Melbourne Rebels Players - where are they going?

[Wilson]

Given that list of 11 names I wouldn't be too confident going to the tahs would have you in a much safer position or better position to show your skills for plenty of those guys. It doesn't look so much like a targeted list to build out a squad as much as the tahs trying to grab anyone and everyone available and fit them into he squad however works out. I'd think there might be much more room to get gametime at hooker and loosehead prop at the Brumbies, or winger and fullback at the Force for example.

Either way, I don't think any of them need to make a call right now, particularly if RA is restricting things to just the tahs offer right now (not in a conspiratorial way, just in terms of salary cap and squad space). Those spots aren't filling up quickly, they have their contracts confirmed and it's a fair way out until even pre-season starts, particularly with the tahs not playing any off season rugby. Their best bet is by and large to wait and see - if the tahs are really getting their shit together, if they can open up more of an offer at the Reds/Force/Brumbies, if they can negotiate a better deal around relocation or if they can get in good interest from overseas.

 

[Tex]

as i was told by someone inside the Rebels and confirmed now several times, the Tahs had a wish list of 11, 7 (at that stage) had refused point blank, one was a yes (Kelleway) 3 others were considering. that roughly aligns with the above.

Point blank refusal is interesting. With respect, is it accurate or hyperbole? I ask because some of the proposed explanations go into Sydney property prices (lol, everything in this country somehow loops back...) and cost of living, competition for places etc etc. But a blanket refusal is pretty instinctive.

 

[KevinO]

I'm pretty sympathetic to LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto).

His not the only one with young kids either, Tupou, Gibbon and Lourwens all do as well.

 

[Strewthcobber]

Maybe they can find common ground with Dan McKellar who just moved back with his family after settling in Leicester?

 

[swingpass]

Tex i was told "refused to consider point blank", possibly hyperbole, but the impression i got was this was a response to RA, rather than a considered position. with time and McKellar's appointment, some may have reconsidered. ps i wasn't told who the11 were, except for Kelleway who was already common knowledge.

 

[Tomthumb]

maybe the Reds don't see a spot for him in the roster

Because there isn’t

 

[Adam84]

This is where RA are probably struggling with the issue.

They are obliged to pay the salaries but can't force players where to go, or force clubs to take on a salary under their salary cap.

I'm sure there's a few discussions going on how to best manage these things. If the rumors are true that a large chunk want to go to the Reds, then I'm sure the Reds are asking for more money or salary cap dispensation. Which doesn't help the competition or financial situation in the short/longer term.

 

[dru]

I thought I read somewhere that RA were asking the clubs to take on 50% of the salaries. Given that financially, Waratahs & Brumbies seem to actually be RA, and Force is covered by a billionare it sort of singles out the Reds as contributing.

I don't see any reason that the Reds should feel obliged to take on additional players without full funding from RA. It's also pretty shite for players building through the Reds squad who were getting close.

 

[KOB1987]

I'm pretty sympathetic to LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto).

I’m also a bit sympathetic to his position. However, he moved to Melbourne. Yes, it was probably acceptance of a job offer to get back in Australia, and then he hoped to return to Brisbane. But, he would have at least considered the possibility he would be in Melbourne for more than a year. It’s like any other employment, if your employer goes bust you need to go where the best job offer is.

 

[stillmissit]

"Agents for 11 players are holding out for more money to play in Sydney" isn't quite as catchy a headline as what they went with is it?

Is that true Strewth? Never heard this..

 

[Strewthcobber]

Is anything true? You've never heard of a player's agent leaking to compliant journos to try and drive a higher price for their client?

 

[stillmissit]

To be fair, is Liverpool even in the Waratahs catchment? Or is that Brumbies territory now?

In my day Players in Western Sydney were getting some offers from Brumbies but only good colts were being grabbed by Syd Uni and Randwick.

 

[stillmissit]

True-ish in keeping with your thinking Strewth, I stupidly assumed you had facts.

 

[Reds Rick]

He has a guaranteed contract with RA. Will get paid at least the same for next year no matter what he does.

Maybe he's holding out for a longer contract or similar, or maybe the Reds don't see a spot for him in the roster

The way it was worded on the pod by Atko was that the Reds are very much keen to have him

 

[Strewthcobber]

Facts? On a rugby forum?

 

[stillmissit]

I must have the old-timers problem.

 

[Mr Pilfer]

Force
Pone (linked)
Proctor
Vaihu
Palu
HJH (Harry Johnson-Holmes) (Harry Johnson-Holmes) (linked from Waratahs)
Louwrens (possibly)

Would be great if the force could pick up those 2 tightheads after losing Medrano. Would make a good front row with Robertson and Paenga-Amosa. Don’t need louwrens with 3 half backs already and the others would be ok

 

[Rebel man]

Remember when we had the drama that we couldn’t even mandate where the Tahs boys played Shute shield

 

[liquor box]

I hope most of them go to the Force, I really think that RA need to ensure that the Force are a success.

NSW will eventually come good due to their clubland. I worry the Force will not get success without lots of money and buying in good players developed elsewhere.

 

[Proud Pig]

I actually hope for the good of the game in Australia they go overseas. Australian Rugby cannot keep paying all these players. Only one team, the Reds, are financially sustainable. The other three teams are either running at a serious loss and as such a drain on RA coffers or are being propped up by a sugar daddy willing to pour money into the club for now. We need to lower the salaries in Australia not increase them which is what will need to happen to get players to move to the Tahs given Sydney's Eastern suburbs is the most expensive place to live in the country. Let the Wallabies be selected from players plying their trade anywhere and accept the financial realities of Rugby in Australia.