I am happy to be corrected if I have provided poor examples, my point was more about where they are being played rather than listed.
The comments above do go some way to highlight my point that we have have a lot of utility backs, especially at for the 13 and winger roles, but we are still very light on in the specialist 10, 12 to a degree, and 15. I personally can see JJH working at 12, with Dargaville and co as alternate options, but 10 could be an issue with Jooste yet to show much in part due to his injury run of late, which is another concern, and with Christian going to Japan maybe we should be half expecting the usual injury curse.
15 is a real and urgent issue IMHO. As for kicking if Christian goes down, its either Jooste or we may see Mann-Rae getting extended game time as he can kick.
It is time that the Brumbies started to use their next gen and move in to a new era. In the past the next gen were signed to bolster the roster behind experienced incumbents but now they are the best options we have as players depart. In the past we have had the luxury of blooding player slowly and making them compete for spots but that is passing to a degree as they have levelled out performance wise (EG: the locks all now bring something without any drawbacks and the newer stocks like Powell adds new elements).
Its been interesting to watch Burnies player management change both in game and off field and its still evolving. The way he has used the beach over the past two seasons has been like chalk and cheese, reluctant to use the beach for the first half of last year, now he has learned the merits and benefits of using it. It also goes to giving some players like JJH and Staniforth a shot, and other being rotated in like Makin and Abel.
We have learned that recruiting players like a Toua can be problematic. He was suspect at Super Rugby level for the Reds, and we now see that hasn't really changed.
To a degree I get the signing of Saia, but IMHO its just tying up a spot for an up and coming Hooker, especially being a 1 year deal. It could mean that come 2018, we may lose both Saia and I am not sure where Mann-Rae will be placed - I think he will be fine but he will be getting towards more of a bench option. So its lost development time.
What does Godwin bring apart from recent poor form and bad habits? An honest assessment will say he has potential but its a wait and see and will take a season or so. Can he be re-coached, find form and will he fit in? With his injury history will he be like Andrew Smith has been for us this year?
On the coaching side of things the same questions and approximate time frames you would have with a rookie apply equally to bringing in "üsed" players, except its easier to mould a rookie rather than change ingrained habits etc, and up skill them when they haven't been able to develop the skills after many years. (EG: recent discussions about Toua's abilities or lack of them.)
We need to take a leaf out of the Kiwi book and give players a shot and develop more. If they don't make it or are not good enough, or a better option appears, then we need to make the hard decisions. Kane Hames is the perfect example; after 20 caps in a Super Rugby title winning side last year he was cut.
Watching the Rebels game last night, I can help but wonder how a Mike Harris would go at 15 for us; solid, good kicking in hand and place, good running and option taking, reliable and ok in defence. Also he is really good cover. I also like the K. Hunt at 15 suggestion.