.....
I disagree our kicking strategy is appalling - Beale and Cooper in particular kick pretty well in general play, but Cooper certainly had an off night, especially towards the end. Execution is inconsistent, no doubt. There are some "one-off" kicks that need to be cut out - Bieber did a horror, Gits has his moments. Barnes may help here - he has an accurate kicking game too.
Cyclo, you are quite right to broaden this out. I deliberately said 'kicking strategy' vs individual skill as, yes, I still find quite a bit of our in-play kick forwards and for the line inconsistent or rushed and feel sure a kicking coach working with all the players ever likely or needing to kick could improve both the choice of kick time, and the execution (off both feet). Next, certainly regards goal kicking, our
strategy of Giteau as No 1 kicker has been an objective disaster and, as Austin's stats proved, he's been performing as, at best, average for a top kicker since 2008, this is not something that has just started since Scotland 2009. In the 2008-10 period he has not improved, and if DC had kicked just to his normal standards in HKG, the ABs would have won, and our v poor kicking stats that night would be the core reason we lost. If we want to win the RWC and attain the No 1 ranking, this debacle of Gits cannot, and must not, continue. IMO, Gits must be dropped, or, just maybe, benched, Barnes should return as 12, and Barnes, JOC (James O'Connor), Beale and QC (Quade Cooper) should be supported by a full-time kicking coach, with Barnes and JOC (James O'Connor) probably the anointed primary kickers, KB (Kurtley Beale) for the long ones (a la F Steyn in Boks).
From the coaching perspective, Egerton is now in there, and while he is nominally the player manager, he has shown plenty of nous previously, and I think could be a big plus. Blake worries me, as I am not sure what he really brings.
Very interesting, and I hope you are right that he's contributing. If you were going out to pick a world-class, seasoned defence coach with Test experience, you would not pick Blake. I suspect, as with Nuci's appointment, Blake was shoed-in fast as the ARU watched with alarm at how core skills (eg defence) and back line structure issues in the Wallabies were not being adequately corrected, or improved.