light
Well, if Gunn is better than Dempsey then Oz Schools is going to have a fine 6 this year indeed.
I saw Gunn play for the Qld Twos in the 2011 U/16 tournament and he did not take my eye, though that doesn't mean a lot, and one year can make a huge amount of difference anyway.
As for the wingers: I believe that Gutherson, who you asked about, is already contracted by the Manly Sea Eagles. Kellaway, who you mentioned played fullback in the NSW trials but the NSW selectors wanted to get both McIntyre and the good all-round flyhalf Horwitz into the XV - so they picked McIntyre at 15.
It's not the worst idea, even though there are probably 3 other NSW trialists who are better fullbacks, maybe 4. Sometimes selectors choose players to play at a higher level because they are big match players and McIntyre is that.
That doesn't explain why 13. Milne is on the wing rather than partnering Newington team mate 12. Moeroa in the NSW Ones or Twos. If they wanted to play a centre on the wing they should have chosen the multi-talented Foketi, who is faster than Milne anyway. Instead, he is playing in the Twos
In other words: there is a lack of specialisation in the NSW Ones back line and a whiff of compromise.
As for the Qld 8: NSW has one of his type in the Twos, but Whiteley in the Ones is a different player altogether: a skills 8, who I have seen play at 12 with aplomb. This is probably OK because NSW Ones has two locks who run over folks and 6.Dempsey runs through them with leg drive.
But here we go again, or at least I do: writing about the Ones players of both big rugby states yet knowing that there are Twos players who should have been in the Ones from both states who will be the apple of a few selectors' eyes. And not even knowing (as I write this), who is in the Combined States, ACT, Vic and WA teams - and even if we did, not knowing the merit of a lot of them.
But it keeps us off the streets which must be of benefit to the general populace.
.