I like to watch
David Codey (61)
You must have stopped counting after their first 3 throws!
RWC 2015 Semi Final 2 - Australia v Argentina Twickenham, Monday 19 October, 2:45 AEDT
- Thread starter Lindommer
- Start date
- Status
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
Yes the world 15 selection will be interesting.
I'm with you - balance, and skill set of these 3 cover so many dynamics, in their positions played.
But as does.
Kaino / McCaw / Read - they also bring a balance, a different balance.
Both combo's can lay claim to World XV starters - it will be interesting.
Kaino & Read play allot looser than Fardy & Pocock / Hooper brings a varied game to McCaw because of his partners in crime.
teach
Trevor Allan (34)
I think some would disagree with you over that, like the SMH. But not me!!! I don't have a dog in this fight. I don't think it would have affected final results if it had been called forward.
I just reckon you guys were lucky George Ayoub wasn't sitting in the TMO box and asked to judge it. Who knows what could have happened!
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
Hooper 2 - I'd love to see the distance those 2 travelled in the game.
Micheal
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
Few things I took from the game:
- The uncalled not-straight calls everyones complaining about: I saw a few crooked throws, but I also didn't see Australia contest a lot of them. If we don't lift a jumper, its not a penalty. If it doesn't haven't a material effect on the game, its play on.
- Kuridrani. He's gone missing this World Cup, and aside from a few good games before it, I was never 100% convinced on him. I'm all for letting him play himself back into form, but next Super Rugby another 13 might play him out of the team. It'll be interesting to see how Kerevi develops next season.
- Sanchez. Wow. What a player. Surely the form 10 of the competition thus far, and I wonder if he'll be represented at all in the IRB Player of the Year nominees (Pocock, Nonu, ...?). Can't wait to see him and the likes of Matera and Cordero in the Super Rugby next year, the latter of which had an absolute cracker of a game. Such an electric runner of the ball.
- Izzy looking far from convincing, alongside Slipper. They'll both need to step up next weekend if selected. I thought Smith had a good impact off the bench, as did McCalman and TPN.
- Giteau's injury is likewise worrying. He's such a stabiliser in the back line and you can tell a lot of the team really look to him for leadership.
- The boys were exhausted. The last 10 minutes of the game was almost played at a walking pace. Neither team wanted to back down yet neither team had any juice in the tank. The next week will be crucial in terms of recovery. Light training and getting the boys mentally prepped is key.
What a game though, bring on next week. This will be a grand-final to go down in the history books.
- The uncalled not-straight calls everyones complaining about: I saw a few crooked throws, but I also didn't see Australia contest a lot of them. If we don't lift a jumper, its not a penalty. If it doesn't haven't a material effect on the game, its play on.
- Kuridrani. He's gone missing this World Cup, and aside from a few good games before it, I was never 100% convinced on him. I'm all for letting him play himself back into form, but next Super Rugby another 13 might play him out of the team. It'll be interesting to see how Kerevi develops next season.
- Sanchez. Wow. What a player. Surely the form 10 of the competition thus far, and I wonder if he'll be represented at all in the IRB Player of the Year nominees (Pocock, Nonu, ...?). Can't wait to see him and the likes of Matera and Cordero in the Super Rugby next year, the latter of which had an absolute cracker of a game. Such an electric runner of the ball.
- Izzy looking far from convincing, alongside Slipper. They'll both need to step up next weekend if selected. I thought Smith had a good impact off the bench, as did McCalman and TPN.
- Giteau's injury is likewise worrying. He's such a stabiliser in the back line and you can tell a lot of the team really look to him for leadership.
- The boys were exhausted. The last 10 minutes of the game was almost played at a walking pace. Neither team wanted to back down yet neither team had any juice in the tank. The next week will be crucial in terms of recovery. Light training and getting the boys mentally prepped is key.
What a game though, bring on next week. This will be a grand-final to go down in the history books.
drewprint
Dick Tooth (41)
The wider (read: everywhere other than AUS) reactions to these great results is just as satisfying as the wins themselves.
Cheated England out at scrum time. Robbed Wales during a period of 13 man cheating. Paid off Joubert for a 'match deciding' penalty to steal the game from Scotland. Scraped past Argentina after a 'forward' pass where Barnes was on our side the whole match.
Pathetic.
Cheated England out at scrum time. Robbed Wales during a period of 13 man cheating. Paid off Joubert for a 'match deciding' penalty to steal the game from Scotland. Scraped past Argentina after a 'forward' pass where Barnes was on our side the whole match.
Pathetic.
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
NRC correct
Test match rugby = scrum, or line out.
And we did contest some of them, gee a number of them went to the Puma's outside shoulder they were that wrong. Why contest if not policed??
The_Brown_Hornet
John Eales (66)
It's been gold, hasn't it? I so hope we win on the weekend so we can stick it right up dickheads like Lord Bald.
Thinker
Darby Loudon (17)
Obviously I'm biased but I thought we got hammered by Barnes.
Not only did the 50/50 calls go their way but the amount of non-calls was crazy. Not straights, collapsing mauls, offsides etc.
My fave was sometime in the second half Kurindrani got over the ball that the Argie had place. Once his hand hit the ball, the Argie (lying on the ground) picked it up and pulled it back into his chest. This happened 2 m directly infront of Jaco and maybe 4m directly infront of Barnes. We got penalized because Fardy then came in from the side. An argie sealed off two on the initial clean out, diving straight off his feet. 2 pens against Arg ignored then we got pinged. We had several off side as a result as Tevita going past the ball and it still a ruck, but Fardy marginally coming through the side got pinged.
EDIT: saw a gif of the incident on Twitter. The more I watch it the more stunned I am. https://pbs.twimg.com/tweet_video/CSMpyG_WwAATHWE.mp4
Not only did the 50/50 calls go their way but the amount of non-calls was crazy. Not straights, collapsing mauls, offsides etc.
My fave was sometime in the second half Kurindrani got over the ball that the Argie had place. Once his hand hit the ball, the Argie (lying on the ground) picked it up and pulled it back into his chest. This happened 2 m directly infront of Jaco and maybe 4m directly infront of Barnes. We got penalized because Fardy then came in from the side. An argie sealed off two on the initial clean out, diving straight off his feet. 2 pens against Arg ignored then we got pinged. We had several off side as a result as Tevita going past the ball and it still a ruck, but Fardy marginally coming through the side got pinged.
EDIT: saw a gif of the incident on Twitter. The more I watch it the more stunned I am. https://pbs.twimg.com/tweet_video/CSMpyG_WwAATHWE.mp4
Hawko
Tony Shaw (54)
Haven't yet watched my replay but live I don't recall getting all upset with our wingers' defence. Doubt AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper)'s misses will be an issue, he's normally very reliable. Probably a result of either:
- Wingers who were back to collect a possible kick suddenly having to get up into the line to cover a linebreak, or
- Wingers coming in on the umbrella and then having to try and realign once the outside break is on.
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
Read it the same - but fuck it was a good game.
Trusting the boys are in bath tubs of ice right now.
southsider
Arch Winning (36)
Pretty sure that's not correct at all........
Hugh Jarse
Rocky Elsom (76)
It's 4:30 am in London right now @Dave Beat.
I hope they're all tucked up in their beddie-byes, and not out on Burger Runs, Ice baths or the like.
Viking
Mark Ella (57)
A world XV back row is sure fun to speculate. I think Poey and Read would get in- they compliment each well. One tight and hard, the other loose and skillful. Then i'd probably chuck in Vermulen on the blindside flank cos he's a beast, or a 2011 Kaino. But then McCaw misses out (which is crazy that guys leadership alone might get him a spot) and Fardy is probably the form 6. Too many good back rowers.
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
Although not all of the English rugby press are down on Australia.
Paul Haywood thinks:
In the toughest of all the groups Australia beat both England and Wales before sauntering into a quarter-final against Scotland with more than a hint of complacency.
Kudos is due for their 20-point smashing of Stuart Lancaster’s side, which was inspired by attacking joie de vivre, and their narrower 15-6 win against Wales, which featured a heroic 10-minute goal-line stand when two Wallabies were in the sin-bin.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/ru...-Wallabies-have-shown-unity-and-maturity.html
As Brian Moore continues:
Australia and New Zealand's dominance comes down to one thing - they are simply more skilled than everyone else.
We have the two best teams in the world in the final next Saturday. We might beat them sporadically but the reason we don’t achieve a higher win rate is abundantly clear.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/ru...re-teams-fail-because-of-a-lack-of-skill.html
Paul Haywood thinks:
In the toughest of all the groups Australia beat both England and Wales before sauntering into a quarter-final against Scotland with more than a hint of complacency.
Kudos is due for their 20-point smashing of Stuart Lancaster’s side, which was inspired by attacking joie de vivre, and their narrower 15-6 win against Wales, which featured a heroic 10-minute goal-line stand when two Wallabies were in the sin-bin.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/ru...-Wallabies-have-shown-unity-and-maturity.html
As Brian Moore continues:
Australia and New Zealand's dominance comes down to one thing - they are simply more skilled than everyone else.
We have the two best teams in the world in the final next Saturday. We might beat them sporadically but the reason we don’t achieve a higher win rate is abundantly clear.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/ru...re-teams-fail-because-of-a-lack-of-skill.html
maxdacat
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
Flanking Eagle
Bob McCowan (2)
Love Pocock's warm down - Attenborough and a huge bag of protein powder!
- Status