NSW AAGPS 2025 (banter and commentary)

[The Chairman]

Sure did this week!

 

[The Kick Chaser]

Did anyone else see Shore number 12s punch. Disgraceful act. He should serve a hefty suspension if the AAGPS takes these matters seriously.

You might be reffering to something else, but what I think your talking about is when the New boy was grabbing and holding on to the Shore players Jersey and the Shore player hit his arm away. How does that deserve anything....

 

[Wingdog]

I watched the last couple of weeks at Joeys, Like a few people on this, I always seek to sit in the same place. There is another on this forum that I generally sit with a few years older.

A good summary, thankyou for sharing. I was also at the game at HH. It's clear to me if Joey's don't make changes they'll struggle with all games. The forward pack, with the exception of some key players, isn't performing, or working together as a team. With a 2nds team behind them putting 50 plus points on some good teams in recent weeks, it suggests that Joeys haven't picked the best line up for the 1sts, with particular focus on the front and back rows. Sticking to something that's not working will hurt their chances for the rest of the competition. Kings were a great team and played to Joey's weakness through the forward pack, putting added pressure on the back line. As well as reviewing and making some player changes, coaching styles must come in to why 2 teams under the same roof are playing such different styles of rugby. I wonder if we're seeing a scenario play out where the 2nds team of the school is possibly stronger then their 1sts. I'm sure this isn't the intention of the coaches selecting the teams. Some tough decisions ahead.... All things aside, it was a great day of rugby and again boys from both schools should be commended for the way they conducted themselves. Wishing the boys all the best for the next game, unfortunately I won't be at the next one so looking forward to the commentary in the chat, pre and post games.

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

he played 8. I think he is a lock not an 8, I’ve said that for 4 years now and i’ve seen nothing to change my view.

Fair enough. Also something just as rare.

How tall would he be? He’s big at this level but the bare minimum at pro level is 195cm but realistically 200cm if you’re not Brad Thorn.

Reminds me of Talataina

 

[PigSkin]

Joeys 1’s were flat on Saturday. A bit like Kings the week before. Hopefully something changes otherwise I see them battling Scots for second last. However never write off The Joeboys.

The 16A’s game was a cracka at Hunters Hill. Unfortunately the Kings lads played uphill against Joeys who received the home ground advantage…..maybe a bit to often.

 

[fortheloveofthegame]

Ghattas was Joeys best forward but he is playing out of position, i’d play him at 2 and bring up the 7 from the 2’s. But the back row isn’t the problem, the other tight five players are a real issue, under size for this level and I would say not mobile or skilful enough to make up for it. The reason why the seconds are dominating though is a combo of a decent team and a weak seconds comp (the natural outcome of other schools development programs ). add in much better coaching in the seconds particularly in terms of man management and a clear picture forms.

 

[fortheloveofthegame]

Sure did this week!

wow, impressive. i am surprised you picked a Joeys tight 5 player, they were on skates all day.

 

[The President]

Trying a Meat Pie From Every School
Part 3: Newington

Apparently they don’t believe in pies in the Co-Ed world…

 

[bigbaldpauline]

Kings vs Joeys

unreal atmosphere and geat place to watch footy. young finn hannion and ed garcia the 7 for joeys tore the kings 2s apart.

1st xv great game and contast minto wasted on the wing i feel, kings 1-15 all played exceptional espicelly there young 7. noticed sayer running the tee any idea why he wasn't playing, also update risati and why wasnt sayer plaing ?

 

[Rugbynbeers]

Kings vs Joeys

unreal atmosphere and geat place to watch footy. young finn hannion and ed garcia the 7 for joeys tore the kings 2s apart.

1st xv great game and contast minto wasted on the wing i feel, kings 1-15 all played exceptional espicelly there young 7. noticed sayer running the tee any idea why he wasn't playing, also update risati and why wasnt sayer plaing ?

Sawyer sustained a ankle injury last week, poor kid can’t catch a break.

 

[JoeBoar03]

I’d even go so far as to say this strike was much worse then that at Bellevue hill and Stanmore in round 1. The sheer malice behind the punch was something else. Us old boys were extremely unhappy.

 

[The President]

As a Shore fan that was one of the toughest trips to Stanmore I have had in a long time. Since 2022, It seems to be a pattern of coming away with scrappy wins or getting smashed when we visit NC. Was very disappointed watching that game. Riverview at Stirling Bridge on Thursday 3:15 will without a doubt be the game of the round. The rivalry between these mighty schools has been brewing for the last couple of years in the Rugby and the Rowing. Whenever these 2 play something special always happens. Shore upset in 2023 at this exact same fixture and Bousie’s last minute heroics at the swamp in 2024 are the first games that come to mind when I think about these 2 schools. If you’re free, come down to Northbridge. This one won’t disappoint.

 

[Howard_Clayton123]

Wanted to write a report for the 3rd XV comp, especially Riverview 3rd XV vs Grammar 1st XV. Tough loss for the old sgs boys, losing 28-5. I think there were a lot more positives than what the scoreline depicts. The year 12s are looking especially weak this year, so many year 11 and 10 boys are getting a good run. I think no. 12 Archie platt (Reece Lightning) should be commended for his hard running and grit on the defensive side. No 8 Howard Clayton also had a standout performance despite a pretty lackluster forward pack, so ultimately bright future for 2026.

 

[Here for the advice]

Based on his play he might not be there - a tough day at the office but a poor game for an inexperienced 12 but also no need for a strike…..

 

[The President]

Looking at the video it appears he has an open palm and not a fist. Don’t think the judiciary will be up in arms about this one

 

[Newingtonga15]

Solid shot from News 17 and then Shores 12 strikes him twice in the head. Hmmm

 

[gothenewboys]

Not a whole lot in it - bit of push and shove and the game continued. Play on for me.

The fight in the second xv at stanmore was certainly more concerning

 

[Handsonheadandblowinhard]

Ghattas was Joeys best forward but he is playing out of position,

spot on re tight 5. Watched the last 2 games and both New and Kings had monstrous front rows who you would expect to tire early in second half given pace of games, but didn’t. Maybe its a bit easier when running pods? in any case, they maintained decent mobility and critically, made good metres over the advantage line in their carries. Unfortunately, the Joeys front rowers, whilst courageous and hard working, were not impactful in carries. tight five also need to be better on the clean out.

hope the boys find some answers against Scots this Thurs. Was tough to see their heads down. separately, great job from the cheer captains in the Joe boys mob. Better energy and volume this round than the New fixture. Though the Kings boys cheering did their team proud as well.

assume that Kynan Hart is carrying an injury - any word when he is expected back?

 

[Maul of Duty]

After watching the Kings forwards in action yesterday it will be a great hit out with Newington

 

[Maul of Duty]

General game impact. Contribution to the team.

After watching all the games, I think Perrett and Lavercombe should be in that list.