Short Ball
Allen Oxlade (6)
Did you manage to get any team lists from the match?
Australian Schoolboys & National Championships 2017
- Thread starter Hugh Jarse
- Start date
- Status
Did you manage to get any team lists from the match?
SOLE334
Jimmy Flynn (14)
Ladies and gents boys and girls,
Nationals is upon us and Im looking forward to see some good schoolboys rugby games.
The mystery of who will make State and Territory teams have been revealed. Some predictable selections and some 'interesting selections there especially with the Qld 2 team. Lets see who will emerge from the pack.
Who's bold to put up a propable list based on your knowledge and observation of the State teams for this yrs Nationals?
Nationals is upon us and Im looking forward to see some good schoolboys rugby games.
The mystery of who will make State and Territory teams have been revealed. Some predictable selections and some 'interesting selections there especially with the Qld 2 team. Lets see who will emerge from the pack.
Who's bold to put up a propable list based on your knowledge and observation of the State teams for this yrs Nationals?
The Honey Badger
Jim Lenehan (48)
Breaks_Away
Sydney Middleton (9)
....And the mystery of who has made the COMBINED STATES TEAM is revealed ......
Combined States Squad 2017
Alphabetical Order:
NSW - Charlie Baker
The Scot's College
NSW - Stewart Brown
Central Coast Grammar
QLD - Harrison Cannon
St Joseph's College, Nudgee
NSW - Cooper Chambers
Trinity Grammar School
QLD - Isaac Crone
Brisbane State High School
NSW - Brady Dawson
Knox Grammar School
NSW - Joel Ellis
Waverley College
NSW - Dougal Hicks
The King's School
NSW - Ben Joseph
The Scot's College
QLD - Emmit Keepa
Ipswich Grammar School
QLD - Jeremy Kempston
Ipswich Grammar School
QLD - William Kirk
St Joseph's College, Gregory Terrace
NSW - Willie Manu
St Augustine's College
NSW - Will McCormick
Waverley College
NSW - Michael Pavlakis
Knox Grammar School
NSW - Tristan Reilly
St Joseph's College, Hunters Hill
NSW - James Sidery
St Augustine's College
QLD - Davida Stowers
Ipswich Grammar School
QLD - Bruce Tevaga
Padua College
QLD - Emosi Tuqirie
Marist College, Ashgrove
NSW - Harry Turner - #7
Epping Boys High School
NSW - Jack Walsh
St Augustine's College
NSW - Jack Winchester
Bishop Druitt College
NSW: 15 players
QLD: 8 players
Total: 23
Ive added the States the players are from, however could those who know the positions the boys play, please add them next to their name.
Cheers
http://www.schoolsrugby.com.au/2017/news/combined-states-team-national-championships-announced/
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Vintage Red
Herbert Moran (7)
Interesting to note that after the completion of the NSW Schools Trials, and the selection of NSW 1 & 2, there were 15 lads identified as "Shadow" players. When the Combined States squad was announced a few days later, it included 15 players from NSW, of which only 8 were from the Shadow squad. Where did the other 7 come from?
Armchair Selector
Johnnie Wallace (23)
Interesting?????? such are the tribulations of selections
.I would assume that the mystery 7, were players that had been ruled out through injury but have been subsequently ruled fit enough to play.
What positions did these players "parachute" into? Care to name names???
The other alternative is that the 7 that remain as shadow players are remaining there to cover positions that NSW Schools feel are likely to need filling. Has been known to happen in the past.
Must say though that if a player was selected as a shadow and then was leapfrogged by someone who didn't trial or did trial but wasn't selected as a shadow, IMHO they should be rightly pissed off
Unless I am missing the obvious. Anyone able to shed any light?
Does that also mean they will bring in an extra 7 shadow players?
The Honey Badger
Jim Lenehan (48)
I presume that the 7 were already selected ahead of the shadow selections. Just not made public until the rest of the combined states announced.
Because they would have to wait for other states to nominate players for this team and then work out what they had to fill.
Sent from my F3115 using Tapatalk
Because they would have to wait for other states to nominate players for this team and then work out what they had to fill.
Sent from my F3115 using Tapatalk
Armchair Selector
Johnnie Wallace (23)
Thanks HB, I cant fault your logic. If that is the case, the boys who were picked up by Combined States from the NSW shadow squad are very lucky that the first choices for CS were already selected by their home states........
Good luck to CS, I hope they knock off some of their favoured opposition (like last year) and a few are rewarded with Aust Schoolboys or Barbarian selections!
The Honey Badger
Jim Lenehan (48)
Which would make perfect sense for those boys that we thought were very unlucky not to have made I OR II . . Reilly being a most notable one.
Sent from my F3115 using Tapatalk
Gary Owen III
Syd Malcolm (24)
Different selectors I believe... thus why some shadows were also selected in CS and others weren't in favour of other players. Happened last year too.
Troy Dickson
Herbert Moran (7)
# The selectors for Combined State are Aus schoolboy aligned whilst the selectors who picked NSW teams and NSW shadow players are aligned with NSW schoolboys. So yeah two separate group of selectors, just goes to show Aus selectors are thinking differently to NSW selectors.
In 2016 the Combined States finished 3rd overall and had 6 players collectively in the two Aus teams.
COMBINED STATES TEAM FOR NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIPS ANNOUNCED
by ASRU on June 25, 2017 in News
COMBINED STATES TEAM FOR NATONAL CHAMPIONSHIPS ANNOUNCED
The Australian Schools Rugby Union (ASRU) has announced the 23 players selected to take part in the Championships being held in Sydney at Riverview College from 3rd to 8th July –next week.
The Combined States Team is selected from players not selected in their State Team, but who the Australian selectors think are worthy of this ,and who may then be still in the running for one of the Australian Teams.
Quite e few players over the years have done this, for example –the son of ARU CEO Bill Pulver was in the Combined Sates Team and was then selected in the Australian Schoolboys Team.
The Australian Schoolboys teams will be announced after the games at Riverview at 1.30 p.m. on Saturday 8th July. The final of the Championships is at 11.30 a.m.
THE TEAM IS , in alphabetical order–
Inside Shoulder
Nathan Sharpe (72)
It doesn't show that at all.
The side is picked from what is left over after NSW (and Others) have picked their squads.
Why they chose to single out Pulver's kid is a mystery: a truckload of CS players have made oz schools, reflecting the political process which is NSW Schools selection, and no doubt QLDs as well.
Hugh jarse is sorely missed in these parts at these times.
Troy Dickson
Herbert Moran (7)
I am referring to the NSW shadow players..... Just because NSW selectors had selected shadow players for NSW team does not mean the Aus Selectors are going to select them for Combined States. Like I said NSW selectors have a different view to the Aus selectors. For the your info it is in their own media release that Aus selectors select Combined States -
The Combined States Team is selected from players not selected in their State Team, but who the Australian selectors think are worthy of this ,and who may then be still in the running for one of the Australian Teams.
The Honey Badger
Jim Lenehan (48)
Esai Haanangana (sorry if the spelling is rong) played CS last year and made starting Lock for Schoolboys. And I believe the only 2016 schoolboy to play Super this year.
That's a better example.
Sent from my F3115 using Tapatalk
Breaks_Away
Sydney Middleton (9)
Yes you're correct HB,
(maybe not with the spelling of Esei's name but hey! you wouldn't be the first and definitely won't be the last! .
Esei Ha'angana
Who was a NSW CCC school boy played in CS last year and was the starting lock for Aus School boys, he then went on to captain the Melbourne U20's flowing onto signing a super rugby contract in 2016. His first debut for the Melbourne Rebels was in May of this year having just turned 18 years and 15 days old! making him their youngest ever debutant!
I guess what needs to be seen here is.... Combined States Team should not be seen as just a team of "left overs!" from school state selections, but rather a team of players (recognised by Aus Selectors) as having as much rugby talent and chance to receive higher honours as those players selected for their 1st and 2nd States teams
"Never under estimate what we may see as the under dog"
for that presumption, could come back and bite us al"
It would be very interesting to find out how many players from the NSW I & NSW II teams who made the Aus school boys - Aus Barbarian squads last year, if they would have similar success stories as Esei?
For example:
Dylan Pietsch NSW GPS -
NSWI - Aus Barbarian 2016 signed an ARU 7's contract June of this year 2017 locked in until August 2019.
S
sidelineview
Guest
The Combined States team came 3rd in the Nationals last year.
They defeated Victoria in their play-off on the final day.
To show how close the competition was last year, NSW2s who won it over NSW1, only just scraped into the Final by the skin of their teeth over Victoria. NSW2s gained a bonus point in their loss to Qld1 by less than 7 points.
Combined States were a very good team and like NSW2s they gelled really well as a team during the week. In contrast, NSW1s didnt come together as well as a team.
Jordan Petaia from Qld was one of their best players for CS at only 17 years of age. He went onto play for the Barbarians and was earmarked as a rising star. As expected, he has been selected for Qld1 this year.
EDIT Petaia was 16 and the Qld 9 must be good.
They defeated Victoria in their play-off on the final day.
To show how close the competition was last year, NSW2s who won it over NSW1, only just scraped into the Final by the skin of their teeth over Victoria. NSW2s gained a bonus point in their loss to Qld1 by less than 7 points.
Combined States were a very good team and like NSW2s they gelled really well as a team during the week. In contrast, NSW1s didnt come together as well as a team.
Jordan Petaia from Qld was one of their best players for CS at only 17 years of age. He went onto play for the Barbarians and was earmarked as a rising star. As expected, he has been selected for Qld1 this year.
EDIT Petaia was 16 and the Qld 9 must be good.
The Honey Badger
Jim Lenehan (48)
I think most are in clubland, some may have played in Super U20. Pretty sure some of the ACT boys did, Lonergan and Gerowski and I know Eadie was playing for QLD.
Hunter Paisami (VIC) played 13 for AU schoolboys, was playing for Samoa in the recent U20 world cup.
But most of these players will come through next year in the U20 state teams.
Sent from my F3115 using Tapatalk
CatchnPass
Vay Wilson (31)
There was a great lesson in there for all players aspiring to higher level - play as a team and individual success is much more likely to follow. Play as an individual and selectors may well overlook you, even if highly fancied in pre match punditry.
S
sidelineview
Guest
True, but it depends on the dynamics within the team. Player personalities, coaches, managers.
Sometimes it gels sometimes it doesnt.
Some players bring so much more to a team than is evident from the sideline watching.
- Status