I think they are referring to everything up until the contact - which I'd agree is true, we do see players charge in at speed and blow people off the ball in very similar ways to what Jac did at a lot of breakdowns. We just rarely see the contact point being the head or neck.I’m getting sick of hearing “you see that 50 times every game” regarding the clean out, because it’s just not true. I’d love someone to show me all the shoulder to head clean outs that are being missed
The Roar pod was talking about this - their guest Charlie Morgan said Lynagh was 1 - 2 m in front, but Russell getting close to 6m in front which was really having a laugh. Really testing the ref - asking permission not permission type stuff.5-10m is a stretch (I think) is there a clip where it's been that bad?
20.2 - A penalty or free-kick is taken from where it is awarded or anywhere behind it on a line through the mark and parallel to the touchlines. When a penalty or free-kick is taken at the wrong place, it must be re-taken.The Roar pod was talking about this - their guest Charlie Morgan said Lynagh was 1 - 2 m in front, but Russell getting close to 6m in front which was really having a laugh. Really testing the ref - asking permission not permission type stuff.
Good question - what's the penalty? Do they give a short arm to the other team? re-take the kick?
I just had to share my odd mental image....I'd just rather argue the miniature of a stupid children's sport that adults get paid to play for some reason, than do any work
I'm waiting for Rassie to use this as a future time wasting tactic20.2 - A penalty or free-kick is taken from where it is awarded or anywhere behind it on a line through the mark and parallel to the touchlines. When a penalty or free-kick is taken at the wrong place, it must be re-taken.
I reckon Rassie will have blokes jumping for the tryline at penalty taps.I'm waiting for Rassie to use this as a future time wasting tactichey Ref, it's infinite re-taken free kicks if we take it in the wrong place right?...
please don't my mental health can't take it.I'm waiting for Rassie to use this as a future time wasting tactichey Ref, it's infinite re-taken free kicks if we take it in the wrong place right?...
As usual with Rassie's shenanigans, just need a ref with big enough balls to use the laws to stop him from taking the piss
I actually thought this also used to be a scrum to the other team but the current Law is usually how it was refereeed20.2 - A penalty or free-kick is taken from where it is awarded or anywhere behind it on a line through the mark and parallel to the touchlines. When a penalty or free-kick is taken at the wrong place, it must be re-taken.
It used to be that any infringement by the kicking team was a scrum. Then they brought in an exception for quick taps taken from the wrong spot (mid-2000s?), then in 2018(?) they just made all penalty kicks from the wrong spot a retake.I actually thought this also used to be a scrum to the other team but the current Law is usually how it was refereeed
Currently this is what happens for incorrectly taken kicks. Eg: a rugby league style tap. (20.11)I actually thought this also used to be a scrum to the other team but the current Law is usually how it was refereeed
Scrum feeds? Bigger hills to die on IMO. If we broadly accept that in every aspect of the game, players will try and rig the moment in favour of their team and push the boundaries of law - then we understand this is going to happen and probably continue to happen even in a crack down. The likely result, to me anyway, will just be more whistle with no long lasting benefit.![]()
"Becoming pointless" - Everyone wants the same law change after the final Lions test - Ruck
A key law in rugby union is being flagrantly ignored – and fans have had enough. The law in question? Scrum feeds. Or more accurately, the complete lack of fair…www.ruck.co.uk
This seems the best place for this? (Happy to move to a more appropriate thread).
Points 1 and 2 seem legit enough - we've all been saying it for ages - no one feeds a scrum straight these days, the caterpillar ruck (while box kicks are a legit strategy) has become a bit of a joke.
However with point 3, I'm not sure they're on the money here. It's not as if the offending player is coming back - and for the really high end, it can be a permanent red I thought.
Seems to be a lot of NH whinge this morning lol