Rebels 2017
- Thread starter Highlander35
- Start date
- Status
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
Haha, yeah, it could've gone better.
But all is not lost. In defence, we probably just bled tries due to the weight of possession from too many attacking errors. Our attacking errors came from us going far too laterally and just being easy to pick off.
Now, there's more to it than that but fixing it will be a good start.
But all is not lost. In defence, we probably just bled tries due to the weight of possession from too many attacking errors. Our attacking errors came from us going far too laterally and just being easy to pick off.
Now, there's more to it than that but fixing it will be a good start.
Twoilms
Trevor Allan (34)
You made every imaginable mistake.
In just the first half alone the Rebels kicked the ball out on the full, got held up in an involuntary maul, knocked the ball on, got pinged for holding on, missed three distinctly kickable shots at goal, got pinged for accidental offside, threw the worlds easiest (not hyperbole) intercept try, etc. That's just the first half... i think you have a few more problem's than errors in attack.
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
Thanks.
I'll note that every single thing you've listed was an attacking error, but maybe you have a personal vendetta against summarisation.
WorkingClassRugger
Michael Lynagh (62)
Mate, he isn't wrong. A lot of fundamental errors. These guys are professional footballers. At the very least they should be able to execute the basics. While have been attacking in nature it's still doesn't make them less inexcusable.
Early days but so far in the race to possible extinction the Rebels have thrown down a marker for being it.
I like to watch
David Codey (61)
^^^^^only if there are 15 out injured......
Twoilms
Trevor Allan (34)
My point was that you were being reductive.
This fails to effectively capture the magnitude of the Rebels incompetence.
Scooter
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
There are almost 15 missing :
1 Toby Smith 2 James Hanson 3 Tim Metcher 4 Alex Toolis 5 Dominic Day 6 Sean McMahon 7 Rob Leota 8 Sam Jeffries 9 10 11 Marika Koroibete 12 Sefanaia Naivalu 13 Mitch Inman 14 Dom Shipperley 15 Pama Fou
We have the forward pack covered although no injuries at 8 but have enough injured locks to have 8 injured forwards. We don't have 9 and 10 covered although Stirzaker could have been added to 9 after 15 minutes.
Main problem is guys like Smith, Metcher, Toolis and Fou are all long term. From what I have heard McMahon a number of weeks away too.
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
So you acknowledge we've said the same thing, you're just not happy I wasn't as alarmist as you?
Let's remember - Round 1 2016, Brumbies 52 v Hurricanes 10
Scooter
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
You heard it here first amirite predicting the Rebels to win 2017 Super Rugby competition
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
Haha, fair chat guys. I'm more getting at the fact that one data point in isolation is meaningless.
neilc
Bob Loudon (25)
Yes better to have a belting at the start of the season so that they can get fired up to improve instead of when they are at the business end. I hope that they do improve, I only saw the 2nd half due to kids touch game but was shocked at how many points the Blues were putting on and with such ease. I'm a Blues fan so happy to see them finally back in form but thought that the Rebels would do better. From what I saw I thought Meehan did some good things - his chasing down of that try where he almost saved it, getting across the field against a winger was impressive commitment. Not sure where the actual Rebels wings or fullback were at that point but I thought that he had saved the try at first.
louie
Desmond Connor (43)
What i thought was most alarming from last night was Tony McGahan halftime interview. What he thought was the game plan seemed completely at odds with the players were trying to do. There's always been a bit of chatter that the players and Tony don't see eye to eye. Maybe it's a little deeper then that.
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
I think the ultimately most unsatisfying thing is the Rebels would've really worked on a lot of skills, habits, and game plan stuff in the off-season, and they didn't put much of it on the park. At least not regularly. Ultimately the most disappointing thing is that it's not that what they worked on in the off-season failed, it's that they didn't get to implement much of it due a huge volume of basic errors.
Their drifting D looked a little bit passive and prone to biting on the wrong guy, but the Blues do have a number of electric runners so that'll happen. This is where all the points really came from, that and weight of possession.
I think Meehan has 'spark plug' written all over him. His energy makes him an excellent finisher in certain game contexts. I do however think he's prone to complaining to the ref and his 'tap first' mentality isn't always the right call. Stirzaker was actually good too, pre-head knock.
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
Interesting - what quote are you referring to?
louie
Desmond Connor (43)
He spoke of playing to a controlled structure. Rebels looked to be doing anything but that.
amirite
Chilla Wilson (44)
I think they were reasonably structured TBH. At least in the first half. But, that shouldn't be confused with the structure working.
I think they just were set very flat and weren't good enough to do it. They also didn't really have the go-forward dominance in the middle, partly due to ineffective carries and partly due to going wide too early.
wamberal
Phil Kearns (64)
Maybe the team that played was not good enough to execute the game plan, a lot of changes, maybe some of them were pretty late.
But I have said it before and I will keep saying it. We simply cannot go into games against good opposition with one lineout jumper. This is just madness. If the Rebels want to persist with Timani at lock, they simply have to pick a lineout option at 6. Otherwise their season is doomed, I tell you, doomed!!!
- Status