Beer Baron
Phil Hardcastle (33)
A lot of humble pie to be eaten by reds fans on this forum
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk
Super Rugby Rd 5, - Reds v Jaguares - 18/3 - 7.40am Buenos Aires
- Thread starter Scrubber2050
- Start date
- Status
TSR
Andrew Slack (58)
I think it is great pity that Thorn and Cooper evidently couldn’t work together. At his best Cooper was a master at bringing out the best in players around him and, ironically this seems to be an environment that the earlier QC (Quade Cooper) would have thrived in.
Thorn deserves credit for having the belief in himself and his young charges to make the change.
dru
David Wilson (68)
The usual scenario here is for someone to take angst at my response to this sort of troll. Let's see what Morgan says: http://www.news.com.au/sport/rugby/...e/news-story/37740d531446cc1be68c41f4409a7dec
SouthernX
John Thornett (49)
Setting up tries is what Quade does...
Thorn didn’t want him in his squad because of his defense. Let’s hope Quade learns to defend in club rugby so we may see him one day back in a Reds jersey
dru
David Wilson (68)
Really positive stuff building from the Reds. The forwards as usual were brutal, but the backs are also looking capable. I'm not usually a fan of this "twin big boppers" centre selection thing, but man Kerevi and CF-S looked good. DP and Stewart as they came on look to need to build partnership - you'd think this will come.
The bench front row is the test of the scrum - full marks. Douglas beginning to show his doubters wrong.
I'm wondering if Korczyk is at 7 simply as Thorn has the loosies muscling up and he's making way for A Scott-Young. I'd imagine that Lian Wright is a more natural 7 and that Adam will need to fight for the 6 jersey. A bit like the story with Fagase, it show some real depth building creating difficulties for players with great promise.
Our kicking game was pants.
I'd like to see the halves settle incl the bench half combinations. There is room to build there.
Overall Thorn has stepped up big time from what I felt was an inauspicious start. Credit where it is due - crack on Brad.
The bench front row is the test of the scrum - full marks. Douglas beginning to show his doubters wrong.
I'm wondering if Korczyk is at 7 simply as Thorn has the loosies muscling up and he's making way for A Scott-Young. I'd imagine that Lian Wright is a more natural 7 and that Adam will need to fight for the 6 jersey. A bit like the story with Fagase, it show some real depth building creating difficulties for players with great promise.
Our kicking game was pants.
I'd like to see the halves settle incl the bench half combinations. There is room to build there.
Overall Thorn has stepped up big time from what I felt was an inauspicious start. Credit where it is due - crack on Brad.
Cha-ching!
Great work Reds.
This team is shaping up nicely. Plenty of belief and guts across the park.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
they are astonishing figures.
Zero_Cool
Arch Winning (36)
I think the reason the Kerevi - CFS partnership is more attractive than the normal 'big boppers' is that Kerevi is quite skilled for a 'big boppa' not as skilled as you'd like at 12, but gets the job done.
I think these last few games have cemented Douglas as the third lock. He's not bad but not brilliant -- he's been very hard working these last few games. I do think that's a little sad for Hockings and Blyth who are much closer than many would have through at the start of the season.
I'm not sure who is dropped next week for Higgers, I do ever think it's possible by the end of the season Smith and Higginbotham could find themselves under a lot of pressure for their spots. Timu, ASY (Angus Scott-Young), Wright and Korczyk have all shown they are capable of starting at the Super Rugby level.
For next week I think 100% Timu isn't playing 8 on those attacking scrums, he's just not quite good enough holding the ball at the back of the scrum when it's motoring along like it has been!
I did like the Stewart - Paia'aua combination it looked to have more fluidity to it, but they didn't have anywhere near enough ball to really be tested.
gel
Ken Catchpole (46)
I don't mind eating a slice or two.
Tastes fine at the moment, to be honest.
Great win - totally unexpected. Dare I start to dream again?
T
TOCC
Guest
I got on that as well, now waiting on the Tahs game for my Reds-Rebels multi, it was at $6.70 odds
redstragic
Alan Cameron (40)
just on the kerevi cfs partnership. my thoughts are that they compliment Jono's game best. Jono is our best at 10 in the 1st team we have.
Stewart and Duncan are young and will be the future. I read some quotes from Thorn during the week about managing his young players and how he would like them to have 15 year careers. He'd have a plan for them that they'd be aware of I rekon that would keep them keen as to put in for the team. When they came on today, they left nothing on the field. There was still a long way to go for them to play integral parts in sealing the win.
Stewart and Duncan are young and will be the future. I read some quotes from Thorn during the week about managing his young players and how he would like them to have 15 year careers. He'd have a plan for them that they'd be aware of I rekon that would keep them keen as to put in for the team. When they came on today, they left nothing on the field. There was still a long way to go for them to play integral parts in sealing the win.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Now I know why he's had few minutes. Quite a poor display from Hamish
redstragic
Alan Cameron (40)
If you ignore the 27 odd tackles including the pearler in the corner.
Sent from my SM-J710GN using Tapatalk
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Great win. It looks to me that we have a TEAM
Scrum dominant all game. The tight 5 are really a unit.
The setup for the win comes from theses blokes. Love to see it.
Kerevi last week and this week has played his best rugby for years !
Toua has been great at the back and Douglas was extra good.
Great to see Lucas and Ready contribute well.
Good to see the Smith boys play together - that must be special for them.
Scrum dominant all game. The tight 5 are really a unit.
The setup for the win comes from theses blokes. Love to see it.
Kerevi last week and this week has played his best rugby for years !
Toua has been great at the back and Douglas was extra good.
Great to see Lucas and Ready contribute well.
Good to see the Smith boys play together - that must be special for them.
T
TOCC
Guest
Stewart played 2nd half... Reds had 29% possession in the 2nd half as opposed to 57% in the first half....
In defence Stewart made 16 tackles/1miss in 40minutes the highest tackle count of either team, pretty bloody good effort if you ask me.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
27 - where is that count from
TSR
Andrew Slack (58)
The teams they have beaten either need to improve a lot or they won’t be there at the business end.I don't mind eating a slice or two.
Tastes fine at the moment, to be honest.
Great win - totally unexpected. Dare I start to dream again?
However, the Reds are winning games built in very solid foundations in defence and high levels of tenancity & effort. They are not giving silly penalties. They are working very hard off the ball.
Even their attack - whilst needing some polish and patience at times - is improving week by week.
Dream away I say. You (we) May still end up disappointed but these wins have been hard fought & well deserved.
Ignoto
Peter Sullivan (51)
Only player I thought who had a poor game was Nabuli. Maybe he doesn't use his feet in contact and just relies on his power and size to beat a man, but he never seems to live up to his hype. When Perese is fit, it'll be interesting to see who Thorn picks for the wings.
- Status