So now we're getting all sorts of calls to play people out of their natural positions again. Beale to 15, Izzy to 13, Rodda to 6. It just goes from ridiculous to worse.
DHP is a fullback and had one of the better games there in Bledisloe 2. Leave him there.
Beale and Foley are weaknesses in defense, whether front on in the line or shifting around to wings and or fullback. Is there any wonder that the Wallabies can't transition from defense to attack on those few occasions the ABs turn the ball over?
Folau might be a good bet at wing, but has shown nothing at 13 when tried by the Tahs, and in fact was played pretty much at 13 in attack in Bledisloe 1, to no real effect.
Rodda is a lock, and like most locks is fairly ponderous in the open. He would not make a 6 in a month of Sundays. Tui has some promise but again is slow around the ground which is a weakness from him. I don't think Samu has shown much in the tests he's played and is not a No 8. Timu would be a better option there.
Arnold is a better fit to start with Coleman, and then Rodda can come off the bench. Tui despite his lack of pace is our best No 6 atm but will be challenged once Dempsey and Valetini are fit and Naisarani is eligible.
The backline must be stabilised in defense with all players defending in their spots. No more swapping around in defense. To'omua needs to come into the starting lineup at 10 or 12. Either or both of Foley and Beale must make way or we'll always have huge holes in the defensive dyke. I would be open to Beale at 10 and To'omua at 12, but more radically perhaps, To'omua at 10 and Meakes at 12. Looks like Hodge at 13 until one of the Ks returns. Izzy considered for wing but nowhere else. Koroibete to come out until he learns to control himself in his kick chases etc. Misses too many tackles by not having the smarts to adjust when the runner puts a step on.
I have been wondering too, just what lineup we'll go with in the back row if and when Naisarani, Dempsey and Valetini come good, say from early next year. If Dempsey regains his No 6 spot, and Naisarani (from March) proves to be the No 8 we are all wanting him to be, who, out of Hooper and Pocock, then go to the bench or be left out altogether? Hard to see the $6m man being left out, but that's exactly what should happen. RA and Tahs fans must be hoping Pocock will leave after the RWC so that the contract can be justified.