Chek will pick the team for the French test with both eyes on the Irish game so I think he'll probably stick with nearly the same starters. But there is something amiss with the group.
Frankly I'd be flicking Sio, Moore, Hooper (if McMahon is fit then Poey to 7 and Sean to 6), Genia for Phipps, Speight and TK. Moore's tenure should be over.
I'd drop Robinson off the bench altogether as he has done nothing at all and bring Alan A on for Keps at 45minutes. Kepu has not been playing very well at all. .Same with Skelton (gone totally).. Really think of Folau at 13 and DHP at 15
Some big changes are needed IMO
Tbh I think Moores been playing really well of late. He's been making a truckload of tackles and has been quite damaging with ball in hand (to me that's remarkable considering his sprint looks like a chafing-affected jog).
Sio hasn't been killing it but Scotland was his best game in a while. Didn't give away too many scrum penalties which has been a flaw of his recently and he was very good with ball in hand. It doesn't help that his replacements, Robertson and Slipper, have been not-much and quite bad respectively. He's still our best option.
Genia and Phipps I'm indifferent about, I'd keep TK as his forms been pretty good bar that missed tackle and he provides a bit of much needed starch and straight running in the backline. One thing I've noticed since his return is how much him straightening the attack provides space on the outside. I think Kerevi is often prone to stepping outside and trying to burn his defender - this can be devastating but it also soaks up space for other opportunities.
To round off my disagreements with you Scrubber - I'm not sure about dropping Speight. He hasn't been great but he's been serviceable. He provides he Horne option on the wing - strong runner, strong defender and additional flanker to secure the ball in wider channels. I think he's been good enough to be retained, especially considering the other options aren't great or inexperienced.
As for Kepu we must be watching different games. I think he's been fantastic. He's such a strong ball carrier and is very strong in the scrums. He won't be stopped or challenged for a good while, although AAAs development is very promising.
We agree on Skelton though. He can fuck right out of the 23 and spend six months eating sashimi and doing sprints.