I reckon the reds would take Benny Mac in a heart beat.
I reckon Benny Mac wouldn't go near a Richard Graham coached team with a 40ft barge pole. Pretty sure he was with Matt Hodgson in the playing group voting to stand RG down mid season after he'd signed with the Reds.
I reckon the reds would take Benny Mac in a heart beat.
That wasn't the question. Someone was suggesting that Mac wouldn't be wanted by a number of state teams. I was suggesting we'd take him. Don't be so defensive.
Yeah because the brumbies who just lost a test standard 8 would rather have a 30 year old, a bloke who hasn't played for 2 years and a rookie over a 30 test #8 who was massive in the resurgence of a club this year....
What the fuck does that have to do with anything?? You're kidding if you think Aeulua, Vaea (who doesn't even play) or Butler are better players than McCalman.
Wow you really don't like McCalman do you.We shall see in the fullness of time. Anyway, Ben McC will probably only be available next year. Expect he will be off overseas after the RWC whether he plays again for the Wallabies or not. At this time, I would place Hoiles in better form than Ben and won/t be surprised if he gets some more test time.
Wow you really don't like McCalman do you.
Hoiles has started about 3 games this year and has been solid in those matcha.
McCalman was arguably the best 8 in Australia going into the test break and had 3 solid games after the break.
Not sure what more he needs to do but i doubt you would give him credit no matter how he plays.
Think about Hoiles is that he is playing for a dominant team and you always look better than you actually are when playing for a dominant team.
Hoiles and McCalman are two guys that are great at Super Rugby level but probably aren't big and physical enough to be long term options at 8 at test level.
It'll be interesting to see who McKenzie goes for.
Hoiles in three games has offered a whole lot lore than Ben imo.
Pretty much the opinion of Deans as well. In his defence, I'd say that in the past couple of games, Hoiles has had more impact than Cliff Palu, who is in the midst of one of his best seasons to date. Isn't that big enough?