Kalani Thomas has been great the last few weeks, really showing why the Reds have shown so much faith in him.
Kalani got noticeably better as the season went on, his first few games for UQ were far from memorable. Same for Nasser before his injury, he was showing improvement getting regular minutes playing a position he hadn't played prior to the Reds' switching him to #2.Yeah absolutely he performed extremely well noting the disruption at 10 for UQ, he took on a lot more responsibility and a big role for a 19yr old. He was copping some real criticism on these forums earlier this year so its good to see him developing like this.
As too does the idea of bringing young fellas into professional squads to accelerate their development.The idea of young fellas doing their time and earning their stripes in QPR has merit.
Absolutely, training within a professional squad is a great opportunity for these young lads. Not saying they should only get picked up from QPR , but there is value in them playing QPR.As too does the idea of bringing young fellas into professional squads to accelerate their development.
Your first point is key and a lot of it revolves around their conditioning.My final notes on the QPR Grand Final that no one asked for:
1. UQ defensive structure, discipline and conditioning were outstanding. GPS didn't really offer much in attack (more on that to come) but regardless the UQ team never looked like giving up the fight.
2. UQ set piece was more than just solid this year, their lineout disruption especially at key moments was important and dominant.
3. GPS offered little in attack. I would have liked to see Aubrey on the bench to add some attacking variation, and would have replaced Vuta earlier. Richards made a comment in the pre-game about not letting UQ get away like Wests did. but they went out with the same side and game plan as the Wests game, and got the same result. Except this time couldn't come back.
GPS will need to do some serious recruiting for next year. Losing Gicquel will be massive, he's their standout attacking forward. Their other core forwards Richards, Byrne, Bartlett, Tualima (and Gorman) all play a similar starchy style game. They'll need a rangey backrrower who can break the line or create opportunities.
UQ - Prems a well oiled machine and Reggies are about to get even stronger. Colts 2 - Joint Premiers and Colts 3 knocked out in Preliminary Final that suggest the depth (as always) coming through is for real.Thought I would put a bit of a breakdown on my perception of the clubs and the seasons they had. both in press and across the grades.
UQ Obviously one of the best run clubs in the country. long term stability in coaching and excellent recruiting. Lets be honest won 1st grade by some distance and made the reserve grade grant final. The only very minor concerns for UQ are the colts did not make finals and the also the womens. 8.5/10
GPS had a great year making the GF in Prems, Womens and Colts 1 with the Colts one winning the premiership. They also took out the 4th grade GF. 8/10
Brothers Probably the first of the clubs that will be disappointed with the return. Brothers had a team that finished the comp stacked with Reds players and with the addition of Joe Powell looked good. Only just missed the GF and for a club as well resourced they only got the chocolates in 3rd grade. I know this is a low grade but compared to expectations and squad 6/10.
Wests What might have been for Wests. Had GPS dead to rights in the Semi Final and did not have the fitness to finish the job. Badly underperformed in Colts missing finals compared to the team they assembled and a low finish in Womens is not reflective of the talent. 6/10
Bond For mine the biggest disappointment of the season. Defence was terrible given they were my early season pick to made the big dance the play did not meet the cattle. Made finals in Womens, 2nd’s Colts 1and 2. They exhibit good depth but should have done better. 4/10
Easts Went from eh Penthouse to the other house this year but did have a strong finish to the season when the Reds came back unfortunately there poor start gave up to much ground to the teams in front. The Womens and Colts 1 got the wins 5/10
Souths Showed some improvement early and finished the season poorly overall as a club they had a good season with 2nd through 6th grade all making finals winning both 2nd grade and 6ths. The Colts played better than the results and the Womens is progressing organically. Next year will be interesting as they probably need a couple of quality recruits to augment a deep club. 6/10
Sunnybank There are some real issues at the bank. The top grade team was very competitive and they struggled for numbers at training and lower down. Only the Women made finals after being dominant for so long. It is not a good sign that the Colts finished last. 3/10
Norths Despite only 2 wins this season there are some good signs at Norths. The program is building and you can see some good structures in place. Hopefully the other clubs do not pillage the playing group. 5/10
Special thanks to Jets for doing the tipping comp again this year.
I would speculate that that be Nick Baker , however , if he can stay fit and healthy , it could be a case of perfect timing for Lachie Howse to take the spot vacated by Matt Gicquel. His form through the Colts 1 Finals was very good and looked like he might be ready for his shot despite being a little under whelming through the best part of the regular seasonMy final notes on the QPR Grand Final that no one asked for:
1. UQ defensive structure, discipline and conditioning were outstanding. GPS didn't really offer much in attack (more on that to come) but regardless the UQ team never looked like giving up the fight.
2. UQ set piece was more than just solid this year, their lineout disruption especially at key moments was important and dominant.
3. GPS offered little in attack. I would have liked to see Aubrey on the bench to add some attacking variation, and would have replaced Vuta earlier. Richards made a comment in the pre-game about not letting UQ get away like Wests did. but they went out with the same side and game plan as the Wests game, and got the same result. Except this time couldn't come back.
GPS will need to do some serious recruiting for next year. Losing Gicquel will be massive, he's their standout attacking forward. Their other core forwards Richards, Byrne, Bartlett, Tualima (and Gorman) all play a similar starchy style game. They'll need a rangey backrrower who can break the line or create opportunities.
Thanks PhilGreat analysis Happyman,
My only issue is with the 5/10 for Norths. 50% is a passing grade at most universities. I don't know how Norths can receive a pass mark when they're stuck at the bottom of the ladder, again.
You can pretty much copy and paste that commentary about 'the program is building and you can see good structures in place' for the last maybe 10 years at the club. In fact I reckon if you went into the last few years of the Premier Rugby conversations on this forum, you'd find that quote paraphrased each year.
I don't want to shit on the club but what is it going to take for them to change? Does there need to be a whole re-brand to try and refresh everything? Do away with the Norths Eagles and start a new club. They haven't been short of decent coaches or guys with good ideas in the last few years, but everyone seems to throw the toys out after 2 seasons and leave the place to burn.
Curious how you came to the assessment that South's conditioning was not just average or poor, but "very poor".UQ - Prems a well oiled machine and Reggies are about to get even stronger. Colts 2 - Joint Premiers and Colts 3 knocked out in Preliminary Final that suggest the depth (as always) coming through is for real.
GPS - Prems were disappointing in the big one. Colts 1 were a class act and played a very old fashioned and entertaining brand of Rugby - that if it is nurtured with the personnel that they have , and with Coach Arnold , has a chance to stay relevant in Prems over the next 2 or 3 seasons assuming a lot of these guys stick
Brothers - Hey love them or hate them they have a genuine tribal culture that takes them long into the fight. They'll address their Finals failures this year (by their standards) and they'll be back as the competition's Dick Dastardly next year
Bond - Agree Prems was a disappointing result
Easts - Seem to have quickly transformed into a Toiling Tiger vibe that will be in games but lack big time gamers when their Reds guys aren't around. No Asiata , Van Nek and Mowen and its a bit of a struggle.
Souths - Conditioning right through the Club is very poor. Not dynamic enough and quite simply just get run off their feet. Not enough focus or demand on a performance culture from top to bottom. Too many physically and mentally soft good time guys.
Sunnybank - Olympus has fallen. It seems as though they have been unravelling ever since Gavin Head bid adieu
Norths - A trendy darling that everyone wants to see do well but deep down no one really cares whether they do or they don't despite the piety. Biggest challenge is that they drag this land of opportunity vibe like an Albatross around their neck which might mean those that are looking for the land of opportunity have already one foot out the door when they arrive where that stepping stone does indeed get them to that land of opportunity
Yes ...well done to Reserve Grade ....BUT ....for the personnel they had in Prems and Colts they should have done a lot better than what they did and Happy Man can make a point ( and a fair one ) that they improved over the course of the season (in Colts) ....BUT .....their style of play was one out and hammer boring and that suits a slow tempo that benefits an unfit team that is carrying too much ballast , because , its all they can do.Curious how you came to the assessment that South's conditioning was not just average or poor, but "very poor".
As someone affiliated with the club, if you managed to catch the Semi Final and Grand Final in Reserve Grade, you would have seen a side that came from behind at halftime in both games to run over the top of Bond and Uni, both teams that are deemed to be "conditioned".
Yeah. Not much chop either. Colts as well. Too heavy....too slow.^ If you think Souths conditioning was poor, what are your thoughts on Wests?