Sydney8–19°C
NEWS
SPORT
ENTERTAINMENT
BUSINESS
LIFESTYLE
VIDEO
search
Bledisloe II Preview
Rugby
Lindfield Rugby Club fearful punishment meted out for allegedly paying player will cause club to die
DEAN RITCHIE, The Daily Telegraph
an hour ago
LINDFIELD rugby union fear their famous 100-year-old club will die if NSW Suburban Rugby Union impose “catastrophic” sanctions for illegally paying a player.
The Daily Telegraph revealed earlier this month that Lindfield – founded in 1919 – had been kicked out of the Kentwell Cup first division competition for breaching the game’s amateur status after allegedly paying a player $600 over three weeks. Lindfield lodged an appeal on Thursday night during a hearing with the NSWSRU board at Moore Park.
The NSWSRU integrity committee expelled the club from all five grades this season, banned the paid player – former West Harbour forward Tala Moli – for five years, deregistered the club’s recruitment manager, Pat Lang, for life, banned first grade coach Adam Coughlan for five years, told the club each grade would start next season on minus 10 competition points and placed Lindfield on a $10,000 bond for the next five years.
Nearly every club in suburban rugby union believe the punishment is ridiculously excessive. Respected litigation lawyer Daniel McGirr, acting for Lindfield, fronted the appeal’s hearing claiming the club could fold if the heavy-handed sanctions were upheld.
Tala Moli, the player who Lindfield allegedly paid.
McGirr argued Lang paid Moli without knowledge of the club’s board. He claimed the club’s directors were totally unaware of the minimal payment. Lang is a club volunteer who works as a real estate agent.
“If the sanctions currently handed down are maintained, Lindfield rugby union club will be ruined,” McGirr told The Saturday Telegraph. “The club will probably fold. That’s the thinking at the moment. Plus the club just doesn’t have the $10,000.
“It could be catastrophic for the club, which is nearly 100 years old. It would be a tragedy. We have already had players say if we start on minus 10 points next year they will be going to other clubs. And that would be a large exodus of players.
“The club vehemently denies making any payments to any player. The only issue left for the NSWSRU board to determine is whether the club was aware of the payments, made the payments or authorised such payments. There is simply no evidence of payments having been made by the club.”
One rival first division club committee member contacted The Saturday Telegraph to say: “It’s just subbies trying to flex muscle they don’t have. They should be more worried about all the clubs that are dropping out of their competitions than a $600 payment. Subbies may not be around in 20 years. The board is just on a power surge. They are lightweights trying to act like heavyweights. It’s sad and pathetic.”
McGirr won’t rule out taking the matter to NSW’s Supreme Court. The NSWSRU board is currently considering Lindfield’s appeal.
“We are confident that in the NSWSRU board’s judicial capacity justice will be done and that proper legal processes will be followed in making a determination,” he said.
NEWS
SPORT
ENTERTAINMENT
BUSINESS
LIFESTYLE
VIDEO
search
Bledisloe II Preview
Rugby
Lindfield Rugby Club fearful punishment meted out for allegedly paying player will cause club to die
DEAN RITCHIE, The Daily Telegraph
an hour ago
LINDFIELD rugby union fear their famous 100-year-old club will die if NSW Suburban Rugby Union impose “catastrophic” sanctions for illegally paying a player.
The Daily Telegraph revealed earlier this month that Lindfield – founded in 1919 – had been kicked out of the Kentwell Cup first division competition for breaching the game’s amateur status after allegedly paying a player $600 over three weeks. Lindfield lodged an appeal on Thursday night during a hearing with the NSWSRU board at Moore Park.
The NSWSRU integrity committee expelled the club from all five grades this season, banned the paid player – former West Harbour forward Tala Moli – for five years, deregistered the club’s recruitment manager, Pat Lang, for life, banned first grade coach Adam Coughlan for five years, told the club each grade would start next season on minus 10 competition points and placed Lindfield on a $10,000 bond for the next five years.
Nearly every club in suburban rugby union believe the punishment is ridiculously excessive. Respected litigation lawyer Daniel McGirr, acting for Lindfield, fronted the appeal’s hearing claiming the club could fold if the heavy-handed sanctions were upheld.
Tala Moli, the player who Lindfield allegedly paid.
McGirr argued Lang paid Moli without knowledge of the club’s board. He claimed the club’s directors were totally unaware of the minimal payment. Lang is a club volunteer who works as a real estate agent.
“If the sanctions currently handed down are maintained, Lindfield rugby union club will be ruined,” McGirr told The Saturday Telegraph. “The club will probably fold. That’s the thinking at the moment. Plus the club just doesn’t have the $10,000.
“It could be catastrophic for the club, which is nearly 100 years old. It would be a tragedy. We have already had players say if we start on minus 10 points next year they will be going to other clubs. And that would be a large exodus of players.
“The club vehemently denies making any payments to any player. The only issue left for the NSWSRU board to determine is whether the club was aware of the payments, made the payments or authorised such payments. There is simply no evidence of payments having been made by the club.”
One rival first division club committee member contacted The Saturday Telegraph to say: “It’s just subbies trying to flex muscle they don’t have. They should be more worried about all the clubs that are dropping out of their competitions than a $600 payment. Subbies may not be around in 20 years. The board is just on a power surge. They are lightweights trying to act like heavyweights. It’s sad and pathetic.”
McGirr won’t rule out taking the matter to NSW’s Supreme Court. The NSWSRU board is currently considering Lindfield’s appeal.
“We are confident that in the NSWSRU board’s judicial capacity justice will be done and that proper legal processes will be followed in making a determination,” he said.