• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

NSW AAGPS 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
Newitonga

Newitonga

Larry Dwyer (12)
thebigone said:
-Hartman
-Phillips
-Tancred
-mason
-graham
-carter
-grova
-conna
-dempsey
-saunders
-osborne
Click to expand...
Quite a lot of those boys are going into year 12 now. How do you think that will effect the 2025 season for Riverview not having many boys with experience in the 1st competition.
 
T

thebigone

Bob McCowan (2)
TheMaulester said:
Quite a lot of those boys are going into year 12 now. How do you think that will effect the 2025 season for Riverview not having many boys with experience in the 1st competition.
Click to expand...
i wouldnt be too concerned there are some really strong boys in the upcuming 16a's.Theyve got some quality footy players who im hoping to see feature on the bench for some 1s and 2s games
 
Lindommer

Lindommer

Simon Poidevin (60)
Staff member
Dunno about that. Two things:

1. Tony Boyd lamented the demise of rugby in government high schools, and especially mentioned Tony Hannon at High. This is a very astute observation, rugby NEEDS numbers in all high schools to keep a wide and solid foundation in grassroots participation.

2. The article mentioned a few names of quality rugby players coming out of Catholic schools, but not one from a Jesuit institution.

One could consider this a very "catholic" comment from Tony.
 
DropGoal

DropGoal

Larry Dwyer (12)
Lindommer said:
Dunno about that. Two things:

1. Tony Boyd lamented the demise of rugby in government high schools, and especially mentioned Tony Hannon at High. This is a very astute observation, rugby NEEDS numbers in all high schools to keep a wide and solid foundation in grassroots participation.

2. The article mentioned a few names of quality rugby players coming out of Catholic schools, but not one from a Jesuit institution.
Click to expand...

“Astute observation”?

It’s like the most generic / obvious answer ever .. Everyone knows the game needs to grow in state schools .. It’s like the Number 1 solution everyone mentions … He should change his name to Br Obvious .
 
Lindommer

Lindommer

Simon Poidevin (60)
Staff member
I think Tony Boyd was subtlely bringing to his fellow private school rugby administrators' attention there's more to the game than winning an arms race in the various GPS, CAS, ISA or whatever competitions. From what most of us here on G&GR know these administrators couldn't give a fuck about the health of grassroots rugby as long as their particular school's doing well. As much as I like Newington as an institution, their rugby program is a classic example of a champion Firsts, and As, and bugger all below. I was appalled to learn from the New assistant coach most of this year's First XV are signed up for NRL clubs; if New, for example, had healthy numbers all the way down to Hs (they don't), one would hope a goodish number of those lower players would go on to Subbies and/or grade rugby. Please don't think I'm anti-New, it's an example I know a bit about where a wealthy private school skims off the cream to the detriment of local grassroots clubs.

Tony Boyd is keenly aware of the need for a wide base of the rugby pyramid, no more. Give him credit for that.
 
Last edited:
M

Masked Crusader

Ward Prentice (10)
GPSlads said:
“Astute observation”?

It’s like the most generic / obvious answer ever .. Everyone knows the game needs to grow in state schools .. It’s like the Number 1 solution everyone mentions … He should change his name to Br Obvious .
Click to expand...
How many GpS Championship/premierships or Shute shield have you won?
 
S

SICInsider

Banned
Lindommer said:
I think Tony Boyd was subtlely bringing to his fellow private school rugby administrators' attention there's more to the game than winning an arms race in the various GPS, CAS, ISA or whatever competitions. From what most of us here on G&GR know these administrators couldn't give a fuck about the health of grassroots rugby as long as their particular school's doing well. As much as I like Newington as an institution, their rugby program is a classic example of a champion Firsts, and As, and bugger all below. I was appalled to learn from the New assistant coach most of this year's First XV are signed up for NRL clubs; if New, for example, had healthy numbers all the way down to Hs (they don't), one would hope a goodish number of those lower players would go on to Subbies and/or grade rugby. Please don't think I'm anti-New, it's an example I know a bit about where a wealthy private school skims off the cream to the detriment of local grassroots clubs.

Tony Boyd is keenly aware of the need for a wide base of the rugby pyramid, no more. Give him credit for that.
Click to expand...
That is pretty rich - if that was the point he was making - because Joeys started the arms race, well before Kings, Scots, Newington and more recently Shore perfected it.
 
The Ghost of Raelene

The Ghost of Raelene

Simon Poidevin (60)
Lindommer said:
Dunno about that. Two things:

1. Tony Boyd lamented the demise of rugby in government high schools, and especially mentioned Tony Hannon at High. This is a very astute observation, rugby NEEDS numbers in all high schools to keep a wide and solid foundation in grassroots participation.

2. The article mentioned a few names of quality rugby players coming out of Catholic schools, but not one from a Jesuit institution.

One could consider this a very "catholic" comment from Tony.
Click to expand...
And this means what to the Wallabies? It's an angled pat on the back article.

If anyone from that article should feel aggrieved it's the Christian Brothers since it gives a little mention of them in NSW but completely brushed Nudgee & Gregory Terrace.

I don't like to throw barbs in here as it just becomes a shit throwing contest but Joeys didn't have a player get in a game at the WC. That Jesuit institution did.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top