• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Australian Rugby / RA

drewprint

Dick Tooth (41)
It's got a real twitter classic vibe to it. No idea how long it will last but it's building up steam at the moment.
I really hope it takes off. I’d love a really great alternative - Threads unfortunately never did it for me. Time to track down some rugby accounts.
 

Merrow

Arch Winning (36)
I really hope it takes off. I’d love a really great alternative - Threads unfortunately never did it for me. Time to track down some rugby accounts.
There’s a starter pack but many of us have carried our names over from twitter to Bluesky
 

barbarian

Phil Kearns (64)
Staff member
I've been thinking more about Hamish. He's such an interesting study in a certain type of corporate Australian.

He's so desperate to be loved and appreciated. It reminds me a lot of what Joe Aston used to write about in the Fin Review every day, a certain class of CEO that over time becomes completely untethered to reality. This excerpt from his final column I think applies:

These people are often just the highest-paid person in the building. I mean, if Twiggy wants to be crazy, at least he’s got his name on the door. The ones who are completely deluded are the ones who’ve just commando-crawled to the top of the steaming pile and then expect us to adore them. You haven’t taken any risk pal, you’ve just lucked in! That’s the other inopportune truth about this caper: luck plays a huge role in business, though you’d never know it from the heroic self-narratives of chief executives.

It’s never enough, either, to be recognised for your commercial acumen. That’s the soulless part of the capitalist endeavour. You also need to be loved for your charity patronage and your (highly selective) corporate social responsibility. You can’t just be Mr Profit, you’ve got to be Mr Altruism, Mr Community. The desire to be feted is all a part of the rarefied delusion state.
So many of his interviews, comments and missives during and after his stint as Chair can be summarised in that final sentence.

It's why he's always ready to tell us he didn't take a salary as Chair during COVID. I was just a volunteer, doing it out of the goodness of my own heart! He's not only a savvy businessman but he's a good person too. A great person actually.

Of course the game consists of thousands upon thousands of volunteers, many of whom put in many more hours for far less reward (and column inches) than our Hamish. But I'm not sure he even knows they exist.

And while I have joked about it, him taking credit for Joseph Sua'ali'i's game against England is just galling. It's revisionist history on so many fronts.

He wasn't some secret that Hamish boldly uncovered. We've wanted him since he was 15. And it wasn't like getting him was the result of some savvy business, they just made a big cash offer. I could have done that.

Nobody was unhappy we signed him and the vast majority of people were excited to see him play. There was some grumbling about the price but realistically they were in the usual corners. So to cast this as some sort of risky decision that nobody believes in is delusional. Likewise the idea that JAS will single-handedly turn the game around.

Funnily enough, there was a decision that Hamish made that was seen as risky at the time - the decision to sack Dave Rennie and appoint Eddie Jones as coach. But that one seems to have faded in Hammer's memory to the point where it's never mentioned anymore. Funny that.
 

The Ghost of Raelene

Simon Poidevin (60)
He dreams of being the rich guy with a vibe. The Mark Cuban type who seem to turn everything to gold and sit with world leaders then fist bump sports stars in the same day. The smoke that gets blown up their ass is incredible and I think they forget that basically everyone around them is being paid or wants to be so you think the world is just great and it always happens for me.

They've sat in too many rooms with people laughing at their shit jokes. They then get bitter and want to tell us about their deeds (which are just doing your job) when getting lambasted by the public who don't have anything to gain from your shit eating grin and it seems to shock their system and the systems of those around them. When the partners lash out you know the cage has been rattled.
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)

Wilson

Phil Kearns (64)
Stowers is a good player and good on him for picking up a contract in the US. It will likely be better for his development then cooling his heels as a fringe player in a super squad, which is probably all he could've hoped for here right now, particularly with the end of the Rebels.

His best chance beyond that was probably the 7s program given his size, and considering it's John Manenti coaching at San Diego he was probably on their radar.
 

PhilClinton

Mark Loane (55)
The threshold for "Star" and "Powerhouse" need to be examined. SD never even won the MLR

Yep - the use of 'star' is one of my biggest gripes across all sports. It is such as headline grabber.

The amount of times I've been suckered into a clickbait article for an NBA 'star' or NRL 'star' injured for months and it's some fringe bloke who's played 2 games and likely wont be re-signed the following year.
 

LevitatingSocks

Alfred Walker (16)
Describing a MLR club as an international powerhouse is a crazy hyperbolic stretch, even for the murdoch tabloids.
MLR probably has more casual familiarity among Australians or Kiwis than Americans. I suppose that qualifies them as "international" if we're being generous with the boundaries of language.

The "powerhouse" descriptor is the far more dubious of the two.
 

LevitatingSocks

Alfred Walker (16)
I've been thinking more about Hamish. He's such an interesting study in a certain type of corporate Australian.

He's so desperate to be loved and appreciated. It reminds me a lot of what Joe Aston used to write about in the Fin Review every day, a certain class of CEO that over time becomes completely untethered to reality. This excerpt from his final column I think applies:


So many of his interviews, comments and missives during and after his stint as Chair can be summarised in that final sentence.

It's why he's always ready to tell us he didn't take a salary as Chair during COVID. I was just a volunteer, doing it out of the goodness of my own heart! He's not only a savvy businessman but he's a good person too. A great person actually.

Of course the game consists of thousands upon thousands of volunteers, many of whom put in many more hours for far less reward (and column inches) than our Hamish. But I'm not sure he even knows they exist.

And while I have joked about it, him taking credit for Joseph Sua'ali'i's game against England is just galling. It's revisionist history on so many fronts.

He wasn't some secret that Hamish boldly uncovered. We've wanted him since he was 15. And it wasn't like getting him was the result of some savvy business, they just made a big cash offer. I could have done that.

Nobody was unhappy we signed him and the vast majority of people were excited to see him play. There was some grumbling about the price but realistically they were in the usual corners. So to cast this as some sort of risky decision that nobody believes in is delusional. Likewise the idea that JAS will single-handedly turn the game around.

Funnily enough, there was a decision that Hamish made that was seen as risky at the time - the decision to sack Dave Rennie and appoint Eddie Jones as coach. But that one seems to have faded in Hammer's memory to the point where it's never mentioned anymore. Funny that.
You can log on to LinkedIn and find a million different permutations of someone like Hamish in the realm of consulting/business/tech.

They tend to share a belief that success in one field confers expertise, and furthermore that this expertise extends itself to unrelated fields.

It's evident when someone has not been told "no" or "shut the fuck up" in quite some time and Hamish is a prime exemplar of this.
 

WorkingClassRugger

Michael Lynagh (62)
Unless I've missed other sources, the rumour seems to be coming from everyone's favourite rugby tweeter T2 rugby, and he appears to be talking specifically about the U20 trophy comp, not the WC

Yeah, I was dismissive of that tweet as well. But it has been expanded upon by the preferred mouthpiece of Sudamerica Rugby. He usually has better information. May end up just being the Trophy but even that is a move in the wrong direction.
 
Top