Broadcast options for Australian Rugby
- Thread starter WorkingClassRugger
- Start date
liquor box
Peter Sullivan (51)
I wish there was someway that they could add chapters where you can select what games you are interested in.
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
Brett is now writing for RugbyPass, Harry still writes for the Roar on occasion. I don't think there is any bad blood, probably just a better job offer for Brett and with the move it made sense for them to do their own podcast instead of the roar's one.
I've never particularly enjoyed Harry's podcasting style (or prose in general), so I'm happy to have a new set of hosts at the Roar and more rugby podcasts overall.
footy1>31
Charlie Fox (21)
deserves its own discussion thread but whatever you think of eddie this is enormously well done so far, like all the best sports docos (drive to survive, QB, lions vids back in the day) content like this is what drives fan engagement. RA should be desperate for 9 to have it on its FTA in a primetime slot, although the nrl would kill it quickly
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
Just watched Stan's new Thursday night show - "The night before gameday" and I'm not exactly sure what the point of it is.
Justin Harrison and Steve Hoiles did a run down of every game looking at the team lists and making a prediction, so it was basically the exact same thing as the Wednesday show the call up, but hosted by Harrison so significantly worse. Maybe they'll differentiate a bit as the season goes on but at this stage there doesn't seem to be much point to it and I would've thought Thursday is where you do a bit more of the fun variety show with more personal player/coach interviews and the like. I'd also rather a Monday or Tuesday review show, but I assume this might still be coming.
Justin Harrison and Steve Hoiles did a run down of every game looking at the team lists and making a prediction, so it was basically the exact same thing as the Wednesday show the call up, but hosted by Harrison so significantly worse. Maybe they'll differentiate a bit as the season goes on but at this stage there doesn't seem to be much point to it and I would've thought Thursday is where you do a bit more of the fun variety show with more personal player/coach interviews and the like. I'd also rather a Monday or Tuesday review show, but I assume this might still be coming.
PhilClinton
Mark Loane (55)
I would definitely prefer a quality over quantity approach. I hope Stan don't try and cram three programs into the week.
I think the Wednesday show doing a review and preview would be good and leave the Thursday show to a more general 'get to know the teams/personalities' type program as you mention.
Harrison being the anchor for any of these programs seems an odd choice though.
SouthernX
John Thornett (49)
Harrison has good in depth analysis IMO. Just not during a live broadcast where his slow and monotone voice/calling of a game can’t keep up with the speed of super/test rugby.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
They might get a bit more content and difference into the shows when the Club seasons kick off? Would mind a quick around the grounds of Club land as well.
My choice would be a Monday Review show and a Thursday Preview show. When the season starts they should be able to grab more coaches, players for segments.
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
There's a whole other show for that - Clubland, and in my view it's the best one they've done. Having the full show dedicated mean they do multiple interviews, look at all the comps and get to dive into the character of the clubs and people around them much than when it's just 5 minutes lip service as part of an hour long show.
I'm hoping there will be more differentiation as the season builds too, but I was pretty surprised to see there wasn't more from the get go. It was almost like they hadn't talked between the different hosting teams about what each show would be. In the end the biggest difference (aside from the identity of the hosts themselves) was one had them behind a desk and the other in armchairs.
liquor box
Peter Sullivan (51)
I think Harrison is one of the better commentators on Stan, based on his content. He is the only one who has the guts to criticise popular players or teams and will point out what he is seeing.
That being said, he has a terrible voice for broadcasting and this is a pretty important part of his job. His voice and pronunciation is streets ahead of Horan and SBW
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
I've gone full 180 with Horan. Can't wait to hear what he has to say next.
Try it. Don't expect much and he actually becomes entertaining.
Try it. Don't expect much and he actually becomes entertaining.
PhilClinton
Mark Loane (55)
See I haven't noticed that and it's one of the reasons I have been critical of him. As the CEO of RUPA I feel like he's a bit hamstrung with what he is willing to say. I've noticed there are a couple of players he won't touch and I find that frustrating.
John S
Chilla Wilson (44)
Yeah, I'm in the same boat - I think he has great analysis, but his role at RUPA is tying him down (well to me). It's also my perception that there are some "protected species" in the player group he won't go near.
LeCheese
Greg Davis (50)
Biggest takeaway from the announcement was how many people on socials have no idea the game otherwise would’ve been on Gem
SouthernX
John Thornett (49)
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
"Go On! You're Free Now, Pigeon!" Cries Rugby CEO Phil Waugh As He Makes The Marketing Pigeon Redundant
More to come.
www.betootaadvocate.com
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
Reds v tahs rated 736k last night:
Sounds like solid numbers, particularly given the late shift to the main channel.
Sounds like solid numbers, particularly given the late shift to the main channel.
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
They've changed the way they report ratings this year. That 736k is "reach", measures anyone who watched for 1 min while the show was on.
The 166k is closer to what the ratings would have been reported last year and previously.
Unfortunately, it means a lot of people watched a little bit, and not very many watched a lot. But 166k is better than what it would have got on Gem.
Matildas did 1.4m reach and 666k total audience as a comparison
Last edited: