Wallabies 2024
- Thread starter rugbyAU
- Start date
dusk
Vay Wilson (31)
I don't know if we'll see Swain in a gold jersey for a long time. What he did against NZ in 2022 was horrifying.
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Adam84
Rod McCall (65)
That incident aside, Swain and Swinton don’t know how to effectively balance between what they think playing ‘hard’ is and playing within the rules, if someone can coach the stupid penalties and cards out of their game then they could be an asset to the Wallabies, until then they’re both liabilities whose talent doesn’t warrant the risk.
eastman
John Solomon (38)
It’s funny that this reputation for yellow cards came from 3 games on a single tour, despite having not received any cards prior or subsequently.
He was never ’exposed’ in his previous body of work including a decent series against the French the year earlier.
The reality is Gordon is not nearly as bad as people make him out to be (nor is he great either). He was also getting selected by Rennie during a time where we occasionally won games- so maybe there’s something there.
upthereds#!
Peter Johnson (47)
How was he for Australia A series and Baabaas discipline wise? Play wise he was great.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Didn't watch so I'd be lying to say anything.
Imagine if he got through a season for the Tahs with only say....1 yellow and injury free. He's ahead of a lot of blokes that could wear the 6 if you just compare attributes.
I'll always be scared of a brain snap. Especially when it seems he can be baited into some of them.
Imagine if he got through a season for the Tahs with only say....1 yellow and injury free. He's ahead of a lot of blokes that could wear the 6 if you just compare attributes.
I'll always be scared of a brain snap. Especially when it seems he can be baited into some of them.
Highlander35
Steve Williams (59)
I'm like 85% sure he got himself yellow carded in the last 6 or 7 minutes of the Tonga loss for losing his head well after the ball left the area.
LeCheese
Greg Davis (50)
Sure did
LeCheese
Greg Davis (50)
3 Yellows and 1 Red in 9 appearances for Australia - a 44% hit rate - sounds a lot like a pattern of behaviour.
Add in another 2 Yellows and another Red across a few seasons of Super and, well....
The most glaring issue is that they have mostly been cards as a result of acts of stupidity
Edit: this is for Swinton, not Gordon - I got lost in the context
Last edited:
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
It's waaaay to many for your Halfback. Absolutely crippling to have a position like that binned.
I think he's another guy that falls into the category of "first class" player and not a Test player to borrow from Cricket again.
I think he's another guy that falls into the category of "first class" player and not a Test player to borrow from Cricket again.
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
Those sound like Swinton's stats rather than Gordon's, but 3 yellow cards in 20 tests (most off the bench) is still way too high for a halfback. He also has a reasonably high penalty rate in Super Rugby. As @The Ghost of Raelene says, it's the one position you really can't afford to have spending regular time in the bin, you just don't have any coverage as standard.
LeCheese
Greg Davis (50)
Yeah just realised I missed the context after Ghost’s post - edited to reflect that.
Agreed re Gordon - not worth the risk, especially when there are other 9s available of roughly equal standard
Proud Pig
Tom Lawton (22)
We don't have the talent in the squad to carry guys that are card risks. 15 on 15 we are struggling put a Swain and a Swinton in the 15 and the odds of being a player down is too great. The big issue is that both have shown that the opposition can get into their heads and at International level there are some first rate bastards that will enjoy every second of it. Etzebeth would set up a permanent camp in Swinton's frontal lobe.
AdelaideRugby84
Chris McKivat (8)
I'm a Tahs fan but I have to agree with this.
Members Section
John Thornett (49)
while i agree with everything you said is there anyone that Eben isn't in the head of?
Derpus
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Swinton doesn't get riled up by the opposition. He's just way too loose and reckless in his tackle technique. I certainly don't recall him being baited like Swain was playing for the Wallabies.
I still think Swinton has something to add to the Wallabies. His form against South Africa was brilliant and showed what he was capable of if he could keep from straying too far over the line.
You'd want to see a full, disciplined season of Super Rugby from him before you selected him though.
Probably a bit of bias but I'm not as fussed by Swain. He doesn't have anything several other players don't have.
Last edited:
Highlander35
Steve Williams (59)
You definitely don't need the probably there mate