Tomikin
David Codey (61)
Agree everything but the finishing , the dude seems to always be bottling it. But he deserves to be there... Lancaster going be selected before him I feel.
Wallabies 2024
- Thread starter rugbyAU
- Start date
Had almost forgot about this, far out.
dru
Tim Horan (67)
Appreciate these posts (and your others in this thread), BR.
Wales gain double points as an away team. We'll go close to dropping out of the 10 with 2 loses. If we lose to Georgia, which is a game we should definitely post our best 23, I can't see how we stay ahead of Fiji. For those not watching the rankings closely, we lose 1 win 1 against Wales and the chances are they go ahead of us and we drop to 10. Lose to Georgia away and Fiji goes to 10.
I'd agree that Schmidt is not going to provide the drivel that EJ (Eddie Jones) did, but I'm not impressed at what seems a lack of drive to get into training. Further to your note on time, I doubt there is a game plan of any depth that can be implemented in two weeks, the same two weeks that you are sorting out who the 23 are. I don't think that could be done at school level.
The Wallabies dropped below "meh" under EJ (Eddie Jones), it seems unlikely that they raise above it in the next few tests. Even with Schmidt.
Wales gain double points as an away team. We'll go close to dropping out of the 10 with 2 loses. If we lose to Georgia, which is a game we should definitely post our best 23, I can't see how we stay ahead of Fiji. For those not watching the rankings closely, we lose 1 win 1 against Wales and the chances are they go ahead of us and we drop to 10. Lose to Georgia away and Fiji goes to 10.
I'd agree that Schmidt is not going to provide the drivel that EJ (Eddie Jones) did, but I'm not impressed at what seems a lack of drive to get into training. Further to your note on time, I doubt there is a game plan of any depth that can be implemented in two weeks, the same two weeks that you are sorting out who the 23 are. I don't think that could be done at school level.
The Wallabies dropped below "meh" under EJ (Eddie Jones), it seems unlikely that they raise above it in the next few tests. Even with Schmidt.
dru
Tim Horan (67)
I have yet to notice a better judge of wingers on G&GR than Derpus. They may be there, but they don't come to mind.
duckbill
Sydney Middleton (9)
I had high hopes of Schmidt after his various media appearances, and then he goes and picks Beale???
He's really hasn't shown anything different to his past performances to warrant a call up, he was absolutely woeful against the Reds and just based on that should have been avoided.
The team gets a bit of a pass from me as an overall score, with the Beale selection being the main outlier that I just don't get
He's really hasn't shown anything different to his past performances to warrant a call up, he was absolutely woeful against the Reds and just based on that should have been avoided.
The team gets a bit of a pass from me as an overall score, with the Beale selection being the main outlier that I just don't get
rugbyAU
Colin Windon (37)
Exactly it's a silly selection, just a feel god story and a headline.
He's only played a few games for the Force and like I said he was okay but certainly not demanding of a test spot
Srgnt Short Ball
Herbert Moran (7)
What are everyone's thoughts on the July tests Squad? Keen to hear.
Srgnt Short Ball
Herbert Moran (7)
really says something about the state of Australian Rugby when we pick 35-year-old outside backs.
Srgnt Short Ball
Herbert Moran (7)
what a game that was!
rugbyAU
Colin Windon (37)
yeah and someone who hasn't played many pro rugby games recently (I think he played Randwick not long ago), he wouldn't be in any other Tier 1 side
duckbill
Sydney Middleton (9)
Even more frustrating if that's all it is. The junkyard dog would have been a much better option
It is a good squad for the player pool available. Schmidt selected based purely on form and the no OS criteria. He selected 13 uncapped players, with Hodgman being an exception.
I agree with Beale's selection, he is 35 but has played 95 tests, Wallabies don't have this level of Test experience, Beale played a handful of games for the Force but he was bloody effective.
Junkyard Dog not getting selected is because, as Schmidt said, at the Test level you don't have a lot of space or time. JYD lacks physicality and Schmidt wants him to build on that, which shows he is planning.
Schmidt has a clear game plan, he is not EJ (Eddie Jones), I believe the focus will be on straightforward forward play with a commitment to the breakdown and ball security. Mauling is a must when 5m out, heavy focus on field position. He will run a plan similar to The Reds.
Schmidt is a conservative, tactical Coach. I Watched Wales v Bok, Welsh forwards look poor, backs are uninspiring. We will go 3-0 in the July series.
PhilClinton
Geoff Shaw (53)
Effective at what? Plodding around in the backfield for a team that won 4 games all year?
Experience for the sake of experience doesn’t necessarily add value. We aren’t talking about a bloke who’s played in the golden era of rugby and is going to galvanise a young team.
Looking at his stats he’s won around 60% of games he’s played in for the Wallabies. Time to move these blokes along.
Wilson
Michael Lynagh (62)
Particularly given he'll still get a bit of international exposure against Wales and Tonga for the Reds, so he has an idea of the level he has to build towards
Joe Blow
Peter Sullivan (51)
60% sounds golden to me. I’d take that in 2024 and beyond.
I agree that Beale is not the answer but no doubt Schmidt wants to put a little experience in the squad. We are lacking experience in the second row at hooker and in the backs in general. Slipper and AAA in the forwards and White and Beale in the backs will be the senior players in the group. Thats not to say that they will be selected in every or any 23.
dru
Tim Horan (67)
I'm not particularly bothered by Beale's age - to misquote, " if you're good enough you are young enough". If he is good enough. I also don't buy his experience in WA being without value. I thought Quade's experience and caps were valuable in a Wallaby squad so it's only consistent to hold the same thinking here.
At the same time I'd be lying if I didn't admit he makes me uncomfortable because, you know, Beale.
At the same time I'd be lying if I didn't admit he makes me uncomfortable because, you know, Beale.
Sword of Justice
Phil Hardcastle (33)
The Force got worse as the season went on which coincided with his signing. I didn’t see anything to say he is good enough. Especially in a sport that values strength in contact more than ever.
Ultimately it is just one selection and Kellaway and Wright are technically converted wingers though.