• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Wallabies 2025

dru

Jason Little (69)
I still say JAS at inside centre. Itikau is the best OUTSIDE centre we have. You shouldn't weaken a strength to strengthen a weakness.

I'm resigned to it. JAS is one of the first picked simply on his athleticism. Ikitau is both a better 13 and a better 12 (though he is much better at 13 imo). You could look to shift JAS wide but we are now pretty strong there and may have Nawaqanitwase returning at some point. Petaia as well.

Overall the coach needs to put the strongest overall team on the field. That can well involve someone shifted out of their best position if the team is stronger for it.
 

TSR

Simon Poidevin (60)
I reckon Ikitau is playing better at 12 than he was at 13, simply because he is far more involved. He has still thrown plenty of passes to set up tries and line breaks so it’s not like his skills with setting up his outside player are being wasted.

I assume he’s favourite for JEM and he’s been at 12 all year. Quite possible he would have been favourite playing 13 too but apart from the last game he’s been great all year.

I’d think the only threats to JEM would be McReight & Hooper. Jorgo, Wilson & Frost will probably pick up decent votes too but I don’t think and of those 3 will top the voting.
 

Tomthumb

Jim Lenehan (48)
I think we are setting ourselves up for disappointment and setting Gordon up to fail the way we are talking about him. He had one good super season for one of the worst teams in the comp, and was very up and down for the Wallabies. Not to mention his goal kicking was absolutely woeful

I hope he comes back and hope he does well, but he hasn’t shown anything to be viewed as this superstar
 

Rugby110

Frank Row (1)
I think we are setting ourselves up for disappointment and setting Gordon up to fail the way we are talking about him. He had one good super season for one of the worst teams in the comp, and was very up and down for the Wallabies. Not to mention his goal kicking was absolutely woeful

I hope he comes back and hope he does well, but he hasn’t shown anything to be viewed as this superstar
I don’t know if you have noticed, we don’t have the luxury of Finn Smith, George Ford and Marcus Smith as selection options. The old saying, if nothing changes then nothing changes. No one has said superstar in these discussions. Phil Waugh is making smart moves and backed by Schmidt and Kiss.
 

The Ghost of Raelene

John Eales (66)
I think we are setting ourselves up for disappointment and setting Gordon up to fail the way we are talking about him. He had one good super season for one of the worst teams in the comp, and was very up and down for the Wallabies. Not to mention his goal kicking was absolutely woeful

I hope he comes back and hope he does well, but he hasn’t shown anything to be viewed as this superstar
Happens with every player that is suddenly distant. Oh the memories.

Same goes for all those stories of your Dads run away try it was 10m, 30, length of the field these days.

With the group of Flyhalves I have no issue with him being in the squad. Nobody better is missing out if he's included.
 

Major Tom

Bob Davidson (42)
I think we are setting ourselves up for disappointment and setting Gordon up to fail the way we are talking about him. He had one good super season for one of the worst teams in the comp, and was very up and down for the Wallabies. Not to mention his goal kicking was absolutely woeful

I hope he comes back and hope he does well, but he hasn’t shown anything to be viewed as this superstar

If we think single-handedly he’s going to fix the team, then yes we’re setting ourselves up for failure. If we recognise that he’s a very good option at flyhalf, who would be there if he didn’t go to league then I think we’re in a good space. I don’t know what else you expect RA to do? Clearly, 10 is a concern for us. He fits the age profile and physical profile that we want from a playmaker. It makes complete sense.
 

Homer

Johnnie Wallace (23)
There is no one else so give Carter a crack. Can tackle and kick, seems to have a calm head, was messed around by Eddie so who knows what he is capable of. Also with him, JAS and Marky Mark (Nawaqanitawase) we finally have some size in the backs again like the good old days.
Mcdermott, Carter, MM, Len, JAS, Jorgo and Wright looks like a fairly awesome backline.
There is speed to burn, height to contest kicks, tonnes of counter attack ability etc
 

The Ghost of Raelene

John Eales (66)
Throw in Petaia who's no small fish... Guys like Pietsch also play with a big guys power which is probably why he was a Schools rep no.8

Big boys smashing it up with the likes of McDermott, Wright and Jorgo lurking off the hip is a nice prospect.
 

Tomthumb

Jim Lenehan (48)
If we think single-handedly he’s going to fix the team, then yes we’re setting ourselves up for failure. If we recognise that he’s a very good option at flyhalf, who would be there if he didn’t go to league then I think we’re in a good space. I don’t know what else you expect RA to do? Clearly, 10 is a concern for us. He fits the age profile and physical profile that we want from a playmaker. It makes complete sense.
Yes but how patient are we going to be with him? We haven't been particularly patient with any of our young 10's, and Gordon has barely had any physical contact let alone game time in the last 18 months

If he comes in and looks worse than Tane Edmed (which isn't unrealistic considering the circumstances), how long a leash will he be given until we give up on him like all the others?

I'd prefer him be brought in slowly and given time to be ready. He wasn't experienced when he was playing Rugby, let alone now
 

Adam84

Tim Horan (67)
So RA paying $100k release fee for Carter’s contract.

Given he didn’t play in 2025, and ‘assuming’ he would have had the same issue had he stayed in rugby, it’s worked out a pretty good little financial exchange this one. RA have effectively paid $100k for the 2025 season he was out injured with Titans covering the rest ;)
 

Dctarget

David Wilson (68)
The revisionism on Carter is interesting. Lots of us commented that when he left that he was a huge loss, we aren't remembering fondly years later. Remember Lolesio shouting out his name? Carter is genuine. His flaws are very obvious but he has skills his competitors don't. It's not like they're paying Sua'ali'i's salary for him. Also.. our flyhalves are terrible.
 

Slim 293

George Smith (75)
Carter Gordon could be the Wallabies’ best flyhalf in the future, but he was far from it when he left…

Lolesio certainly had the last laugh there…

But it’s definitely worth having him back.
 

Red Runner

Alfred Walker (16)
The revisionism on Carter is interesting. Lots of us commented that when he left that he was a huge loss, we aren't remembering fondly years later. Remember Lolesio shouting out his name? Carter is genuine. His flaws are very obvious but he has skills his competitors don't. It's not like they're paying Sua'ali'i's salary for him. Also.. our flyhalves are terrible.

Fuck that was a sad indictment on him I reckon. Shows a complete lack of temperament that you need for a top level 10. Not that I think Carter has it. Its one of his known 'flaws' among the rugby community.
 

Dctarget

David Wilson (68)
Speaking of Lolesio, what's the latest on him?

Still injured? Will he play his season in Japan? Is it confirmed he's coming back for RWC27? If so, when available?
 

rugbyAU

Ken Catchpole (46)
Speaking of Lolesio, what's the latest on him?

Still injured? Will he play his season in Japan? Is it confirmed he's coming back for RWC27? If so, when available?
Definitely not confirmed for RWC, probably a good chance the Japanese club terminates his contract
 
Top