Reds v Rebels MOM

[Sandpit Fan]

Here we go. Think I will watch again then put mine down.

 

[vidiot]

Reds, enough contributors that the following is a bit random.

3. James Slipper. Mountain of work.
2. Leroy Houston. Best game for ages, great hands.
1. Mike Harris. Sorry Coops, Faingles, Taps. He has an Aussie grandma!

Rebels - back to the rabbles.

3. Lachlan Mitchell
2. Cooper Vuna
1. I dunno. Scratching to get this far. Oh yeah - Phipps.

 

[lincoln]

Reds
3. Cooper
2. Genia
1. Harris

Rebels
3. Delve
2. Phipps
1. Mitchell
0. Sommerville (would have been 3 except for dropsies at very critical time)
-1. Rooney
-2. Chamberlain
-3. Mortlock (shocking 1st/unsighted 2nd - not near Wallaby std tonight)

 

[unsub god]

3- A. Fainga'a
2 - Slipper
1- Genia

 

[cyclopath]

Reds
3 Robinson
2 Ioane
1 Harris

rebels
3 Phipps
2 Mitchell
1 Delve

 

[GC]

Reds
3. Genia
2. Robinson
1. Adam WH

Rabels
3. Vuna
2. Sommerville (not for his try-scoring abilities)
1. Henderson

 

[Reddy!]

Reds:
3. AWH
2. Simmons
1. Daley

Unlucky: Davies, Cooper, Genia, Harris, Higgers - the forwards really did win us this game, they were immense, particularly the 2nd row. The Foxsports panel were critical of Davies on the wing but I think he is developing into one of the best all round wingers in the competition. Needs to improve his link play but is nearly there.

Rebels
3. Mitchell
2. Vuna
1. Sommerville

Unlucky: No one, 2nd row worst in the competition. Byrnes is a joke.

 

[kiap]

Reds:
3. Michael Harris
2. Beau Robinson
1. James Slipper

Rebels:
3. Cooper Vuna
2. Nick Phipps
1. Greg Somerville

 

[spectator]

Reds

3. Robinson
2. A Fainga'a
1. Wallace-Harrison

 

[Brumbies Guy]

Reds
3. Genia
2. Robinson
1. A. Fainga'a

Rebels
3. Vuna
2. Phibbs
1. Sommerville

 

[Johnny Blaze]

REDS
3-Houston
2-Robinson
1-A.Fainga'a

REBS
3-Sommerville
2-Phipps
1-Vuna

 

[Sandpit Fan]

Reds:

3. Beau Robinson - Link has made some good pickups to fill out the squad
2. Leroy Houston
1. Michael Harris - plenty of other contenders, but 2 tries gets the nod.

Rebels:
3. Nick Phipps
2. Cooper Vuna
1. Lachie Mitchell

 

[Moses]

3. Beau Robinson
2. Scott Higginbotham
1. Mike Harris
-1 Genia. Was truly awful service. Slow, innacurate, innefective. They showed a highlights package in the post game show which Horan and Martin gushed over, and even after they cut out his two absolute barry crockers he looked unable to make a decision and sloppy. Then there was his drop goal attempt..

3. Lachie Mitchell.
2. Phipps
1. Cooper Vuna

 

[rugbysmartarse]

Reds
3: Leroy (never thought I'd say that)
2: beau (or that)
1: ioane
I'd like to see Harris play 80 v an opposition that wasn't already beaten before being convinced

Rebs
3: vuna (looked good whenever he got the ball)
2: Phipps
1: Mitchell (did well shifted in 1 spot)

 

[topo]

Reds:
3. Beau
2. Slipper
1. Higginbum

Rebs
3. Phipps
2. Mitchell
1. Sommerville

 

[Croks]

Reds:
3. Genia
2. Houston
1. A. Fainga'a

 

[cyclopath]

I don't normally like to comment on others' opinion on these points things, but I am struggling to see how Genia is rated by some as best on field last night? I don't think he was as bad as Moses suggested, but neither was he at or near his best. Took some poor options that he got away with, due to the execrable nature of the opposition. Horan and Martin were completely ignoring any of his faults with their gushing at the end. He's still my choice as first pick 9 for the Wobbs, but he is not near top form yet.

 

[MrTimms]

3. Robinson
2. Leeroy
1. Quade

3. Phipps
2. Vuna
1. MItchell

 

[Jets]

Rebels

3, Delve
2, Phipps
1, Vuna

Reds

3, Beau
2, Cooper
1, AWH

 

[disco]

3. AWH - Did his best work when the Rebels were still having a go.
2. Houston
1. Higginbotham