So TD, what you are saying is that junior clubs and schools should get all the credit for developing players and none should go to the senior clubs they play for?
If that's the case a club like Wests shouldn't get any credit for players like Hugh McMenniman and Richard Brown, Sunnybank couldn't take any credit for Albert Anae or Richard Kingi and East had nothing to do with Aidan Toua or Joel Falkner? All of these players were developed through their school and had played in schoolboy teams before going to their senior clubs.
The other thing is a lot of Premier Clubs are quite separate to their Junior Clubs and don't have any real links to the players they develop apart from playing at the same home ground.
Players play for different clubs for a number of reasons and saying teams only win because they have "stacked rosters" of players they didn't develop is just an excuse that under performing clubs use.
If that's the case a club like Wests shouldn't get any credit for players like Hugh McMenniman and Richard Brown, Sunnybank couldn't take any credit for Albert Anae or Richard Kingi and East had nothing to do with Aidan Toua or Joel Falkner? All of these players were developed through their school and had played in schoolboy teams before going to their senior clubs.
The other thing is a lot of Premier Clubs are quite separate to their Junior Clubs and don't have any real links to the players they develop apart from playing at the same home ground.
Players play for different clubs for a number of reasons and saying teams only win because they have "stacked rosters" of players they didn't develop is just an excuse that under performing clubs use.