• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

2015 IRB Junior Rugby World Cup - Italy

Status
Not open for further replies.

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Happy to trade meat pies for 3 pointers.

Re McCalman and a Gold Jumper. It would be a bold selector that leaves him at home.
 

Hans

Fred Wood (13)
Mc Seems to be able to sniff out a tryline, that type of player is always handy to have!

It will be interesting to see if the selectors can ignore the quality performance of the NSW team when picking the NSW squad and balancing numbers
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
^^ @Braveheart81. They are off the land. Plenty of colour in their culture. Spades are not short handled square mouthed digging implements.

@hans, there will be no balancing of numbers against a state quota. If the Reds or Barbars are not good enough players, then they are not good enough players. Artificially constructed barriers disappear when we are talking about Gold jumpers, and if a banjoplucker is better than one of our talented young athletes, then I like the sound of that his music.
 

Lee Grant

John Eales (66)
Across a whole tournament, i wouldn't imagine too many times.

Now I get it - let me check.

Only kidding, they wouldn't played in the same tournament too many times, but Nick scored for Combined States once against NSW Schools with NSW fullback Andrew looking like a shag on a rock.

[Folks this is just light relief waiting for the scores to come through. Think of it as a commercial like searchthemeerkat.com].
.
 
B

Bobby Sands

Guest
Happy to trade meat pies for 3 pointers.

Re McCalman and a Gold Jumper. It would be a bold selector that leaves him at home.

Probably but there are atleast two other pretty decent 7s from QLD not even playing today/
 

Lee Grant

John Eales (66)
Mc Seems to be able to sniff out a tryline, that type of player is always handy to have!

It will be interesting to see if the selectors can ignore the quality performance of the NSW team when picking the NSW squad and balancing numbers

The game is not over.

Anybody at Viking Park seen a dead squirrel? I'm worried about him.
.
 

Hans

Fred Wood (13)
^^
@hans, there will be no balancing of numbers against a state quota. If the Reds or Barbars are not good enough players, then they are not good enough players. Artificially constructed barriers disappear when we are talking about Gold jumpers, and if a banjoplucker is better than one of our talented young athletes, then I like the sound of that his music.

I hope you are right.........
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Probably but there are atleast two other pretty decent 7s from QLD not even playing today/
By all accounts Jack Mac has gained some mass over the last 12 months, and he can double as a No 8 if needed. Obviously his game would be different to that which Lolo F (My first choice No 8) would bring to the table.

I have a sneaky feeling that Brad W may not be released from the 7's programme for Jnr RWC. Hong Kong and Japan Comps are very close to the Jnr RWC, and Gunn is a gun and will be in my Squad. There will be intense competition for the run on 7 at Jnr RWC.
 

Hans

Fred Wood (13)
By all accounts Jack Mac has gained some weight, and can double as a No 8 if needed. Obviously his game would be different to that which Lolo F (My first choice No 8) would bring to the table.

I have a sneaky feeling that Brad W may not be released from the 7's programme for Jnr RWC. Hong Kong and Japan Comps are very close to the Jnr RWC, and Gunn is a gun and will be in my Squad. There will be intense competition for the run on 7 at Jnr RWC.

All the better for Aus Rugby. Would appear we have another huge pool of talented 7's to pick from yet again. Are we able to touch base with NZ and Eng about getting some ex-pat Sth Africans to move out this way and breed these 2.5 meter tall 115kg locks they seem to have a stack of?
 

kiap

Steve Williams (59)
I hope you are right...
Just remember that winning the tournament does not guarantee 28 rep team jerseys in a brown paper bag either.

WA found that out last month, undefeated in winning the SS comp and only getting 5 boys in the Baabaas side.

It's not about how many points the trialling teams score. The selectors will build a side from the players they think can do the best job at the next level.
 

Hans

Fred Wood (13)
Just remember that winning the tournament does not guarantee 28 rep team jerseys in a brown paper bag either.

WA found that out last month, undefeated in winning the SS comp and only getting 5 boys in the Baabaas side.

It's not about how many points the trialling teams score. The selectors will build a side from the players they think can do the best job at the next level.

I agree entirely, however, could one make some sort of an argument considering the Barbarians results at this tournament.

This is not intended to start a fight, and i am not questioning the integrity of the selectors or coaches, just making note. There were plenty of people on here who were "taken back" by the Barbarians selection. Perhaps some selected on reputation rather than performance?
 

Lee Grant

John Eales (66)
Happy to trade meat pies for 3 pointers.

Re McCalman and a Gold Jumper. It would be a bold selector that leaves him at home.

Jack Mac can play and his porking up in the summer did him no harm.

Thing is that Hamish Dunbar kept him out of Colts 1 for a lot of last season until the Grand Final.

You'd think he'd make the team at least for the Oceania tournament camp.

I think they will take only two opensides to Italy, and one will be Brad Wilkin. The other will be between Michael Gunn and Jack Mac - and Gunn may be playing Super Rugby on the weekend.

People may be cracking their knuckles to start typing that one of the three can cover 6 - but the lock/6 situation is much more serious than that of 6/7. That has to be satisfied first with somebody like NK covering 6/lock.

Once that is solved, and I know the solutions as well as most, then the extra 7, if there be such, can be talked about.
.
 

Lee Grant

John Eales (66)
By all accounts Jack Mac has gained some mass over the last 12 months, and he can double as a No 8 if needed..

I'd be surprised if Jack Mac played 8: his weight increase was that of a skinny, bandy legged kid to a normal U20 type opensider.

Of the players I have seen this year, which is only NSW and ACT live and one video from Adelaide, it's more likely Croke and Kamp will be second 8 and 6 cover and next N. Kellaway as lock/6/8 dogsbody.

Those names can be changed but the bottom line is I don't see a place for a specialist opensider covering anything.

I'm talking about the team for Italy, there will be three opensiders for the first camp.

Mind you - I've been wrong before.
.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top