@Purce, my only question is why does University have so many numbers? I'm surprised, because it would be hard to star! From what I've seen, University hasn't got a strong club culture in Colts (not grades) as there so many numbers.
Mate you can't put it down to one or two things. I think the club is different things to different people and it appeals to all types of rugby players/coaches/managers/supporters. It's a surprisingly diverse group for what you would expect from a University club.
There is a VERY strong "Club first" culture at UQ which I think brings in, and keeps, the right type of people(for our particular club). Those who put themselves before the club tend not to last long at Stade de Heavie. I guess what I'm trying to say is that we tend to attract good "clubmen" who buy into what we stand for (and our goals) as a club, as a result they tend not to lose their sh!t if they aren't in the top team. As an example we had a guy who was Aus schoolboy rep who played 3rd & 2nd grade for years happily because he enjoyed contributing to the most important goal of the club. ----- It's funny because this is something you rarely hear associated with Uni but this attitude the very heart and soul of the club and is spoken about on a weekly basis.
The culture is never going to be as strong in colts as it is in grades, mainly due to time spent together, but from my dealings with the colts (and their performances at club nights) they're a tight nick group who respect the club and enjoy being together.
Obviously the Uni and colleges attract a number of younger players as well. My understanding though is that quite often the college blokes don't come down till they've finished college because their comp runs at a similar time of the year.
We can't pretend the recent success of the club doesn't attract players. Nor can we pretend the academy doesn't attract players looking for that sort program. This is the thing easiest for people to see from the outside, so I guess that's why it is often a source of debate.
I also think having the current Reds captain and recent Wallabies captain Horwill has had a positive effect on recruitment. On top of that the players and supporters see that guys like him, Sharpe, Moore, Chapman, Chibba, McDuling, Owen, Harris, Lance, Morahan, Foley always down at games whenever they're in town/don't have a game. I think this reinforces in the players just how much the club means to a lot of people. I think it's also fair to say that all those players are pretty highly regarded both on and off the pitch which sends the right message to players and prospective players alike.
There are many other reasons but I'd say these are some of the main points.
Apologies if this post is a bit all over the shop, I was wide awake after 2 games of touch when I started and I'm struggling to keen my eyes open now.