Reds 2014
- Thread starter Troy
- Start date
- Status
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Well, he's off to the Rebels anyway
Scoey
Tony Shaw (54)
Jeebus! That's terrible. That's almost up around Yow Yeh's recovery time isn't it? Trying to think of a player that has come back from such a significant injury? Drew Mitchell springs to mind. That was a pretty horrific ankle injury. If he does come back, expect him to have the standard hamstring and calf injuries after.
I think the 18 months is more the expected timeframe for a full recovery. He should be running and available substantially before that if things go well.
It's similar to the Mitchell and Yow Yeh injuries. There are plenty of potential complications in the recovery and it could go much better or as happened with Yow Yeh, end your career.
In the AFL, Swans player Gary Rohan had a similar injury and returned to the side within a year.
It's similar to the Mitchell and Yow Yeh injuries. There are plenty of potential complications in the recovery and it could go much better or as happened with Yow Yeh, end your career.
In the AFL, Swans player Gary Rohan had a similar injury and returned to the side within a year.
Ignoto
Peter Sullivan (51)
His rushed rehabilitation left him undercooked and barely lasted a couple games after returning.
Yow Yeh is a similar story, but the treating docs in Perth stuffed up and he had complications due to incorrectly cleaning the wound and it got infected. He suffered because of that and was never right after a second round of surgery.
What makes Dom out for 18 months is, it's a 8-12 month recovery period which brings us to the end of Super rugby next year. So the Docs would be erring on the side of caution and say, miss next years games and focus on having the entire pre-season of 2015/16 under your belt.
Ignoto
Peter Sullivan (51)
So the recovery time Mitchell had didn't have an effect on his strength and conditioning especially on an area he's had problems before?
As I said, 18 months is drawn out. Just like Pocock's injury. Hypothetically, he could be right for the spring tour, but why risk it? It's the same for Dom, why rush it for a couple games at the end of next year?
Yeah, different situations though. Rushing back to try and make the RWC is a totally different situation to rushing back to try and play a few games of Super Rugby.
That said, I expect Shipperley will play by part way through next season.
qwerty51
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Of course, that's why his hammy blew.. My point was his ankle was ready to run/take contact on after 4 months. He just didn't have time to get conditioning done on the rest of the his body as he wasn't running. Shipperey will be 100% good to go in 6 months you'd think.
T
Train Without a Station
Guest
Thanks for the diagnosis Dr Qwerty. We'll pass it on the Dom.
Yes it was Dr. Richard Graham who mentioned the 12-18 months before he's back to his best. I'd say he should be good to go at the start of next year.
http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport...ng-ankle-surgery/story-fnii0lp2-1226972480319
http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport...ng-ankle-surgery/story-fnii0lp2-1226972480319
T
Train Without a Station
Guest
Mitchell also had recurring ankle issues FYI.
That seems to be common with this sort of injury.
Everything seems fine and they're up to full speed etc. but after a while new issues start showing up through normal use due to the invasive surgery, scar tissue, screws etc.
Ignoto
Peter Sullivan (51)
I agree it's different situations, I'm just pointing out there's absolutely no rush for Dom and hence the elongated recovery period than the 6 - 8 months people think it'd be. It's better for the medical team to say "12-18 months" and re-evaluate around the 8 month mark and see the progress (which will be around the start of the super rugby season). If he needs more time, fine, everyone was prepared for it and great if he doesn't.
Look at Lealiifano, similar injury and time frame and said 2013 didn't feel great in and around that injury. The Doctors aren't out there to push anyone back onto the field sooner than they should be (you think Pocock's surgeon isn't sweating bullets that his knee holds this time round?), there's a reason why they over-estimate recovery times.
Parse
Bill Watson (15)
Yep, not allowed to enter unless you have a mobile phone
- Status