Killer
Cyril Towers (30)
Sounds like they have all the credentials to fit right in with Clyne, clarke and north. RA sign them up now.
Rugby News from unexpected places
- Thread starter p.Tah
- Start date
Sounds like they have all the credentials to fit right in with Clyne, clarke and north. RA sign them up now.
Dctarget
Tim Horan (67)
That's seriously impressive you managed to bring that up, 10/10, would tangent again.
Killer
Cyril Towers (30)
Just putting it into perspective for you, a mirror you might say.
It's a bit arrogant to be criticising and laughing at the Romanians after the carry on by the RA clowns last year, which was all highlighted in the Senate enquiry, have a read.
What do you mean by "would tangent again", showing off your engineering speak?
WorkingClassRugger
Michael Lynagh (62)
And now we have another twist in this tale. Apparently Romania have used an ineligible player during this qualification cycle which means they could be docked the points from the game or games he was used. Meaning Spain could in fact be Japan bound.
Omar Comin'
Chilla Wilson (44)
And also that Belgium fielded an ineligible player in their match against Germany. Same guy was originally named to play against Spain as well, but ended up being replaced before the game. It's amateur hour at Rugby Europe!
Question is whether Belgium only get disqualified for the match against Germany or if they get disqualified from the entire qualification tournament. If the latter then Spain would go through too. You'd think it would probably just be for the Germany match, but maybe not if they decide it's unfair for one team to get a forfeit victory, i.e. automatic points, in such a crucial tournament. WR (World Rugby) could use that to justify Lance Armstronging Belgium out of the standings altogether.
Obviously wouldn't make a difference if Romania had been playing the whole time with an ineligible player as well. Only that in addition to Spain qualifying Russia would go through to the playoff against Samoa (presuming they beat Portugal).
Question is whether Belgium only get disqualified for the match against Germany or if they get disqualified from the entire qualification tournament. If the latter then Spain would go through too. You'd think it would probably just be for the Germany match, but maybe not if they decide it's unfair for one team to get a forfeit victory, i.e. automatic points, in such a crucial tournament. WR (World Rugby) could use that to justify Lance Armstronging Belgium out of the standings altogether.
Obviously wouldn't make a difference if Romania had been playing the whole time with an ineligible player as well. Only that in addition to Spain qualifying Russia would go through to the playoff against Samoa (presuming they beat Portugal).
boyo
Mark Ella (57)
Adam Jones: Wales and Lions prop to retire from rugby union
http://www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/43533268
http://www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/43533268
What seems clear out of this is that World Rugby has to take a bigger role overseeing RWC qualification once it gets up to the final stages.
Rugby Europe (and the various other bodies around the world) might be right to manage it when it is every country in the region is playing and almost all of them won't qualify but once it gets down to the business end and there is more at stake there has to be better oversight to avoid future embarrassment like this.
Rugby Europe (and the various other bodies around the world) might be right to manage it when it is every country in the region is playing and almost all of them won't qualify but once it gets down to the business end and there is more at stake there has to be better oversight to avoid future embarrassment like this.
jimmydubs
Dave Cowper (27)
Would it be fair to assume that all these odds and ends have only come to light because of the consequences of qualification? If this is par for the course for Rugby Europe they need a major shakeup, I don't think World Rugby taking a bigger role, I'm thinking more World Rugby kicking some arse so that Rugby Europe can competently do it themselves, all the time, not only for RWC qualifications.
I don't think it will ever be much different. Most of these unions outside of the ones close to RWC qualifying would run with the budget and professionalism of a subbies club.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
T
TOCC
Guest
Belgium, Romania and Spain could all be disqualified for RWC due to fielding ineligible players...
And the Steven Bradbury in all of this could be down to Germany or Russia!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
And the Steven Bradbury in all of this could be down to Germany or Russia!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Tex
Greg Davis (50)
Imagine being a club player from Germany and getting the call up to Japan!?
WorkingClassRugger
Michael Lynagh (62)
WorkingClassRugger
Michael Lynagh (62)
Just read an article on Americas Rugby News and from what they've attained at least one of the Spanish pair is fine but the other is less clear. The Spanish Union seems confident that there is no issue and it hinges on whether the French fulfilled their duty of informing the player that his participation in 2011 essentially locked in his eligibility as the French moved from using their 'A' squad as their next senior squad to their U20s team.
Jesus Christ.
Jesus Christ.
Omar Comin'
Chilla Wilson (44)
I've read that Spain approached WR (World Rugby) to get approval for their player when he was first selected. What if Romania did as well, and both were given the green light incorrectly?
What a nightmare. Maybe they should just have some new set of matches between Romania, Spain and Russia in June.
What a nightmare. Maybe they should just have some new set of matches between Romania, Spain and Russia in June.
That would mean changing the timetable on a whole host of other qualifiers.
The window to correct things with no changes is gone. Spain were already scheduled for a playoff against Portugal on 4th of April.
To only impact that match they'd need to resolve it prior to 2nd of June when the winner of that playoff is scheduled to face Samoa in the first leg of that series.
It's a complete clusterfuck.
Omar Comin'
Chilla Wilson (44)
Good points. Then I guess the worst case scenario is that Romania, Spain and Belgium all get disqualified, Russia qualify and Germany and Portugal playoff to see who gets to be destroyed by Samoa.
Japan vs Russia to open the tournament is pretty sellable, and Russia is at least roughly the same level as Romania and Spain. But there's a big drop off after them so hopefully they don't have their own issues!
That said, Spain might turn out to be fine. The case against Romania seems more cut and dried but who knows, they might have an ace up their sleeve too if it turns out WR (World Rugby) gave them the all clear incorrectly.
Japan vs Russia to open the tournament is pretty sellable, and Russia is at least roughly the same level as Romania and Spain. But there's a big drop off after them so hopefully they don't have their own issues!
That said, Spain might turn out to be fine. The case against Romania seems more cut and dried but who knows, they might have an ace up their sleeve too if it turns out WR (World Rugby) gave them the all clear incorrectly.
What irony if Russia makes the RWC because other countries were cheating.
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
Looking forward to European Rugby appointing respected rugby administrator Vladamir Ruski from the Russian Federation to decide whether Romania, Spain and Portugal should be disqualified
RebelYell
Arch Winning (36)
Can somebody tell me why Portugal are still in the equation? They play in what is seemingly Tier B on the European Rugby Championships. Surely, as the winner of that, they would be the 7th best (non-tier On) team (behind Romania, Russia, Georgia, Spain, Germany & Belgium)....