Waratahs 2016
- Thread starter Hugh Jarse
- Start date
- Status
If he hadn't produced an outstanding scrum in the last two minutes against the Stormers our season would be over.
Not saying he should be retained for next year but he's been pretty good for us this season.
Hugh Jarse
Rocky Elsom (76)
^^^ Wasn't there some talk of re-badging Tolu Latu as a LHP or was that just someone's wishful thinking, based on him playing there for a short period in the Shute Shield Finals last year.
Que? Robinson's been a LHP for yonks. Anyways, it's strongly rumoured Benn's retiring after his recent eye injury.
You don't mean Reece, do you.....?
I think he meant Robertson.
Hawko
Tony Shaw (54)
Irony just does not translate to the written word.
If Latu hadn't got injured he could easily still be ahead of Roach.
It's interesting how an injury can give someone a chance they otherwise wouldn't have had and change the pecking order.
It's interesting how an injury can give someone a chance they otherwise wouldn't have had and change the pecking order.
If TPN goes offshore the Tahs are left with three hookers: Fitzpatrick, Latu and Roach. Every Super squad needs three hookers, the Tahs should start to develop the more promising hookers in Sydney for when one of those three leave or go down injured.
I presumed you did but couldn't resist the temptation. Robertson's only 24 this year, he should be left to develop his craft at THP with a view to donning a gold jumper in the next five years. Tom's played extraordinarily well in his debut year, let's hope he gets better. Once he gets his medical studies out of the way he could prove to be something special.
I presumed you did but couldn't resist the temptation. Robertson's only 24 this year, he should be left to develop his craft at THP with a view to donning a gold jumper in the next five years. Tom's played extraordinarily well in his debut year, let's hope he gets better. Once he gets his medical studies out of the way he could prove to be something special.
Hugh Jarse
Rocky Elsom (76)
^^^ In the Next Gen of hookers off "The Pathway" for Tahs are David Vea (Aust U20) but he seems to have fallen out of favour at the Randi-Wix who are using a Pensioner as their first Grade hooker, and Folau Fainga'a (U20 2015).
After that we are looking at Schoolboy, Gen Blue and Woodies own Ed Craig, Gordon's and NH Ray's Wilkinson and U20 Gen Blue and Stars Moore from The Corporation. Outside of these folk, you are reaching down into the Class of 2015 or looking for a bolter from clubland.
After that we are looking at Schoolboy, Gen Blue and Woodies own Ed Craig, Gordon's and NH Ray's Wilkinson and U20 Gen Blue and Stars Moore from The Corporation. Outside of these folk, you are reaching down into the Class of 2015 or looking for a bolter from clubland.
Folau Fainga'a almost debuted when we had TPN and Latu out. They went with Hilterbrand instead.
He's definitely on their radar though.
Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk
He's definitely on their radar though.
Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk
wamberal
Phil Kearns (64)
I hope you watched today's Shute Shield match.
WorkingClassRugger
Michael Lynagh (62)
The Uni scrum isn't what it used to be. Not so for a couple of seasons actually. I watched the Wicks get the upperhand on it earlier this season. Also, saw that same Wicks pack comfortably match and at time out scrum the Woodies pack. Also earlier this season.
Shute Shield seems to be a level where pot plant props are more beneficial than they are at Super Rugby level.
It seems the upside of having a really strong scrum at club rugby level against the downside of having a couple of players who don't add much around the park is a good trade off. Certainly the pace of the game means sides can get away with it to a greater degree.
At Super Rugby level the teams with average scrums seem to get found out less and the need to have everyone contributing around the field weighs more heavily.
At least that's my observation.
It seems the upside of having a really strong scrum at club rugby level against the downside of having a couple of players who don't add much around the park is a good trade off. Certainly the pace of the game means sides can get away with it to a greater degree.
At Super Rugby level the teams with average scrums seem to get found out less and the need to have everyone contributing around the field weighs more heavily.
At least that's my observation.
formerflanker
Ken Catchpole (46)
Without stats to support my observation I can only go on gut feel - that refs ping poorly performing scrums a lot in Super Rugby and teams work hard to get full arm penalties. Whereas in club rugby the refs are more inclined to let the game flow and ignore some scrum issues.
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
TPN has spent alot of time on the side line over recent years, what are his plans, is he eyeing off the next RWC? That last game against the Chiefs, he and the whole pack played well.
I wonder how Dave Porecki's schooling has gone in the Northern Hemisphere as well?
- Status