Brumbies vs Reds - Saturday 22 February 2014.
- Thread starter mudskipper
- Start date
- Status
T
tranquility
Guest
It's going to be a good one, I can feel it...
emuarse
Chilla Wilson (44)
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
I thought it was a good subtle gesture that may not be picked up by those sensitive chaps from the capital
en_force_er
Geoff Shaw (53)
We're talking breaking out of the scrum probably a second or less quicker. If that's really the rational I'd put giant question marks over it, even at an elite level.
and the difference of scrumming up against 2 people at TH as opposed to 1 at LH. Its a fairly common approach to prop selection.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
So do the Wallabies
en_force_er
Geoff Shaw (53)
I presumed you were talking about the fact they can break out quicker because there's a shoulder free.
The reason I disagree with the less effort at LH V TH approach is because the amount of energy used is not accurately measured by force against you, but rather the force you're exerting.
For example, if I whack 100kg on a bench press and move it really really fast I'm using the same amount of energy as when I bench 120kg slowly. No prop is going to use less energy based on the force against him IMO.
I've played all over the front row (though, not at elite level) and I just can't give you a quantifiable difference in effort exerted in the scrum.
But I guess I'm not an elite coach and this is just my opinion. I also don't think I explained it very well haha.
T
tranquility
Guest
Slipper is a LHP, who can play TH. Pretty simple.
It is also pretty clear, that a tighthead has a larger role to play in all scrums that the disruptive nature of the LH. Doesn't the short story go that a TH creates the foundation of a scrum, and a LH try's his best to make the opposition ball as disrupted as possible?
It is also pretty clear, that a tighthead has a larger role to play in all scrums that the disruptive nature of the LH. Doesn't the short story go that a TH creates the foundation of a scrum, and a LH try's his best to make the opposition ball as disrupted as possible?
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Yep.........
He's been a TH at the Reds until now.........
So it will be interesting to see how the Reds front row goes with him and Holmes now swapping sides after all this time..........
T
tranquility
Guest
Sorry Slim, not true.
Holmesy has been playing tighthead and loosehead for the Red for the past two seasons. Slipper, was picked for the Wobs playing LH for us. By no means is this a new combination.
Whilst I think everyone acknowledges that Slipper and Holmes have played 1 and 3 for the Reds previously, they were selected the opposite way around in every game I can find for 2013.
Purce
Dave Cowper (27)
Pretty excited about this match. As a few have alluded to it could be ruled by the ref and perhaps a "trench warfare" type aussie derby. If it opens up a bit the selection of Smith at 13 and Toua at 15 could be crucial (would have liked to see CFS at 13). The acceleration, speed and all round rugby nouse of Toua could see him get on the outside of Smith a bit. He's a good defender but there is no substitute for out and out speed. Will be an interesting match up between these two backlines.... plenty of talent there. Piggies to bash the hell out of each other hopefully.
I want the Reds to get up but think the Ponies will get the W tomorrow night.
I want the Reds to get up but think the Ponies will get the W tomorrow night.
- Status