Shute Shield 2014

[Iluvmyfooty]

Theer ahs been a fair amount of discussion on here about the actions of the Uni winger on Saturday. Normally when Uni is discussed Bruce Ross is a good contributor. i would be interested in his observations of the incident giving a Uni point of view

 

[I like to watch]

Let's not focus on who he plays for,let's focus on his actions.
And, the processes that make him accountable.

 

[MACCA]

Theer ahs been a fair amount of discussion on here about the actions of the Uni winger on Saturday. Normally when Uni is discussed Bruce Ross is a good contributor. i would be interested in his observations of the incident giving a Uni point of view

Who was the player ? If its that bad, he should be outed me thinks.
I couldn't find the incident on Vimeo

 

[Dave Beat]

Who was the player ? If its that bad, he should be outed me thinks.
I couldn't find the incident on Vimeo

Worth finding it.
It was around the 20 minute mark in one of the halves

 

[Dave Beat]

Dave BeatDick Tooth (41)

Likes Received: 606

New

Manly s team list

http://www.manlyrugby.com.au/rugby-mainmenu-137

2nd grade looking strong with Mark returning to 9, and Malie in thecentres

 

[the coach]

Who was the player ? If its that bad, he should be outed me thinks.
I couldn't find the incident on Vimeo

Go back a few pages (p 45) -- I think I accidentally () outed him, assuming the team sheet was correct.

 

[Spieber]

http://sydneyunirugby.com.au/season/team-lists.html
Mr Rudd still listed on the wing, which I find disappointing - both of his actions were reprehensible and could have sparked an all in similar to Gloucester/Bath last weekend. Uni have a well earned rep for being smart arses but they are not thugs.

 

[Iluvmyfooty]

Dave BeatDick Tooth (41)

Likes Received: 606

New

Manly s team list

http://www.manlyrugby.com.au/rugby-mainmenu-137

2nd grade looking strong with Mark returning to 9, and Malie in thecentres

I'm looking forward to the clash of the 13's - Ingate v Hingano. Should be a very close encounter all over

 

[the coach]

http://sydneyunirugby.com.au/season/team-lists.html
Mr Rudd still listed on the wing, which I find disappointing - both of his actions were reprehensible and could have sparked an all in similar to Gloucester/Bath last weekend. Uni have a well earned rep for being smart arses but they are not thugs.

3 hyphens in 2nds -- is that a record?

 

[Dave Beat]

I'm looking forward to the clash of the 13's - Ingate v Hingano. Should be a very close encounter all over

To right, looking to make a day of it - 4 grades of high quality 3rd tier rugby.

 

[Retired Fatty]

I assume that the Nonu-Carling one is a pi**-take.....

 

[couldabeen]

I get the pretentious bit, But. I once coached a kid with two names. He did it because his mum was profligate with men but he wanted to give some honour to her most recent alliance whom he respected. (and who knows what else). Be careful. After she moved on, he did also. One name thereafter.

 

[Spieber]

At le

3 hyphens in 2nds -- is that a record?

2 are old family names rather than the two dads variety - a hangover from imperial times

 

[couldabeen]

At le
2 are old family names rather than the two dads variety - a hangover from imperial times

Yep - that too. What are you going to do? Check out the details of Lord Mountbatten. Some people like names, lots of them.
Would be an interesting study for some Sociology major.

 

[Done that]

So is it up to solely Wests?
I thought the rugby union may have also had a responsibility to ensure the game didn't see that?

Agree 100%, although as the SS is run by an organisation which has no employees, no website and to all intents and purposes doesn't exist, it would seem unlikely that the SRU will do anything. Having something called the SRU means that NSWRU can wash its hands of what occurs in SS, and over the years they've turned masterly inactivity into an art form - highly unlikely that the governing body in this state will do anything.

Clubs will rarely cite opposition players and it often leads to tit for tat citings. The law of the jungle applies.

If my memory serves me correctly, University cited a West player last year,Vaughan Lomax,for a punch.I recall he received
6 weeks suspension(?). Wests were one of the leading clubs at the time but I recall only won one of the following 6 matches.
Tit for tat may play a part in this situation perhaps, as I would suspect Wests would cite the offending player following this
nasty incident.

 

[Hugh Jarse]

Like many in the rugby world, we are waiting for a sibling of Adam Ashley-Cooper to marry a sibling of Adam Wallace-Harrison.

Will they be an Ashley-Cooper-Wallace-Harrison?

 

[Hugh Jarse]

<snip> West player last year,Vaughan Lomax <snip>

Where is Lomax this year? I don't think I have seen his name on the team lists, but think his dad is still listed as coaching at the Pirates.

 

[couldabeen]

Like many in the rugby world, we are waiting for a sibling of Adam Ashley-Cooper to marry a sibling of Adam Wallace-Harrison.

Will they be an Ashley-Cooper-Wallace-Harrison?

And will that mean 4 times less likely that the sire will pass the ball?

 

[boyo]

3 hyphens in 2nds -- is that a record?

Hooray Henries, chinless wonders?

 

[Moonball]

"Where is Lomax this year? I don't think I have seen his name on the team lists, but think his dad is still listed as coaching at the Pirates."

He is playing in France and his dad is no longer coaching at the Pirates. Lomax was the best Tight head scrummager in SS in 2013 now he is gone probably why the Pirates scrum struggled against Uni.