They have definitely come up short this year but as you've mentioned before TWAS the criticism is bit short sighted. If the NRC had started last year everyone would be complaining that the Stars were too good. Appart from the fact that almost all their Waratahs are either injured or have been upgraded to starting Wallabies, they have lost many of their 1st 2nd and 3rd grade locks to overseas or injuries. Looking the teams they fielded this year in SS you wonder why players in 3rd and 4th grade are selected for the stars swuad and other better players have missed out. They are truly scraping the bottom of the barrel which only goes to show the true depth of their program. I'm not a Uni supporter, I go for any team that plays against them, but I don't understand the tall poppy syndrome and why everyone wants them to be dropped, their performance in the last decade shows that they are a tier above SS and likely the rest of club rugby around Australia. As well as that at least they changed their name, can't say the same for the Vikings.