I don't think Croft is a bad player, he;s actually pretty good. Just maybe not the type of player you want to start the first test. It's going to be a complete shit fight for the first 60 minutes and the Lions will need every able body to get the breakdowns. Having one less player who can do the donkey work will make a hell of a difference.
Best might have been the answer as he does tremendous work at the breakdown, but given his throwing I wouldn't want to see him anywhere near the test side. Losing Healy was also a blow to our breakdown work.
But generally on Croft I wouldn't be too disappointed if he was picked. In general the back row players have been fantastic. It was the most competitive area just to get into the initial squad and the quality of players available is immense. Even Warburton is finding some form so other than a natural Irish loyalty I'll be happy with whoever is picked in the backrow.
I certainly can't say the same of a lot of other positions. I would be worried seeing any of Farrell, Barritt, Wade, Best, Ben Youngs, Ian Evans, Stevens etc. either in a starting lineup or coming onto the field with the scores close. I'd add Williams to that list also but thankfully his was a one night only gig.