The Ghost of Raelene
David Codey (61)
Pushing the chips in on Bowen long term I feel. Interested to see what happens with Harrison being injured again. I’m of the opinion you sign him cheaply if possible and see what happens.
Waratahs 2024
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
7137
Alex Ross (28)
Not enthused about losing Harris. I think he has the potential to exhibit all of Swintons best attributes without the boneheaded penalties and cards.
I’ve tried to remain positive about Swinton and feel that he will mature. But the latest incident was just about the last straw
I’ve tried to remain positive about Swinton and feel that he will mature. But the latest incident was just about the last straw
Crashy
John Solomon (38)
I agree re Swinton. I'm sure he's a good bloke and all that, but he has let his team and fans down time and time again. As a Tahs supporter I honestly don't want to see him in the team knowing that we're likely to see another yellow/red card / citing / penalty at a key time. I think maybe some soul searching overseas might be a solution, as he can't go on like this. Being aggressive is one this - but a complete liability is another.
The Ghost of Raelene
David Codey (61)
I agree. Harris still has a very high ceiling. Glad to see him stay in Australia though.
Swinton is nothing but a liability now when in the 23. He also hasn't been the most durable player. 27 games since 2018 isn't really value for money. We laugh at Vunivalu being off the field alot but he's played 25 games since 2021
Without the boneheads penalties and cards? Sure he’s not at Swinton level but he’s done some dumb stuff.
The Ghost of Raelene
David Codey (61)
I feel like Harris is an athlete that is still developing as a Rugby player. Sounds absurd at the professional level but I think he can continue to improve steadily if coached well. Cron is a guy that can do that.
kiap
Steve Williams (59)
It doesn't need any "both sides" shade tho.
There's dumb stuff.
And then there's insane in the membrane.
Marce
John Hipwell (52)
That's the kind of centre RA needs
Yeah. He may not be Swinton level. But I’ve seen him do some Swain level stuff.
kiap
Steve Williams (59)
Was it after he got his cap torn off and hair mussed?
Dctarget
Tim Horan (67)
Good stuff. I'm enjoying the shuffling of the players out west.Gleeson resigns to 25 and Donaldson and Harris shown the door
Waratahs lock down golden Gleeson as Donaldson heads west
Rising star Langi Gleeson has extended his NSW and RA contract until 2025, but Ben Donaldson is set to sign with the Western Force.amp.smh.com.au
Gleeson re-signing is brilliant, I watched his interview and was impressed with how well spoken he is. Keep him in Aus, could be a future captain.
It'll be weird to have a Hooper-less Waratahs next year. Even weirder that you've re-signed Swinton, let the bloke go decapitate some poor Japanese fellas for millions. Is Lee-Warner coming across to be a bench warmer? 4. Holloway 5. Amatosero/Hanigan 6. Swinton/Hanigan 7. Gamble 8. Gleeson 20. Lee-Warner?
Bowen and Teddy Wilson are probably the highest priority long term signings for the Tahs. They're absolutely the future of the team.
The Ghost of Raelene
David Codey (61)
Wilson signed this year didn't he?
He was fantastic in the U20s on Monday. Controlled pace of play and playmaking from 9 which I haven't seen for a while. Those 2 could be a great package into the future.
He was fantastic in the U20s on Monday. Controlled pace of play and playmaking from 9 which I haven't seen for a while. Those 2 could be a great package into the future.
I can understand not prioritising the retention of Harris. His skillset is more suited to playing 8 and he's clearly behind Gleeson now.
Hanigan and Swinton provide better balance at 6 in the backrow. Fergus Lee-Warner is also vying for either the 6 jersey or lock.
I think Wilson is only signed for this year.
I couldn't be higher on him. He's excellent and my way too early prediction is that Wilson and Bowen will be the Wallaby 9 and 10 by the time the 2027 RWC rolls around. I think they are both generational talents.
Hanigan and Swinton provide better balance at 6 in the backrow. Fergus Lee-Warner is also vying for either the 6 jersey or lock.
I think Wilson is only signed for this year.
I couldn't be higher on him. He's excellent and my way too early prediction is that Wilson and Bowen will be the Wallaby 9 and 10 by the time the 2027 RWC rolls around. I think they are both generational talents.
Marce
John Hipwell (52)
I hope this comes true. We already heard it many times and doesn't end up happening
John S
Peter Fenwicke (45)
Not so much revolving door as making space - I don't think it was feasible really of the Tah's hanging onto three fly-halves.
They've now got to make sure the ones they've got can improve form and fitness.
Drew
Bob Davidson (42)
I had heard a while back that Harrison might be off the Force. Guess that’s changed
The Ghost of Raelene
David Codey (61)
Would be a risk to have Pasitoa and Harrison both on your books coming off Knee recos
7137
Alex Ross (28)
Force were gunshy on picking him up with his injury history. But I expect it’s the reason Tahs are going to be able to keep him cheap