Proud Pig
Tom Lawton (22)
I agree it is a bit of a juggling act but it is no point developing a game plan based around having a dominant scrum and set piece unless you have the players to execute it. The game plan has to suit the players available. There are infinite game plan combinations there are not infinite suitable and available player combinations. Obviously you can't just select the best player in each position and then structure a game plan around them. You could end up with no one in the side that can kick the ball to save their life. You need to select the best combination of players and then build the game plan around them.
As to whether form is Super Rugby form or previous Test form, the more important consideration is recent form. Is anyone seriously arguing that the Wallabies squad should not have been dominated this year by Brumbies and Reds players, except Dingo of course. They were the players with recent form instead players were selected on past performances like McCabe and the complete Waratahs squad. Picking form players does not preclude you from picking players from the weaker Super Rugby teams but the top super sides as a general rule should have greater representation than the weaker sides.
As to whether form is Super Rugby form or previous Test form, the more important consideration is recent form. Is anyone seriously arguing that the Wallabies squad should not have been dominated this year by Brumbies and Reds players, except Dingo of course. They were the players with recent form instead players were selected on past performances like McCabe and the complete Waratahs squad. Picking form players does not preclude you from picking players from the weaker Super Rugby teams but the top super sides as a general rule should have greater representation than the weaker sides.