Rugbynutter39
Michael Lynagh (62)
Gees BH you have changed your tune - not long ago you saying we would be crazy to leave Super Rugby - now at least you seem to be accepting reality that we need to replace it.
Australian Rugby / RA
- Thread starter Dave Beat
- Start date
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
Change is only possible if the structure is changed and democratic accountability is reintroduced.
As per the RFU and FFR models, clubs affiliate directly to the governning body - state RUs go completely.
There's no perfect system, but the one we have now is a travesty.
I have consistently said that a Trans Tasman comp is desirable.
I don't think there is an Australian only model that will work though.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
S
sidelineview
Guest
It's easy to kick the Wallabies when they're down and to state the obvious, but the Kiwis were superior in all areas of the game.
Basic catch/pass skills, defence and positional play in defence.
It wouldn't have been easy to defend against the All blacks because they played the game so fast and their 2nd and 3rd phase play was excellent but still.
When Wayne Bennett gets hold of a Club he immediately goes back to basics and works on catching and passing skills because he knows a lot of grade players can improve in that area, meaning they havent been coached properly as juniors and as they've progressed through the ranks.
If players dont have good basic skills by the time they play for the Wallabies whose fault is that?
Basic catch/pass skills, defence and positional play in defence.
It wouldn't have been easy to defend against the All blacks because they played the game so fast and their 2nd and 3rd phase play was excellent but still.
When Wayne Bennett gets hold of a Club he immediately goes back to basics and works on catching and passing skills because he knows a lot of grade players can improve in that area, meaning they havent been coached properly as juniors and as they've progressed through the ranks.
If players dont have good basic skills by the time they play for the Wallabies whose fault is that?
kiap
Steve Williams (59)
That sort of figure is just the ARU's "over budget" number. The number to be looking at is bigger - their overall Supe expenditure encompassing all grants, expenses and bailouts etc. Weighed against the income generated it has been a loss leader from day dot (and sure, this is not the full Soup picture as each team also has their incomings and outgoings).
Replace it, yes -- or condense the format for teams from 16 games and finals in 6 months (Feb-July) to say 8 champ cup games in two months -- and 40% of the financials are as they were.
Well, factoring in Super's continuing slide in value, anyway. Cut the boredom. Cut the fat.
Remaining 3-4 months, the possibilities open up. Costs drop, scheduling windows for matches widen, no more 2 am games, dot dot dot.
They have tried to move towards doing this several times over the past few years and the State RUs, especially the 2 largest, will not have a bar of it.
I agree it absolutely needs to happen but how? I cannot see it being done.
WaltBrisney
Peter Burge (5)
Many people bemoan the lack of talent and suggest we have overreached by having 5 teams in Super Rugby. When you consider the number of young Aussies plying their trade overseas I don't think we can pin our troubles on lack of players.
To me, it seems coaching is where we are lacking. There are limited pathways and limited opportunities for coaches to develop.
Yes, NZ have a wealth of talent but it is not restricted to playing stocks. They have good systems for developing coaches.
We lament the skills gap but we are not talking about uncoordinated newbies. These are professional athletes with better than average coordination. If they were spending the right amount of time developing skills, they should be able to close that gap. Quality coaching is the is the key here and not just at the top level, though the wallabies defence in the first half would suggest there are some issues there.
Development officers are an important cog here. I have seen some brilliant ones but they rarely stay in the role for long as the rewards are not there. If this could be addressed and we could get more coach development happening in clubs and schools we would reap the benefits in the years to come.
To me, it seems coaching is where we are lacking. There are limited pathways and limited opportunities for coaches to develop.
Yes, NZ have a wealth of talent but it is not restricted to playing stocks. They have good systems for developing coaches.
We lament the skills gap but we are not talking about uncoordinated newbies. These are professional athletes with better than average coordination. If they were spending the right amount of time developing skills, they should be able to close that gap. Quality coaching is the is the key here and not just at the top level, though the wallabies defence in the first half would suggest there are some issues there.
Development officers are an important cog here. I have seen some brilliant ones but they rarely stay in the role for long as the rewards are not there. If this could be addressed and we could get more coach development happening in clubs and schools we would reap the benefits in the years to come.
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
That's the nub of the problem. It will be very difficult. It's why I think that almost total collapse is the best hope.
I like to watch
David Codey (61)
Centralise the common functions of the super franchises.
Stop the ad hoc bailing out of franchises by properly overseeing how they spend the money the ARU gives them.
That's probably $5M a year.
That's a good start without changing a thing.
I get that, but if the ARU collapses, but the state unions stumble along and survive, which they probably will, and a new national body arises, we still have the road blocks in place.
We need dragons.
The Honey Badger
Jim Lenehan (48)
@Quickhands, was that you I saw in the clip with the Marlins T shirt?
Santa clause beard near the end.
Sent from my F3115 using Tapatalk
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
When's the next world cup we could possibly hold?
I'm only half joking suggesting that too.
I'm only half joking suggesting that too.
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
NSWRU has had to be bailed out twice (at least) in the last 20 years or so. Wouldn't surprise me if they were on the cusp of the third strike. They all need to be allowed to go broke (which given the level of governance will happen).
I think they actually made a small profit this last year. Somehow.
You're assuming that they will disappear if they go broke. I'm not. They're like the dead, hard to kill again!
The Kiwis have thus far been quite adamant that they are not interested in this.
T
TOCC
Guest
Geoff Stooke at the Western Force rally said of the ARU Board "The rest of the board is morally bankrupt"
chibimatty
Jimmy Flynn (14)
Well, if all the South Africans move to Pro 14, the other more fantastical idea, would be to amalgamate Pro 14 and Super Rugby. Then we can have two separate conferences running as separate leagues, one Argentina/Greenwich mean timezone, the other an Aus-NZ-Asia/Pacific timezone. Have no the inter-league stuff until the finals come along only. By that stage anyway, being one or two games away from a grand final, people would still stay up late to watch their team on the other side of the world, as it's a sudden-death play-off. Three games maximum out of your timezone only maybe?
I dunno, just brainstorming.