MoneyBill685
Larry Dwyer (12)
hmmm so coaches get paid and players dont? I mean they will do the same work as players right? training twice a week and play on the weekend. Surely it wouldnt be a fulltime salary in amateur club land?
QLD Premier Rugby 2025
- Thread starter Coleman Rees
- Start date
PhilClinton
Paul McLean (56)
I'm not sure if you're baiting here.
Most of the 1st grade coaches I've known are at very least also reviewing game footage one night a week and having standalone meetings with other coaches to gameplan on other nights, along with full training session plans. On top of that a lot of the coaches are making themselves available all day on gameday even though the 1st grade players usually won't arrive at the grounds until lunchtime.
Todd Dammers was always at GPS games for the 9am kickoffs and happy to lend a hand.
Most of the 1st grade coaches I've known are at very least also reviewing game footage one night a week and having standalone meetings with other coaches to gameplan on other nights, along with full training session plans. On top of that a lot of the coaches are making themselves available all day on gameday even though the 1st grade players usually won't arrive at the grounds until lunchtime.
Todd Dammers was always at GPS games for the 9am kickoffs and happy to lend a hand.
Stanley Hudson
Frank Row (1)
Not to mention the countless times he would jump in as a touch judge at Souths for 4th and 5th grades. As well jumping into halftime huddles and offering his bits of advice when needed. He and many other 1st grade coaches don't have to be at the club for 5th grade kick offs yet they still turn up.
Brisbane Rugby Runner
Frank Row (1)
Looking at how Souths were building as a club during that period the club would be disappointed to be in the current position that it’s in.
I know listening to Dammers talk when he was at Souths, he was very much about the success of the entire club. Those days for Souths supporters seem a long way away.
I am nervous for them in all grades against the likes of Easts, Brothers & Wests… could be a bleak year for their lower grade depth.
MoneyBill685
Larry Dwyer (12)
Tony Mcgahan has come in and did a much better job of recruitment which filters down through the other grades. Last year they picked up zero recruits for prems.
LevitatingSocks
Billy Sheehan (19)
If you think a subset of players aren't getting paid directly by clubs or indirectly through employment opportunities/discounted housing, I have a bankrupt casino shaped like a toilet to sell you.
Bulldog
Arch Winning (36)
Just looked at what is ahead of Wests in the next two rounds Souths at home and Bothers away so potentially the Bulldogs could be 1&4 - they could be in the same situation as the Penrith Panthers - denying that there is anything wrong.
Respectfully the premiership window does not stay open forever, and maybe there needs to be some humble pie eaten at Sylvan Road and change a few things to suit the current crop of players because if they do go 1&4 it is a very long road to finals footy.
Respectfully the premiership window does not stay open forever, and maybe there needs to be some humble pie eaten at Sylvan Road and change a few things to suit the current crop of players because if they do go 1&4 it is a very long road to finals footy.
what do you think needs changing? Genuinely interested, personally I think there has been almost no structure in attack from the backline, it has been 2 very wet games, but others have had same conditions and shown more. Also some poor turnovers in possession from forwards mainly but backs at times too have really hurt momentum
Bulldog
Arch Winning (36)
A bit of humility and honesty in their analysis of performance. I heard Elwee on a podcast saying that they are winners and they know how to win , etc. well I would say that reputation earned in prior performance does not win you games. This is a different group of players so they don’t have the shared experience of working through tough situations and winning. Work out what’s going wrong in performance and set about fixing it. I thought the failure to get the draw by taking the points against Easts was poor decision making. If they took the points at first offering they would have had plenty of time to get back down there to secure a victory with another penalty. It was said on here that they knew they had two bonus points in the bag v Easts but a draw would have given them 3 and reduced Easts return to 3. That was dumb rugby but mistake made move on and learn from it. By gifting that win to Easts they have given a leg up to an opponent. If 10 wins gets you into the finals then they need to win 9 out of their 13 remaining games - if they are good enough this is not impossible. Their for and against average over the first 3 rounds is 21(for) and 20 against so it is small margins indeed which surely can be turned around with attitude and application. The coaching staff and leadership need to take action and change things up because if you want to look back to past performance as an indicator of future performance then last two grand finals and the 3 games in 2025 would tell you that Elwee coached sides have challenges in winning close games. Championship sides win more close games than they lose.
Watchingrugby
Allen Oxlade (6)
……..plus the players who went to Sydney plus the players who went to Canberra
Spamnoodle
Jimmy Flynn (14)
This happens at every club, every year.
LevitatingSocks
Billy Sheehan (19)
losing both flyhalfs and the comp leading try scorer probably hits harder than the usual horse trading though