NSW AAGPS 2025 (banter and commentary)

[The Chairman]

Did you watch the Scots Newington game? Sinclair didn't play?

Who was the Scots 10?

 

[Maul of Duty]

Good luck to all the lads this weekend in both the games and higher honours.

 

[Srgnt Short Ball]

I think Lavercombe would be in but if Osborne in yr 12 he may get the spot over Bloomfield (yr11) if that is the way that they select

They do tend to give the nod to yr12s. Osbourne is definitely deserving

 

[The Chairman]

Shore

1. Jarrett
2. Baxter
3. Green
4. Shadforth
5. Frape
6. Squire
7. Leahy
8. Stock
9. Greig
10. Ritchie
11. Hockey
12. Robertson
13. Francis (c)
14. Bremner
15. Wendt

 

[Newingtonga15]

Final GPS 1s prediction from the seargent:

1. Tancred (I)
2. Smith (K)
3. Osbourne (I)
4. Fonua (K)
5. Muir (N)
6. Taumoepeau (J)
7. Dempsey (I)
8. Lemoto (S)
9. Grover (I)
10. Garling (I)
11. Roberts- Lintmeijer (N)
12. Gough (J)
13. O'Conner (J)
14. Folkes (I)
15. Callaghan (E)

No Callum Grantham (N) at 15 should be considered a criminal offence of the highest nature.

 

[The Chairman]

No Callum Grantham (N) at 15 should be considered a criminal offence of the highest nature.

League commitments?

 

[Backintheolddays]

I like him as a kid and player, know him from the junior club rugby days, but surprised at the ongoing selection of Gough. I know he was in last year so would be expected this year but, against two fairly inoffensive Kings backlines last year and this, I have not seen him do much at all to warrant unanimous selection. Maybe they're his bogey team and he puts on a show against others? Shame Risati and Bass unavailable - could have been a pretty special backline this year (albeit nearly all leaguies across Bass, Makasini, Callaghan, Grantham, Risati, Large x2). Blow you apart anywhere across the park.

 

[Maul of Duty]

They do tend to give the nod to yr12s. Osbourne is definitely deserving

Yes he has been very consistent for a long time now

 

[Jockey181]

Any joeys 3rd xv team?

 

[Foresight]

My Final Predictions for the GPS First XV:

1. Lavercombe (K)
2. Smith (K)
3. Bloomfield (K)
4. Fonua (K)
5. Muir (N)
6. Taumoepeau (J)
7. Simmons (N) - Dempsey (I)
8. Lemoto (S)
9. Grover (I)
10. Callaghan (E) - Taylor (K) - Antielea-Tsioussis (N)
11. Folkes (I)
12. Gough (J)
13. O'Conner (J) - Sloane (N) - Scarr (I)
14. Roberts- Lintmeijer (N)
15. Grantham (N) - Callaghan (E)

I believe every position is pretty much cemented, bit of toss up between 10, 13 and 15. I have put Simmons in but I believe Dempsey is electric and may be fundamentally better than him, will be interesting to see selections and games this weekend.

Thoughts, would be suprised if I missed any.

Regards Scrummie

How do selectors choose what’s the process ?

 

[Where's the beef]

I like him as a kid and player, know him from the junior club rugby days, but surprised at the ongoing selection of Gough. I know he was in last year so would be expected this year but, against two fairly inoffensive Kings backlines last year and this, I have not seen him do much at all to warrant unanimous selection. Maybe they're his bogey team and he puts on a show against others? Shame Risati and Bass unavailable - could have been a pretty special backline this year (albeit nearly all leaguies across Bass, Makasini, Callaghan, Grantham, Risati, Large x2). Blow you apart anywhere across the park.

I would agree. Hist last year was far better than this year. More incisive.

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

 

[Srgnt Short Ball]

No Callum Grantham (N) at 15 should be considered a criminal offence of the highest nature.

high calibre rugby player no doubt. But the explosiveness of Callaghan would just add constant attacking danger in a strong GPS backline. He's played unbelievably this season with a less than ideal supporting cast...

 

[Jakeburner65]

View attachment 22501
View attachment 22502
View attachment 22503

Full strength good to see. It’s payback time for Round 1 at Home. Who wouldn’t back them?

 

[Jakeburner65]

My Final Predictions for the GPS First XV:

1. Lavercombe (K)
2. Smith (K)
3. Bloomfield (K)
4. Fonua (K)
5. Muir (N)
6. Taumoepeau (J)
7. Simmons (N) - Dempsey (I)
8. Lemoto (S)
9. Grover (I)
10. Callaghan (E) - Taylor (K) - Antielea-Tsioussis (N)
11. Folkes (I)
12. Gough (J)
13. O'Conner (J) - Sloane (N) - Scarr (I)
14. Roberts- Lintmeijer (N)
15. Grantham (N) - Callaghan (E)

I believe every position is pretty much cemented, bit of toss up between 10, 13 and 15. I have put Simmons in but I believe Dempsey is electric and may be fundamentally better than him, will be interesting to see selections and games this weekend.

Thoughts, would be suprised if I missed any.

Regards Scrummie

Kings much?

 

[Joker]

It’s Friday. Is there a Joeys line up out there?

 

[PBear]

It’s Friday. Is there a Joeys line up out there?

Joeys v Shore

1st XV
Whittaker
Boon
Quinn
Stuckey
Dooley
Garcia-Wood
Ghattas
Taumoepeau
Ryan
Hannon
Dunn
Gough
O'Connor
Minto
Palmasani

2nd XV
Luce
Geach
Chan
Chrara
Benson
Playford
McInerney
Jones
Wallace
Fogarty
Short
Seve
Bourne
Circosta
Troy

3rd XV
Hicks
Hopkins
Byron
Campbell
Brown
Short
Tarrant
Raper
Snell
Bayada
O'Hara
Maunsell
Cornish
Foy
Boyd

 

[PBear]

@Joker do you have any records on how many Champion teams in history (ie undefeated teams) in 1st's 2nd's 3rd's ?

 

[The Cleaner]

I have been on this forum for quite a while now, and I have had enough. The tireless subtle digs at scots have gotten out of hand, especially from the people who are supposed to be the so called "moderators". Now I know, we all love a little banter towards the boys of the east. However, I do also like to ask the question on why particularly the boys in Bellevue hill? Is it because they have castle? In that case I suggest people start making comments about the architecture of st Josephs, direct representation from a medieval castle. Kings, a school with so much land, they have their own post code. Riverview, a place where some students take their own boats to school. Newington and Shore, constantly renovating their school to have state of the art facilities. All I am saying is, it's not just the boys on the hill with their " Handbags" and I hope this is considered when making comments about them.

Could not agree more. It has been going on for years. If it is directed at other schools it is considered Too far, but when directed at SCOTS it is titled 'banter'.

JOKER1 & FUNNY GUY - Perhaps consider changing your names if you do not find the post funny #banter #lightenup

 

[The Cleaner]

My Final Predictions for the GPS First XV:

1. Lavercombe (K)
2. Smith (K)
3. Bloomfield (K)
4. Fonua (K)
5. Muir (N)
6. Taumoepeau (J)
7. Simmons (N) - Dempsey (I)
8. Lemoto (S)
9. Grover (I)
10. Callaghan (E) - Taylor (K) - Antielea-Tsioussis (N)
11. Folkes (I)
12. Gough (J)
13. O'Conner (J) - Sloane (N) - Scarr (I)
14. Roberts- Lintmeijer (N)
15. Grantham (N) - Callaghan (E)

I believe every position is pretty much cemented, bit of toss up between 10, 13 and 15. I have put Simmons in but I believe Dempsey is electric and may be fundamentally better than him, will be interesting to see selections and games this weekend.

Thoughts, would be suprised if I missed any.

Regards Scrummie

As much as I like seeing that you have picked the 3 front rowers from Kings to play together in one team. I don't think its a good thing, not good for their "individual performance"? I would like to see them split up. I would like to see how they play with other players, other front rowers. I would like to see #1 & #3 split up. Its good for their individual game in my opinion. Kings front rowers are comfortable playing next to each other. I want to see how they perform with either a different TH or LH. Its good to win, but I'm sure the coaches will be more interested in seeing individual performance and how play/fit in a different team with new players. Just my 1 cent worth.