• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Brumbies 2018

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tigs Man

Allen Oxlade (6)
Some people on the Tigers forum are saying that Lachlan McCaffrey has signed a contract with the Brumbies.
 

Brumby Runner

Jason Little (69)
Was previously with the Brumbies on an extended playing contract. Plays No 8 and had some game time in Super Rugby iirc.
 

Brumby Runner

Jason Little (69)
Yeah - that's right BJ. I'd have preferred Smiler to stay on for another year or two. He had pretty much locked down the No 8 spot this year, and with Fardy's departure could have had the choice of 6 or 8.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mst

upthereds#!

Peter Johnson (47)
If Smiler and Alcock are on 1 yr Japanese deals then the Brumbies could use them, again, however if on 2 yr deals (non flexible) then the Brumbies will need another big flanker and a backup 7 / pocock combo.

I imagine they are looking VERY closely at Force and Rebels players because that's a couple holes that they could fill from there. Timani & Fainga'a or a RHP & Hardwick
...Hardcock has a ring to it.
 

amirite

Chilla Wilson (44)
If Smiler and Alcock are on 1 yr Japanese deals then the Brumbies could use them, again, however if on 2 yr deals (non flexible) then the Brumbies will need another big flanker and a backup 7 / pocock combo.

I imagine they are looking VERY closely at Force and Rebels players because that's a couple holes that they could fill from there. Timani & Fainga'a or a RHP & Hardwick
.Hardcock has a ring to it.

Is McCalman not still an option? He's got "no-frills Brumby" written all over him.

I think next year will be a year too soon for Valetini, but if he goes well in the NRC you could look at Fakaosilea (raw but he's got something). You could also play Poey at 8 and Cusack at 7 (there's potential there) or even back Hyne in as a Fardy type 6.
 

upthereds#!

Peter Johnson (47)
Is McCalman not still an option? He's got "no-frills Brumby" written all over him.

I think next year will be a year too soon for Valetini, but if he goes well in the NRC you could look at Fakaosilea (raw but he's got something). You could also play Poey at 8 and Cusack at 7 (there's potential there) or even back Hyne in as a Fardy type 6.


I'm sure he is but a while ago I read he was keen to go home to NSW so just a thought.

Cusack, Hyne, Poey, Valetini, fakasolia and mccaffrey now. I imagine they will try and pick up 1 more experienced/quality player. Hyne is ok, Fakasolia is ok, Cusack is ok, but Ok won't help them defend their Aus conference win.

In my mind I see it like this, so if I was list manager at the Brumbies, I would say losing Fardy, such a key and outstanding player, requires to make an effort to get someone who is as good as we can get that's potentially available. Priority signing. They got Mccaffrey which I would put on par with Smiler, but if they want to effectively replace Fardy, they will need to do better then promote from within.

6/8s.
Tier 1 Mccalman & Timani (Fardy)
Tier 2 RHP Mccaffrey Naisarani (Smiler)
Tier 3 Valetini fakasolia hyne Cottrell Stander (Butler)
Tier 4 Leota Fox Sinclair

With the force sadly looking most likely to go, they the highest number of quality 6/8s to be made available
 

amirite

Chilla Wilson (44)
I'm sure he is but a while ago I read he was keen to go home to NSW so just a thought.

Cusack, Hyne, Poey, Valetini, fakasolia and mccaffrey now. I imagine they will try and pick up 1 more experienced/quality player. Hyne is ok, Fakasolia is ok, Cusack is ok, but Ok won't help them defend their Aus conference win.

In my mind I see it like this, so if I was list manager at the Brumbies, I would say losing Fardy, such a key and outstanding player, requires to make an effort to get someone who is as good as we can get that's potentially available. Priority signing. They got Mccaffrey which I would put on par with Smiler, but if they want to effectively replace Fardy, they will need to do better then promote from within.

6/8s.
Tier 1 Mccalman & Timani (Fardy)
Tier 2 RHP Mccaffrey Naisarani (Smiler)
Tier 3 Valetini fakasolia hyne Cottrell Stander (Butler)
Tier 4 Leota Fox Sinclair

With the force sadly looking most likely to go, they the highest number of quality 6/8s to be made available

True. Could do worse than picking up Tui (flanker Tui) from the Reds for the Fardy role.

I'm not sure if there's a limit on the time he can spend at a single Super Rugby franchise (as an international). Either way, he seems surplus to their requirements.
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/rug...touas-super-rugby-future-20170711-gx8r0q.html

The ACT Brumbies are hopeful they can strike a deal with the ARU to keep Aidan Toua at the club next year as they prepare to play without the speedy back for the first time in two years.

Toua has been ruled out of the rest of the season after injuring his ankle last week, and it is understood he has signed a deal to play in the Japan Top League at the end of the Super Rugby campaign.

No no no no no no no no no.........


However, the ARU is taking a tough stance on players doubling up on contracts in a bid to stem the flow of talent leaving Australia.
Yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes.........
 

amirite

Chilla Wilson (44)
Whilst it's very frustrating to see the Campbell Magnays, Jack Debrezcinis, and Aiden Touas go the Japanese route, if you let fringe starters sign these contracts then you're setting a bad precedent.
 

Brumby Runner

Jason Little (69)
I don't think the back row is going to present too many problems for the Brumbies next year. The return of Pocock is a very big plus to start with. Fardy will be a loss, and so will be Smiler. Jarrad Butler has been a very good club man, but will be more easily replaced with the talent avail;able. I believe Cusack will surpass Butler in time, maybe by next year. So one more back rower looks to be what's needed, and while McCaffrey is coming in, probably, I think there will be better available on the market if either of the Rebels or Force are cut.

The bigger problem is in the backs. Hopefully CL will fill a big hole at 10/12, but the current situation with injuries to Godwin and Toua has shown that depth is a problem in the backline. Banks looks the goods at 15, but who's the backup? Wing will be Henry, Taliauli, Muirhead, Dargaville and ????. No 13 is Kuridrani first up but then? Smith is adequate as a late game replacement but doesn't light the game up. JJH and Jooste seem to round out the talent. Both have issues and are quite young, so still a lot of development required to be starting Super Rugby players. Hopefully, there are some moves afoot to bolster the ranks of backline players for next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mst
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top