Best schoolboy tens in recent years have been:
Pasitoa (Brumbies Academy now Force)
Sam Walker (Roosters #6)
Gordons (both @ Rebels/Bulldogs)
Campbell Parata (NZ)
Noah Lolesio (Brumbies)
One of them should have been locked in.
Best 10 in Colts last year was Bas Ward. He’s not even in the Academy I don’t think.
Two of them were locked in. COVID gave them a get out clause and they took it.
None of these guys would have got regular time in front of O’Connor (well, I can’t really comment on Walker as I don’t watch league - but wasn’t he always going to league?). Also worth noting that most of them weren’t better players in 2021 than Hegarty was. A couple of them have done nothing to suggest they would be better current options than Creighton. All left/never signed for better opportunity/more money and have had various levels of success at that.
Lucas WAS being given time to develop at 10 but used COVID as an opportunity to take a higher contract. There are various stories about what else may or may not have motivated him - but the fact is that he was being given opportunity to develop as a player and he decided his best option was elsewhere.
Lolesio has done fantastically well at the Brumbies but he wouldn’t have got those chances if he stayed at the Reds. He would’ve been playing mainly Prems. Given Pasitoa was playing behind Lolesio at the Brumbies, I’d assume he would’ve been further back in the pecking order.
Gordon, who looks like he has some good qualities and who I thought looked good last year, hasn’t been so good this year and needs more development from what I’ve seen. No way he would start regularly in front of O’Connor. Remember, he was under contract with the Reds and a guy who wasn’t his agent anymore shopped him anyway and he took the money/opportunity.
From everything I read about Parata he never wanted to do anything but go to NZ.
Over the last two years O’Connor has been the best performer 10 in Australian super rugby and he has the award last year and the test recognition to back that up. Fact is that the Reds have locked down the best domestic 10 in Australian super rugby but the trade off to that is that all the younger guys have sought greener pasture.
It is a bit concerning we are starting this week with a rookie 10. And it’s easy to say the Reds should have done better. But some of the views being expessed here are conveniently overlooking some of the actual fact, the very real impact of COVID and are taking a somewhat niave view of the player contracting/roster management process and the influence of the very high levels of ambition if young pro athletes - in my humble opinion.