Waratahs 2025

[eastman]

My only issue with Sua'ali'i is that he’s shown so little in attack (although oddly he’s been tough). For the hype that he received as a schoolboy you’d expect Greg Inglis or Israel Folau- type athleticism and he’s no where near that talented.

 

[Richard Hope]

Cheika favourite, but if they can't get or afford him then Manenti or Raiwalui are the way to go, and it lines up with the fans thoughts

 

[Wilson]

I back Raiwalui, but a reader poll in the SMH should have absolutely no bearing on who coaches the tahs next.

 

[Richard Hope]

I back Raiwalui, but a reader poll in the SMH should have absolutely no bearing on who coaches the tahs next.

correct, but interesting nonetheless. Riwalui started a job with world rugby 6 months ago, so unlikely.

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

Good to see the SMH gets some traction in Coogee.

How the hell does Hoiles get 12%

 

[Oldgoldminer]

My only issue with Sua'ali'i is that he’s shown so little in attack (although oddly he’s been tough). For the hype that he received as a schoolboy you’d expect Greg Inglis or Israel Folau- type athleticism and he’s no where near that talented.

Let’s hold that judgement until we see him play against some union defence. I think he might just eat some of them next year.

 

[Rob42]

I'm getting keener on John Manenti. The 7s players that have come over to Super Rugby in the last couple of years have shown good basic skills, and he should be familiar with working within a larger program, managing assistants, etc. And a good history of team performance.

 

[Richard Hope]

I'm getting keener on John Manenti. The 7s players that have come over to Super Rugby in the last couple of years have shown good basic skills, and he should be familiar with working within a larger program, managing assistants, etc. And a good history of team performance.

Yeah had a look, his record is very good at all levels and he's well liked and respected around the traps

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

True. They do get a lot of elite youth though.

The knock could be that he has less 15s experience than DC. Went from Eastwood to the 7s program. Success at Eastwood though.

 

[fatprop]

My only issue with Sua'ali'i is that he’s shown so little in attack (although oddly he’s been tough). For the hype that he received as a schoolboy you’d expect Greg Inglis or Israel Folau- type athleticism and he’s no where near that talented.

More Folau than Inglis, I stood next to him for a few moments at a Tahs game, the guy's a beast

His highlight reel suggests winger to me initially

And "if" he can pass both ways, kick effectively, can "defend" (not just tackle) and has a rugby brain etc etc he can do more important jobs

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

I think the Wing is a great place to start. Hope he brings the League looking for work attitude as well. He is a big unit who I think has the ability to be like Reiko Ioane over someone like Folau.

Most of his Rugby highlights/hype are from when he was 15 and playing 1st XV so I wouldn't be too critical of anything he does fine skill wise.

His performance at the RLWC for Samoa at Fullback showed a lot of all round skill and ability to organise. Think he would have picked up a lot of footy nous from guys like Tedesco, Manu and Keary.

 

[Rob42]

He trained with the AU 7s team whilst he was at school, they were impressed with his ability and physicality even at that age.

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

Souths said the same thing when he did pre season with them while at school.

 

[RugbyReg]

I'm getting keener on John Manenti. The 7s players that have come over to Super Rugby in the last couple of years have shown good basic skills, and he should be familiar with working within a larger program, managing assistants, etc. And a good history of team performance.

really important connection to the Shute Shield too.....


seriously though I think this would be a great call.

 

[Thalium]

really important connection to the Shute Shield too.....


seriously though I think this would be a great call.

The question is would he even be interested? going from the success of the sevens program to the Tahs would be a hard sell

 

[pnut]

The message I am conveying is that basically no one of any quality gets to age 21 or thereabouts as someone who is unknown to the system. We are not just unaware of kids who are fantastic players that suddenly become a surprise when they make it at the next level.

I am not ignoring players who don't show outstanding talent before being 21. We simply do not have the resources to provide a (semi) professional pathway for these kids in the hope that they will become outstanding in the future. We have to pick and choose which players we offer these contracts to already out of the kids who look pretty clearly like they are among the best in their cohort. If we had a lot more money to pay people then you could take a punt on more kids who have some attributes that indicate they could succeed later but perhaps have only just taken up the sport or haven't had good coaching etc.

You also need to accept the financial metrics of what teams can pay players vs what they have elsewhere in their life. If someone is 25 or older and would only warrant a contract paying them as a fringe Super Rugby player then it's almost certainly a bad option for them and the professional team. A bunch of players stick to playing club rugby only because they are trying to develop a professional career at the same time.

So basically keep it the same as the tahs have done for 10 years. Yep makes sense. Turn them into an academy side for RA. That will bring the crowds. Or tv dollars

 

[eastman]

So basically keep it the same as the tahs have done for 10 years. Yep makes sense. Turn them into an academy side for RA. That will bring the crowds. Or tv dollars

What’s your solution pnut?

 

[eastman]

More Folau than Inglis, I stood next to him for a few moments at a Tahs game, the guy's a beast

His highlight reel suggests winger to me initially

And "if" he can pass both ways, kick effectively, can "defend" (not just tackle) and has a rugby brain etc etc he can do more important jobs

So if he can pass both ways and kicl but not break a tackle it’s fine? We have Bayley Kuenzle to do that for a lot less cash. He’s getting paid X factor cash so he needs to do more.

 

[Oldgoldminer]

I think the Wing is a great place to start. Hope he brings the League looking for work attitude as well. He is a big unit who I think has the ability to be like Reiko Ioane over someone like Folau.

Most of his Rugby highlights/hype are from when he was 15 and playing 1st XV so I wouldn't be too critical of anything he does fine skill wise.

His performance at the RLWC for Samoa at Fullback showed a lot of all round skill and ability to organise. Think he would have picked up a lot of footy nous from guys like Tedesco, Manu and Keary.

He is not going to get paid that money to play wing. That’s crazy

 

[KOB1987]

He is not going to get paid that money to play wing. That’s crazy

RA or Joe Schmidt aren’t paying it though. The benefactor was happy to part with his daily interest income to bring JS back to our game which is what matters. He doesn’t care in the slightest what position JS is picked in, as long as he’s out there somewhere.