We're picking based on their best games for us in a Wallabies jersey? Then I'd say it's as follows:
- James Slipper (2014 Rugby Championship - Game 2 v South Africa)
- Stephen Moore (2013 EOYT - Wales)
- Sekope Kepu (2014 Mid Year Tests - Game 2 v France)
- Kane Douglas (2015 World Cup - Wales)
- Sam Carter (2014 Mid Year Tests - Game 1 v France)
- Scott Fardy (2015 Bledisloe 1)
- David Pocock (2011 World Cup QF)
- Sean McMahon (2017 Bledisloe 3)
- Will Genia (2013 Lions Series - Game 2)
- Bernard Foley (2015 World Cup - England)
- Joe Tomane (2013 Rugby Championship - Game 2 v Argentina)
- Matt To'omua (2013 EOYT - Italy)
- Tevita Kuridrani (2016 EOYT - Wales)
- Dane Haylett-Petty (2016 Mid Year Tests - Game 1 v England)
- Israel Folau (2014 Mid Year Tests - Game 1 v France)
This is a fun game, though. Gone back over the history of the G&GR player of the year and had a look.
I'd throw some other options in the mix - a few curly ones here.
4. Will Skelton vs France in Sydney in 2014.
4. Sitaleki Timani vs New Zealand in Auckland in 2012
6. Rocky Elsom vs South Africa in 2010
8. Radike Samo vs New Zealand in Brisbane 2011
6. Scott Fardy vs New Zealand in Wellington 2014
6. Jack Dempsey vs New Zealand in Brisbane in 2017
15. Kurtley Beale vs South Africa in South Africa in 2010
12. Matt Giteau vs England in RWC 2015
14. Israel Folau vs Lions in Brisbane in 2014
The one real change I'd make is to turf out Tomane or DHP and put Folau to the wing (that Lions game was one of the performances of the decade), and Beale at FB (those South Africa games were both pretty special).
.