Wallabies vs England, Sydney, 3rd Test, 25 June @ 8:00pm
- Thread starter The torpedo
- Start date
- Status
Brumby Runner
Jason Little (69)
My son wants to know, if the Wallabies lose tonight will there be a Cheixit?
Viking
Mark Ella (57)
My son wants to know, if the Wallabies lose tonight will there be a Cheixit?
haha doubt it.
Although a 3 - 0 loss to England at home is far worse then 2 - 1 Loss to the B&I Lions.
Mr Doug
Dick Tooth (41)
Can't say I'm approaching tonight's test with any confidence. I'm normally a positive person, however, after tipping an Australian win in the two previous tests, I'm going the other way, tonight. I hope I'm wrong, but I think we will get another lesson in the scrums, (the poms use their bodies, we use our feet, [and dig up the turf]), the lineouts and the breakdown.
No confidence in "Big Willy", but happy for him to prove me wrong.
Izzy still has allot to learn about the game of Rugby, (still has a "confidence problem" with his running and his kicking), and Phipps is just not up to it!!
No confidence in "Big Willy", but happy for him to prove me wrong.
Izzy still has allot to learn about the game of Rugby, (still has a "confidence problem" with his running and his kicking), and Phipps is just not up to it!!
Ash
Michael Lynagh (62)
I feel like there is a lot of panicking and hoping for some luck in the selections for this game.
Cheika seems desperate for some game breakers and big bodies and is taking a lot of risks in bringing them in.
Skelton in the forwards, who has had one really good game all year for the Tahs. You could say the same about Palu, but he's one of the last men standing at 8. There's a bit risk with Skelton, as he doesn't seem as fit this year and won't keep up with a high tempo game. This pack of English forwards has been very good, and you feel could very well expose some of Skelton's deficiencies.
Simmons in for Carter, who I thought had one of his best games in gold. Carter has been fairly lack luster this year for the Brumbies, but didn't deserve to be dropped for his game last week. (I didn't think that Simmons deserved to be dropped after an OK 20 minutes before an injury the first game either, but there you go). Simmons coming back in seems a selection to make up for Skelton's deficiencies. Not a fan of this chopping and changing of players who don't deserve to be dropped.
Coleman, who was in the shadow squad, comes in with no injury. Good luck to Coleman, but calling Coleman in is an interesting call. Horwill, for example, was called back from the UK, played well in the first game, and is rewarded by getting dropped for the rest of the series, including getting shunted behind someone from the shadow squad. Cheika seems desperate for another big body, and has decided it isn't Arnold for now.
To'omua coming in after being injured for a couple of months, and not being in very good form before being injured. I can understand the desire for a second play maker, and Lilo hasn't performed at 12 in his chances in two tests. But we have parachuted in To'omua (who I am a big fan of at 12) as the first game back from injury and with no form before it. Unfortunately I can't see this ending too well.
Which has led to the dropping of Kerevi entirely from the 23, arguably our second best back in this series behind Folau (maybe DHP too). Harsh reward for the test rookie.
On the bench Naiyaravoro is drafted in. Cheika is desperate for a point of difference with another large body, but again it has led to the selection of a guy without a lot of form and seemingly lacking fitness. Big Naiya wasn't fantastic in Scotland from what I've heard, so it's apparently another selection on little form but plenty of hope.
The other concern is some key players in the team struggling for form, like Moore, Kuridrani, Phipps.
Cheika seems to be digging for some change and a point of difference, but it looks like a big gamble on players with little form to hold onto some pride.
I have no confidence that we can get the job done tonight, and unfortunately if I was forced to put money on this game, it wouldn't be on us.
Cheika seems desperate for some game breakers and big bodies and is taking a lot of risks in bringing them in.
Skelton in the forwards, who has had one really good game all year for the Tahs. You could say the same about Palu, but he's one of the last men standing at 8. There's a bit risk with Skelton, as he doesn't seem as fit this year and won't keep up with a high tempo game. This pack of English forwards has been very good, and you feel could very well expose some of Skelton's deficiencies.
Simmons in for Carter, who I thought had one of his best games in gold. Carter has been fairly lack luster this year for the Brumbies, but didn't deserve to be dropped for his game last week. (I didn't think that Simmons deserved to be dropped after an OK 20 minutes before an injury the first game either, but there you go). Simmons coming back in seems a selection to make up for Skelton's deficiencies. Not a fan of this chopping and changing of players who don't deserve to be dropped.
Coleman, who was in the shadow squad, comes in with no injury. Good luck to Coleman, but calling Coleman in is an interesting call. Horwill, for example, was called back from the UK, played well in the first game, and is rewarded by getting dropped for the rest of the series, including getting shunted behind someone from the shadow squad. Cheika seems desperate for another big body, and has decided it isn't Arnold for now.
To'omua coming in after being injured for a couple of months, and not being in very good form before being injured. I can understand the desire for a second play maker, and Lilo hasn't performed at 12 in his chances in two tests. But we have parachuted in To'omua (who I am a big fan of at 12) as the first game back from injury and with no form before it. Unfortunately I can't see this ending too well.
Which has led to the dropping of Kerevi entirely from the 23, arguably our second best back in this series behind Folau (maybe DHP too). Harsh reward for the test rookie.
On the bench Naiyaravoro is drafted in. Cheika is desperate for a point of difference with another large body, but again it has led to the selection of a guy without a lot of form and seemingly lacking fitness. Big Naiya wasn't fantastic in Scotland from what I've heard, so it's apparently another selection on little form but plenty of hope.
The other concern is some key players in the team struggling for form, like Moore, Kuridrani, Phipps.
Cheika seems to be digging for some change and a point of difference, but it looks like a big gamble on players with little form to hold onto some pride.
I have no confidence that we can get the job done tonight, and unfortunately if I was forced to put money on this game, it wouldn't be on us.
dru
David Wilson (68)
Have a look at Englands LO stats through the 6 Nations. Whatever the heights their LO is very good. And they are out-kicking us.
We start with two primary jumpers, Simmo and Fardy. With skel we have only only one jumping lock, and you need to lean on your backrowers just to match what you normally get from locks. But its not just the inclusion of Skel, its the selected back row. Baring Fardy the back row are not renound jumpers even at Super Rugby level. If we had, say Higgers at 8, you might not be as concerned.
General wisdom is you need 4 jumpers.
Pedrolicus
Dick Tooth (41)
The main point is that any player that Skelton replaces would be a better lineout technician. So you have to put two jumpers in the backrow to compensate. We haven't done this, banking on Skelton and McMahon's general play skills to make up for this deficit.
I think Carter should have been on the bench, no disrespect to Coleman though. Sam would just be better lineout insurance, having called well in Melbourne he arguably had a better game than Simmons did in Brisbane.
While there's a lot of talk about Big Willy, I'm more excited about see Naiyaravoro have a run late in the game. If we're still in touch he might be a game breaker.
The torpedo
Peter Fenwicke (45)
England will win this easily - the haven't lost all year and will continue this streak. Eddie is inside Cheiks head (metaphorically) and the poms are confident while we are not.
England by 27
England by 27
it helps when most of the pommy players are outclassing and playing their opposite wallabies playersEngland will win this easily - the haven't lost all year and will continue this streak. Eddie is inside Cheiks head (metaphorically) and the poms are confident while we are not.
England by 27
The torpedo
Peter Fenwicke (45)
Foley
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
These English can play when they want to
- Status