The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
I love the ‘idea’ of a 12 team comp with everyone getting parochial about their team but we have to be realistic. We still need a competition that is quality of you are to genuinely develop players. We produce enough talent to be a consistent top 5 nation in the world. Our problem is the lack of top level Rugby they play once they leave school to the age of 23-25 when we want to see them establish themselves as potential internationals.
If we have diluted comp all they are doing is bullying the comp again and not growing. The U20s in league produced nothing if you consider how many players it had involved. All the top level talent was straight into the NRL squads and played a handful of games. Almost every kid got a spot, backpack, shorts and got sold the dream.
I’ve always been a proponent of a Super Rugby A, along side Super Rugby 20s. It should be hard to make these teams. If you take out all the Wallabies you’d have 10-15 spots in each squad to fill with kids and the best of clubland. The U20s then provides a selection trial for the Aus U20s.
If we have diluted comp all they are doing is bullying the comp again and not growing. The U20s in league produced nothing if you consider how many players it had involved. All the top level talent was straight into the NRL squads and played a handful of games. Almost every kid got a spot, backpack, shorts and got sold the dream.
I’ve always been a proponent of a Super Rugby A, along side Super Rugby 20s. It should be hard to make these teams. If you take out all the Wallabies you’d have 10-15 spots in each squad to fill with kids and the best of clubland. The U20s then provides a selection trial for the Aus U20s.
Last edited: