
Ron Walden (29)
No thanks. We’ll keep him.
Kurtis is a confidence player. I’m sure he will bounce back.