dru
David Wilson (68)
This is the key. Things would be very different if there were literally hundreds of commentators employed to commentate around the country and at the top level we just got to hear the best of them.
Australian sports broadcasting is full of former players who have obvious allegiances. I think it is worse when they pretend they are neutral because they clearly aren't.
I find Rod Kafer worse to listen to than most because he tries to make it out that he is neutral and even-handed and he very much isn't.
At least it is clear where you sit with someone like Marto or Kearns. They wear their heart on their sleeve and get excited when their team wins and disappointed when they lose.
I'm not in any way saying that makes them good commentators, just that I think it is better that they don't try and hide it.
For me, if a rugby commentator does not have a "horse in the race", then they are not engaged enough to commentate rugby. Having some level of bias seems not just inevitable but necessary. Wear it, try to level not out, and move on.