KOB1987
John Eales (66)
Thanks for this, these are some interesting notes.
Why do you think Jones is soft? I am mainly commenting on his super form, and I thought he was much more consistent than Dempsey, and obviously has a much larger volume of work than Valetini. He is also better than both in the lineout, and from what I can see in maul defence. Happy to hear your thoughts on this - but I am steadfast in my opinion that Lukhan must go and now. Now that Bernard is cooked (thankyou Chek) Lukhan is my next major issue.
Liam Wright at 6 is something that I have proposed quite a bit with the emergence of McReight/Kibble coming through. I think he could make a tremendous 6 in the Dusatoir mould, and note that he played 6 for Easts on the weekend. I certainly think he COULD be a shot, but think its too early. To be clear though, I would much prefer him there rather than Lukhan.
Think you might be getting a bit carried away there. As has been discussed elsewhere comparing Foley's performance at altitude against the Saffas (which was an OK performance BTW) and behind a pack going nowhere, is not really comparable to a game against the Argies at Suncorp behind a dominant pack, and was a credible performance but hardly outstanding. I don't mind conceding that perhaps Lilo has his nose in front but we all know you're a serial Bernard basher and if you think you've seen the last of him in gold you are going to be severely disappointed.