pjm
Billy Sheehan (19)
It was even worse than a guillotine choke with pressure placed directly on the windpipe.
Brumbies 2016
- Thread starter Brumby Jack
- Start date
- Status
It was even worse than a guillotine choke with pressure placed directly on the windpipe.
People were stunned because they have short and/or non-existent memories. Ian Prior's suspension included a bye counting as a match about a month before Latu's suspension.
Ian Prior was suspended last year and the bye counted as a match in 2015.
Owen Franks used a club game to count as one match of a two match suspension in 2015.
Ben McCalman was suspended for two weeks of which one club game counted as a match when they had a bye in 2013.
It seems that any time a team has argued that the player would have played club rugby during a bye week it is accepted and that counts as a week.
There are plenty of examples where the team hasn't seemed to argue that and the then the bye week doesn't count as a match (like Pocock in this example).
Clearly this should be cleared up so it is consistent and I think they should just make it so the bye counts as a match.
I don't understand why people view this as being so cynical. It's a subjective situation where there is uncertainty first over whether someone will be cited for what they did and then how the judiciary officer will grade it in terms of severity. There is then some uncertainty over whether they will apply extra weeks as a deterrent and/or subtract weeks for clean records and pleading guilty.
Why would you not try and achieve the best outcome possible for you and your team?
pjm
Billy Sheehan (19)
The position of his forearm and wrist and Leitch grabbing at the area afterwards.
pjm
Billy Sheehan (19)
And you're guessing it wasn't? You really don't want to see your idol fall
pjm
Billy Sheehan (19)
We know what happened though. Pocock will forever more be on the level of eye gougers and the like.
Great hyperbole.
He grabbed a player round the neck and was suspended for it.
He committed an offence that has a low level entry point of 2 weeks, medium of 4 and high end of 8 weeks.
Eye gouging has a low end of 12 weeks, mid range of 18 weeks and high end of 24 to 208 weeks.
Totally the same though. Thanks for your contribution.
Scoey
Tony Shaw (54)
I don't know why people are getting riled up about Pocock's suspension. He has been suspended for 3 weeks. That's it. He can't play for 3 weeks. Simple. It's not a x number of matches suspension, its a time period so the discussion on how many matches he will miss is completely moot.
mst
Peter Johnson (47)
Same move was used at Wrestlemaina the other day! 
Anyways - meanwhile that other stuff that is going on in the background, it seem everybody is out denying they are implicated! Same script writer?
ACT Government:
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act...cated-in-brumbies-report-20160405-gnyv2q.html
UC:
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/rug...es-drama-and-kpmg-report-20160406-gnzmhq.html
Anyways - meanwhile that other stuff that is going on in the background, it seem everybody is out denying they are implicated! Same script writer?
ACT Government:
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act...cated-in-brumbies-report-20160405-gnyv2q.html
UC:
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/rug...es-drama-and-kpmg-report-20160406-gnzmhq.html
Shiggins
Simon Poidevin (60)
Worse then a guillotine choke? You have no. Idea what you're talking about. Pocock is a class player and bloke. To say that it was worse because of the position of his wrist is ridiculous as you cant see his wrist and he is walking backwards. Try to choke someone out whole 8 guys are pushing you backwards. Plus he only used one arm. He needed to use 2 arms to complete any form of legitimate choke. Don't pretend you know things about other sports when you dont have any idea
Sent from my SM-G928I using Tapatalk
Hugh Jarse
Rocky Elsom (76)
When is Episode 2 of the Jones drama being played out in the courts?
SammyP
Chris McKivat (8)
I actually thought the best and most believable example (cough cough) was when Michael Hooper was apparently going to play for Manly the week before the Bledisloe Cup. He served his suspension by missing the SS match, possibly a semi I think, then was free to play against the Kiwis. Would love to know how many starting Wallabies are released to play club rugby before a Bledisloe.
mst
Peter Johnson (47)
From what I can gather, episode 2 is currently playing out with no fixed date for the curtain call.
His Honour is awaiting copies of each of the scripts from all the cast members to makesure his ending ties it all up; then the cliff hanger he is penning will be suitably ended with the AFP taking over creative control in series 4. I think series 3 will be split between the civil action and the Board spill(s).
Jones the next day went to the Supreme Court with 120 pages of documents and hit the Brumbies board with a wrongful dismissal claim. Justice Richard Refshauge has reserved his decision but allowed Jones to return to work while gagging the board.
Meanwhile, a whole range of Supreme Court subpoenas served on the Australian Rugby Union, University of Canberra officials, ACT government leaders and the Brumbies board for all their private emails and phone calls relating to Jones must be returned within 14 days.
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
mst
Peter Johnson (47)
- Status