The Engine Room
Ward Prentice (10)
How is Charlie Brosnan? It did not look good. This MEDIC is surely something the higher powers at the QRU need to look at.
Qld Premier Rugby 2024
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
The Adjudicator
Frank Nicholson (4)
Repeat ref and touchy abuser as well, most games he'll spend more time spraying the touchy than anything else.
Man from snowy river
Stan Wickham (3)
Charlie Brosnon‘s hip was dislocated. It was put back in at the ground and he will be out for 4-6 weeks. Regarding the rugby it was a great day at Brothers. They are going to be good this year. Jonte Connolly and Michael Wood to come back in the next 2 weeks. They also have some quality number 9’s with Isaac Tarabay who’s was outstanding at the back end of last year and Will Cartwright was great on Saturday and then Isiah Christian is back in 6 weeks.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
There's a few options that have no Cricket but you'd need one of them to win and host IMO. Otherwise if the QLD side has the ground available they host it.
Rat Park (Warringah) Tahs trialled there in the pre season.
Forshaw (Southern Districts) Used in the U16,U18s NSW v QLD last year.
Woollhara (Easts) Awful synthetic thing.
TG Milner (Eastwood)
Eric Tweedale (Two Blues)
Concord (West Harbour) Best of the lot. NSW v QLD U18s just gone played there.
Eastwood have been the most likely winners recently amongst the venues but Easts have the most talent as of right now.
Gordon, Norths, Manly, Randwick all Premier Cricket grounds as well.
SouthernX
John Thornett (49)
Yeah I think there’s only one club in Queensland that hosts cricket and that’s GPS rugby.
I was out watching GPS and Brothers yesterday. Brothers just got up, Brothers had about 5 or 6 regular first graders. I don't know why considering they don't play again for 3 weeks. The big issue for me was the amount of penalities. I reckon there was 15 at least for high shots. It was just terrible to watch. I reckon 13 out of the 15 would have been play on last year. Rugby has enough problems as it is and I think this adds to there problems. I love my rugby but it was very difficult to watch yesterday.
LevitatingSocks
Alfred Walker (16)
It's been a bit unclear how it applies to defending pick and goes. There's very little margin for error if the ball carrier is coming in with low body height and his torso is near horizontal.
Ref_Ted
Ward Prentice (10)
GMGs very clear no change for pick n go from last year.
JRugby2
Charlie Fox (21)
This year will no doubt be different to last year but you can make it more enjoyable for yourself by:
1. Reading the GMG (https://australia.rugby/participate/referee/laws) - this goes into depth about the tackle height law trial as well as a myriad of other key focus areas for the referee team. Also remember that this is like week 3(?) for referees who don't have a bi-weekly training to practice at.
2. Probably more importantly than (1) - have patience with the change. There will be shit calls, and there will also perfectly accurate penalty decisions that were play on last year. It's just the way the game has evolved and will continue to evolve. My prediction is that throughout the season we'll see the penalty counts start to drop as players adjust more and referees get more experience with the change.
1. Reading the GMG (https://australia.rugby/participate/referee/laws) - this goes into depth about the tackle height law trial as well as a myriad of other key focus areas for the referee team. Also remember that this is like week 3(?) for referees who don't have a bi-weekly training to practice at.
2. Probably more importantly than (1) - have patience with the change. There will be shit calls, and there will also perfectly accurate penalty decisions that were play on last year. It's just the way the game has evolved and will continue to evolve. My prediction is that throughout the season we'll see the penalty counts start to drop as players adjust more and referees get more experience with the change.
Ref_Ted
Ward Prentice (10)
From the trial games I have done this year games have been starting with a lot of penalties followed by general compliance, only for a few more later in the game likely due to fatigue as everyone has to keep it front of mind (incl. refs) until it becomes second nature.
The really big props with little core strength are the ones who appear to be really struggling. Not even looking to bend at the waist.
Sir Charles
Fred Wood (13)
Appreciate the reasons for the law change, but the stop, start and cards are making it a hard watch.
Ref_Ted
Ward Prentice (10)
Agree, though it should not last long as the players adapt after a couple of rounds.
MoneyBill685
Ted Fahey (11)
Now that trials are done....season 2024 predictions anyone?
Man from snowy river
Stan Wickham (3)
My thoughts for 2024 season.
Bond Uni will be minor premier.
East I think will struggle. Lost a lot of players from last year.
Norths, same as last year.
Souths just lost there 9. Will finish 5/6
Sunnybank will be much better recruited well during the season. Could be a dark horse however they lack depth. Outside the 4
West I think will be good again this year.
Uni will be solid and agin be there or there about. Thomas has move back to Souths. Haven’t seen them play this year.
GPS Again will be solid with great depth.
Brothers again will be strong with there depth
My top 4
Bond
Brothers
Wests
?????
SouthernX
John Thornett (49)
Should have never left.
the hypothetical QPR grand final where we have the uni starters (Tate and Tom) versus the Souths bench warmers (Thomas and HMP)
that’s a great storyline for Stan.
I agree he should never have left. Brothers have 4 prem grade NO.9's in their ranks. It will be interesting to see were he ends up in grade. I would have Tarabay and Cartwright definitely ahead of him and Christian is back in 6 weeks.
warhorse
Alfred Walker (16)
Not sure what you're referring to. Kalani Thomas was a Souths Junior and Colt 1 Premiership winner. He left Souths and went to UQ. I don't understand your reference to Brothers.
MoneyBill685
Ted Fahey (11)
yeah i don't get what brothers 4 halfbacks have to do with Thomas going to Souths
???
weird flex
SouthernX
John Thornett (49)
think his point is about QPR depth and why Kalani Thomas should never left… when he headed over to UQ he was always going to be in the pecking order behind Tate (I believe Scott Gale - also a former reds 9 might of still been involved @ the heavies)
Tate McDermott/Scott Gale combo at UQ probably was the reason why Moses Sorovi left for Wests.
lot of great halfbacks kicking around and only 9 teams in QPR