• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Subbies 2023!

The Ghost of Raelene

Simon Poidevin (60)
The only blokes i know playing league as an adult, were all involved in some sort of development pathway at some point, either playing Harrold Matt, SG Ball or Ron Massey Cup, Not quite making it into the NRL and so going to club land and earning a pretty $500 a game. Not sure if my experience is Unique.
Where as playing Union, most of the blokes playing subbies were never really involved in a development pathway, i guess never having that same exposure to professional sport.
I had a few mates decide to give it ago probably 10 years back and it lasted 1 season. There isn't really a lower standard/social aspect to many of the comps even if you're playing reserve grade. You're getting your head reset button pressed almost every weekend.
 

TheBigArvo

Larry Dwyer (12)
You're not alone in that, which speaks to the effort of your committee to have a thriving club in a higher division. With more teams comes a proportionally higher level of effort to keep the lights on and push ahead, after all.

The point GoR was making: you're in a a rugby area. The eastern fringe of Sydney is more heavily populated with rugby people. so the number and size of the clubs should be proportionally higher. And it is, when you look at the map of Subbies and Premier Clubs.

My club doesn't have the same challenge of Premier Rugby or large Subbies Rugby in the area.

Instead, I've got a dozen rugby league clubs who will pay guys $200 a game or more just to walk onto the field.

I'd say the effort and size of our Committee / Volunteer base to keep 2 teams on the field is proportionally equal to Lindfield's 5+ teams.

(Anecdote: I was out for a walk the other day in my Renegades training shirt, and a young couple were coming the other way. Struck up a conversation as he had a Bunnies training top on, and said he'd heard of us. After urging him to come to training, he asked what the game wage was :confused: "Free beer and pizza - we're amateurs", was my reply).
You have free beer and pizza??? I’m there! Sign me up!
 

Pfitzy

Nathan Sharpe (72)
The only blokes i know playing league as an adult, were all involved in some sort of development pathway at some point, either playing Harrold Matt, SG Ball or Ron Massey Cup, Not quite making it into the NRL and so going to club land and earning a pretty $500 a game. Not sure if my experience is Unique.

And, considering those competitions you name have every NRL franchise AND some of the lesser lights e.g. North Sydney Bears, it is a LOT of talent that doesn't make it into the logjam of pro RL. Remembering they're producing these kids every year, but retirements aren't happening at the same rate.
 

KentwellCup>ShuteShield

Ted Thorn (20)
And big sponsorships at the smaller clubs who don't have a big club base.

Let's also remember Subbies was NOT amateur once upon a time (in living memory), and more than a few players did alright out of it.

It creates an arms race that isn't sustainable in either code when the sponsor decides to walk.
What where the logistics of this in subbies? How did clubs afford to pay players? How much where they getting paid? Was it in every division? Which clubs where the biggest offenders?

I love learing about it a bit of subbies lore.
 

Pfitzy

Nathan Sharpe (72)
1) sponsorships
2) I know of amounts up to $8k + car + job etc
3) not sure about every division but it wasn't just the big clubs
4) again not sure on biggest budgets but it was pretty opaque
 

KentwellCup>ShuteShield

Ted Thorn (20)
Does anybody know the situation in premier rugby with match payments? as far as i know they get very little or only a few get paid.

I find this crazy when I have friends you have played in places in italy and getting 400 euro a week plus rent.
 

Oldsoldier

Stan Wickham (3)
What where the logistics of this in subbies? How did clubs afford to pay players? How much where they getting paid? Was it in every division? Which clubs where the biggest offenders?

I love learing about it a bit of subbies lore.
You’ll be happy to know everybody stopped payments immediately once we went amateur and nobody was caught out in any wrongdoings….
 

Oldsoldier

Stan Wickham (3)
Do tell....I'd love to hear a Lindfield person's perspective on this....
Haven taken over as CC the following year I do know the situation better than most and I don’t think there is much to add beyond what was reported by subbies and the media. all I’ll say is that payments were made to a player without the club’s knowledge to which subbies, probably rightfully so, came down very hard and it’s taken a long time to fully recover.
 

The Ghost of Raelene

Simon Poidevin (60)
Does anybody know the situation in premier rugby with match payments? as far as i know they get very little or only a few get paid.

I find this crazy when I have friends you have played in places in italy and getting 400 euro a week plus rent.
Depends on the player and the club. I know of one club a few years ago that was $250 per game and $400 if it’s a win. This was for a guy that would always be picked in the 1st grade. No idea what happens if you a 2nd grader that gets on and that sort of thing.
 

HogansHeros

Jim Clark (26)
What where the logistics of this in subbies? How did clubs afford to pay players? How much where they getting paid? Was it in every division? Which clubs where the biggest offenders?

I love learing about it a bit of subbies lore.
A lot of Jobs for the boys which included visa sponsorships for our islander friends
 

HogansHeros

Jim Clark (26)
I had a few mates decide to give it ago probably 10 years back and it lasted 1 season. There isn't really a lower standard/social aspect to many of the comps even if you're playing reserve grade. You're getting your head reset button pressed almost every weekend.
I played Rugby Union Juniors, but had a few mates playing C Grade (U19s) Loige after school, so went and had a go. Went straight back to Union after that. Not an enjoyable experience.
 

Heure

Peter Burge (5)
hahahahaha.

has anyone actually been caught since the ruling came in?
Unfortunately the subbies board are too spineless to have a straight back to be able to take their snouts out of the trough to audit clubs / speak to players. Been going on for years and will continue to do so. I won’t point fingers but give you a clue to a certain club that are untouchable Drum*oyne
 

Pfitzy

Nathan Sharpe (72)
Unfortunately the subbies board are too spineless to have a straight back to be able to take their snouts out of the trough to audit clubs / speak to players

1680870586816.jpeg


A few things to unpack here:

1) Applications for the Board are open every year. Look forward to seeing your name up there later this year, champ.

2) I'm assuming, given your statement above, you're unfamiliar with Section 3 of the Operations Manual, which deals with the processes of Amateur Status. Here is a link for you but in short: an investigation requires a complaint concerning an individual or club. Fill your boots, but take note of Section 3.1 especially - and I quote:

Whilst anonymous complaints will NOT be accepted or investigated, a complainant’s confidentiality will be respected if requested.

3) All complaints will be investigated by the Integrity Committee. Easiest way to get it there is via the Executive Director as per the instructions on the handy BREACH OF AMATEUR POLICY COMPLAINT FORM in section 3.7

----------------------------------

You've been posting here 2 months (under this account, anyway), talking nothing but rubbish.

My assessment is that you've got very little to aid integrity of the sport, but I'm happy to be proven wrong.
 
Last edited:
Top