D
daz
Guest
I need to restrain myself a bit because there is a massive diatribe just under the surface waiting to come out.
But I have two points about what Ben said:
1) If we are limited to being able to criticise something that we only have first hand experience with, then the debate process will become redundant and things like political elections may as well be carried out via coin toss. In a rugby context, I am not good enough to be a Wallaby, nor even a bench player in the Wangaratta 4th XV, but I know when a player does something dumb. Just because I am not good enough to even do the dumb stuff does not prevent me from commentating on those that are.
2) As a (nominal) contributor to the salaries of rugby players on ARU top-ups, I reserve the right to praise or criticise as I see fit. That may be done either constructively, or in the heat of emotion, semi-abusively. Depends on my mood. Either way, if you accept the praise, you better be prepared to accept the criticism.
I need a cold shower, so I'll see myself out.
But I have two points about what Ben said:
1) If we are limited to being able to criticise something that we only have first hand experience with, then the debate process will become redundant and things like political elections may as well be carried out via coin toss. In a rugby context, I am not good enough to be a Wallaby, nor even a bench player in the Wangaratta 4th XV, but I know when a player does something dumb. Just because I am not good enough to even do the dumb stuff does not prevent me from commentating on those that are.
2) As a (nominal) contributor to the salaries of rugby players on ARU top-ups, I reserve the right to praise or criticise as I see fit. That may be done either constructively, or in the heat of emotion, semi-abusively. Depends on my mood. Either way, if you accept the praise, you better be prepared to accept the criticism.
I need a cold shower, so I'll see myself out.